Tailored Access Operations 2007

Open PDF
Creating agency: NSA National Security Agency (US)
Document date: 2007-01-08
Pages: 20
Genre: slides
Banner:
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL

This NSA document describes the Tailored Access Operations (TAO) division, which conducts sophisticated cyber operations to penetrate and maintain persistent access to target networks globally through both remote exploits and physical interdiction methods. The presentation outlines TAO's organizational structure, mission capabilities across telecommunications and data networks, development of hardware/software implants for devices ranging from servers to SCADA systems, collaboration with HUMINT partners for physical access operations, and specialized divisions focused on exploiting telephony systems, computer networks, and developing tools for computer network attack and exploitation.

Long Description:
This NSA presentation reveals the sprawling infrastructure of Tailored Access Operations (TAO), the agency's elite hacking unit tasked with penetrating the world's most sensitive computer networks and telecommunications systems. TAO's mission, stated with remarkable candor, is to "sustain a deep, persistent, and pervasive presence on critical target networks" and to "aggressively scale" its capabilities for computer network operations (CNO). The document lays bare the agency's ambitions to subvert virtually every category of network device—servers, workstations, routers, phone switches, even industrial control systems—through a combination of remote software exploits and physical interdiction operations conducted in partnership with human intelligence operatives. The organizational chart reveals a sophisticated division of labor spanning multiple specialized branches. The Telecommunications Network Technologies (TNT) group develops methods to manipulate phone networks including GSM, 3G, and VoIP systems, while also targeting SCADA energy management systems and video communications platforms. Meanwhile, the Data Network Technologies (DNT) division focuses on developing software implants and remote access techniques for computers, with explicit missions to "Deny, Destroy, Degrade, Disrupt, Manipulate, Mislead, and Collect against enemy targets." The Access Technologies & Operations unit (ATO) conducts "expeditionary" physical access operations worldwide, working with FBI and international intelligence partners to deploy hardware implants when remote hacking proves insufficient. The Persistence Division specializes in firmware-level compromises that survive system reinstalls and operate "covertly without any indication of their presence." What emerges is a portrait of an intelligence apparatus that has moved far beyond targeted surveillance of specific threats into wholesale compromise of global communications infrastructure. The document's references to automation, scalability, and maintaining "a large number of accesses" suggest mass exploitation capabilities rather than precision intelligence gathering. TAO's collaboration with Five Eyes partners (USA, UK, Canada, Australia, New Zealand) indicates these capabilities are shared among allied intelligence agencies. The casual discussion of computer network attack capabilities alongside intelligence collection blurs the line between espionage and offensive cyber warfare, while the targeting of industrial control systems and energy management platforms raises profound questions about whether these tools could be weaponized against civilian infrastructure. The presentation's matter-of-fact tone about subverting the security of telecommunications networks and "public infrastructures" reveals an agency operating with virtually no technical or ethical constraints.
Programs:
ATM, GENIE

People mentioned:
-

Countries:
-

Tags:
Tailored Access Operations, Computer Network Exploitation, Computer Network Attack, offensive cyber operations, Five Eyes, FVEY, intelligence sharing, network penetration, supply chain attacks, persistent access, persistent malware, remote operations, remote access, Remote Operations Center, software implants, hardware implants, firmware exploitation, endpoint access, network compromise, telecommunications espionage, phone switches, GSM, 3G networks, GPRS, UMTS, VoIP exploitation, ISDN, SMS interception, MMS, geolocation, metadata collection, scada, industrial control systems, energy, critical infrastructure, Siemens, Areva, ABB, programmable logic controllers, PLC, intelligent relays, substation SCADA, video teleconference, webcams, Skype, physical access, interdiction, off-net, on-net operations, humint, fbi, expeditionary operations, covert access, Close Access Operations, isolated network, hard targets, Data Network Technologies, DNT, Telecommunications Network Technologies, TNT, Access Technologies Operations, ATO, Mission Infrastructure Technologies, Persistence Division, firmware implants, software-based capabilities, reverse engineering, malware development, zero-day exploits, vulnerability exploitation, vulnerabilities, network shaping, traffic shaping, target development, requirements targeting, GENIE operations, automated exploitation, scalable operations, bulk collection, Computer Technology Division, Network Technology Division, Cyber Networks Technology Division, CNTD, Access Division, Forensics Engineering Branch, FEB, Acquisitions Evaluations Branch, AEB, exploits, nation-state malware, tradecraft signatures, OPSEC, stealthy operations, sustained access, data exfiltration, intelligence collection, foreign intelligence, private branch exchanges, PBX, voicemail systems, SIP, H.323, SCCP, Linux, Windows, SDH exploitation, SONET, ATM routers, multiplexers, transport services, enterprise telephony, cell phones, mobile phones, Ghidra, IDA Pro, JTAG, assembly language, C programming, Python, Perl, Java, target networks, High Value Individuals, high-value targets, target tracking, communications monitoring, network warfare capabilities, Computer Network Defense, cyber threat, foreign networks, DoD, intelligence community, IC partners, international collaboration, SAOSSM, telecommunications infrastructure, public infrastructure compromise, broadcast, satellite, PSTN, data packet, voice control, cellular switches, routers, servers, GPS, Internet exploitation, intranet, modems, fax interception, pagers, telephony, mobile communications, ITU standards, standards exploitation, IEEE standards, digital video, SDH technology, collection tools, voice intercept, IP exfiltration, passive SIGINT, strategic intelligence, information operations, IO support, deny destroy degrade disrupt, manipulation, misleading operations, multi-platform exploitation, operating system exploitation, cross-platform tools, mission applications, warfighter support, enemy targets, counter-exploitation, CCNE, tool productization, intelligence assessment, toolbox diversity, research and development, industry sources, academia, NTOC, ANO, services collaboration, CNO community, partner agency, evaluation, prioritization, tradecraft, vulnerability research, exploit development

Identifier:
Tailored-Access-Operations-2007

PDF SHA-256:
418c4dac4a2a76e9686e64874c753686480266ab9d0d8232c5990ed5eb7585d3

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL

NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

CENTRAL SECURITY SERVICES
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Development

Derived From: NSA/CSSM 1-52
Dated: 20070108
Declassify On: 20360401

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL


NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

Telecommunications Network Technologies

This Briefing is Classified TOP SECRET//COMINT//ORCON//NOFORN

Tailored Access Operations

This Briefing is Classified TOP SECRET//COMINT//ORCON//NOFORN

DERIVED FROM: NSA/CSS Manual 1-52, Dated: 20070108, Declassify On: 20320108

IOEC1000


SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TAO Mission

  • Sustain a deep, persistent, and pervasive presence on critical target networks
  • Rapidly penetrate and track the communications of high-value individuals
  • Continually execute CNE; support CNA and CND
    • CNE: Exploit networks for foreign intelligence
    • CNA: Provide access and capabilities to support authorized network attacks
    • CND: Hunt foreign cyber actors on foreign networks
    • Deconflict DoD CNO with IC/Foreign partners
  • Build the techniques, tools and infrastructure required
    • Subvert endpoint devices
      • Servers, workstations, firewalls, routers, handsets, phone switches, SCADA systems, etc.
    • Covertly communicate with implants in target networks
    • Automate CNE operations and maintenance of a large number of accesses

Aggressively Scale CNO Capabilities and Operations

SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TAO Organization

TAO

  • Requirements & Targeting
    • Manage ops requirements
    • Perform target development
  • Remote Operations Center
    • Conduct On-net ops (exploit, collect, geo-locate)
  • Data Network Technologies
    • Develop operational concepts and software implants to exploit computer networks
  • Telecommunications Network Technologies
    • Develop operational concepts and software implants to exploit phone switches
    • Develop network warfare capabilities
    • Network shaping
  • Access Technologies & Operations
    • Conduct physical access (off-net) operations
    • Conduct expeditionary CNO
    • Develop hardware and firmware implants to access isolated or complex networks
  • Mission Infrastructure Technologies
    • Design, development and delivery of the end-to end infrastructure that supports GENIE operations

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY


Access Technology & Operations

  • conducts global off-net operations with HUMINT partners to develop and deploy technology that enables on-net operations targeting high priority target networks and individuals.
  • works closely with development organizations to create technical and operational solutions using specialized TAO hardware and software tools that are tailored to each mission and opportunity.
  • bring unique talents to gaining access to intelligence when conventional collection methods prove ineffective.
  • The diverse skill sets that ATO personnel bring to the mission leverages the support of our HUMINT partners, unique access, and sophisticated tools and techniques that provide physical access to networks and communications.

Access & Target Development

  • (S//SI) Develop deep understanding of target communication techniques and practices of target entities with goal of identifying vulnerabilities that can be exploited via physical access.
  • Define and develop physical access strategies, aligned to national requirements and TAO priorities, with emphasis on hard targets and isolated networks.
  • Build and maintain significant relationships within the HUMINT community necessary for achieving access.
  • Drive resulting operations to achieve end-to-end SIGINT successes.

Access Technology & Operations

Field Operations

(TS//SI//REL) The Field Operations Division is responsible for the developing and deploying customized SIGINT collection and data exfiltration solutions that enable remote network operations by gaining access to isolated target networks. The Division is also responsible for maintaining access to selected targets, exploring methods of enhancing the value from existing access, efficiently managing sustained operations, and working closely with the FBI and other HUMINT partners to plan and conduct operations.

Expeditionary Access Operations (EAO)

(TS//SI//REL TO USA FVEY) S3283 is the expeditionary arm of TAO which conducts worldwide Human-Enabled Close Access Cyber Operations to satisfy National and Tactical SIGINT access requirements.

Access and Target Development

(S//SI) Develop deep understanding of target communication techniques and practices of target entities with goal of identifying vulnerabilities that can be exploited via physical access. Define and develop physical access strategies, aligned to national requirements and TAO priorities, with emphasis on hard targets and isolated networks. Build and maintain significant relationships within the HUMINT community necessary for achieving access. Drive resulting operations to achieve end-to-end SIGINT successes.

Persistence Divison

(U//FOUO) The Persistence Division (S3285) conceives, develops, tests, and integrates sophisticated firmware and software-based capabilities and techniques to directly support three of Tailored Access Operations' (TAO's) mission technology focus areas: Persistence - IT/GEO - Computer Network Attack (TS//SI//REL FVEY) These firmware and software techniques are remotely deployable to target devices via a network connection or by physical interdiction. Regardless of the deployment methodology, these highly developed accesses operate covertly without any indication of their presence and provide TAO with unique and advanced capabilities that directly support NSA and its other Intelligence Community partners with some of their most significant successes.


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL

Telecom Network Technologies

  • Providing logically intrusive methods of manipulating or extracting data from telecommunications networks.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL


TOP SECRET // COMINT // X1

TNT Mission:

"Define, design, develop, & test, logically intrusive methods of manipulating & extracting data from telecommunication networks, public infrastructures, and public broadcasting networks - and supporting enabling efforts, remote operations, initial deployments, and information operations."

Fixed Satellite Systems
Global Information Network
PSTN
Satcom Gateways
Packet Data & Voice
Control Links
Tactical Comms
GSMC
MSC
BSC
BTS
Abis
Servers
GPS
Internet / Intranets
Cellular Switches PBX
Routers
Pagers
Telephones
Modems
FAX

TOP SECRET // COMINT //


TOP SECRET // COMINT // X1

Targeted Technologies:

  • Telephony:
    • VOIP - Voice Over Internet Protocol
    • ISDN - Integrated Services Digital Network
    • GSM - Global Systems for Mobile Communications
    • GPRS - General Packet Radio Service
    • 3G - 3rd Generation Mobile Telephony
    • SMS - Short Messaging Service
    • MMS - Multimedia Messaging Service
    • SDH - Synchronous Digital Hierarchy
  • Facilities & Infrastructure:
    • Data communications standards (ITU & IEEE)
  • Broadcast:
    • ITU standards for digital video communications

TOP SECRET // COMINT //


CBND Overview

  • Control Platforms Branch
    • Large Scale SCADA Energy Management Systems (EMSs)
    • Vendors
      • Siemens
      • Areva
      • ABB
  • Control Devices Branch
    • Substation SCADA Technologies
    • Technologies
      • Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs)
      • Intelligent Relays
  • Video Technologies Branch
    • Video Teleconferencing Systems (VTCs)
    • Personal Video Technologies
      • Webcams
      • Internet Chat (Skype, etc)

Project Descriptions

  • OPERATIONAL
    • GSM implants deployed in several target networks
    • Geolocation tools used with great success
    • Metadata and other voice collection tools
  • DEVELOPMENT
    • GPRS and UMTS
  • STRATEGIC EFFORTS
    • IP exfiltration
    • Enabling passive SIGINT collection

VND Overview

  • Enterprise Telephony
    • Private Branch Exchanges (PBXs)
    • VoiceMail Systems
    • Network Management Systems
    • Technologies
      • SIP, H.323, SCCP
      • Linux & Windows development platforms
      • C, Assembly, Perl/Python
      • Ghidra, IDA Pro, JTAG for reverse engineering
  • Transport Services
    • SDH, SONET Multiplexers
    • ATM Routers
    • Technologies
      • SDH, SONET, ATM
      • Linux & Windows development platforms
      • C, Assembly, Java
      • Ghidra, IDA Pro, JTAG for reverse engineering

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL

Data Network Technologies

  • Providing the software-based capabilities needed to surreptitiously exploit computer networks and the technology needed to covertly pass endpoint access commands and data across public networks to support endpoint operations.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL


Data Network Technologies

Access Division, S3231

(TS//SI) The Chief, Access Division is responsible to the Chief, Data Net-work Technologies Office to develop access to targets of interest to NSA. The Access Division focuses on developing remote access techniques and tools, ensuring continued remote access through the deployment of tools via remote or human assets, and assisting with remote access operations under the authority of the Remote Operations Center. The Access Division will act as the front door for DNT-wide efforts. The techniques developed should be scalable, automatable, and robust.

Network Technology Division, S3235

(S//SI//REL) The Chief, Network Technology Division is responsible to the Chief, Data Network Technologies Office for the development of tools and techniques to exploit components on global and private networks supporting endpoint operations.

Computer Technology Division, S3234

(TS//SI) The Chief, Computer Technology Division is responsible to the Chief, Data Networks Technologies Office for collection against target networks. The Computer Technology Division focuses on the development of software implants, automation, and control tools to support endpoint operations.

Cyber Networks Technology Division, S3232

(TS//SI) The Chief, Cyber Networks Technology Division (CNTD) is responsible to the Chief, Data Net-work Technologies Office to develop and deploy logically intrusive, software-based, end-point access techniques to enable Computer Network Operations (CNO) across multiple target operating systems and platforms. CNTD's purpose is to collect or enable collection of data for Foreign Intelligence and Operational Information and to include support to Information Operations.


TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

Data Network Technologies

Cyber Network Technologies Division (CNTD)

  • Mission:
    • (TS//SI//NF) Develop and deploy logically intrusive, software-based, end-point access techniques to enable Computer Network Operations (CNO).
  • Purpose:
    • (TS//SI//NF) Collect or enable collection of data for Foreign Intelligence and Operational Information, to include support to Information Operations.
  • The Bottom Line
    • (TS//SI//NF) "Provide the War-fighter with a world class capability for computer network attacks and counter-computer network exploitations".
    • (TS//SI//NF) Develop mission applications that Deny, Destroy, Degrade, Disrupt, Manipulate, Mislead, and Collect against enemy targets.
    • (TS//SI//NF) Design and develop techniques that enable stealthy sustained operation of our mission applications on target.
    • (TS//SI//NF) Accomplish the above points across many target operating systems and platforms.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN


TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

CNTD Overview

Acquisitions and Evaluations Branch (AEB)

  • Search for or identify opportunities to purchase tools and their source code
  • Validate, prioritize opportunities with appropriate development organization
  • Acquire tools and their source code, provide in-depth evaluation to accurately assess the tools functionality
  • Productize tools by modifying/developing for OPSEC, tradecraft, integration, testing with other TAO capabilities in order to meet operational requirements.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN


TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

Methodology

+--------------------------+
|       Prioritization     |
+--------------------------+
| - Customer Requirements  |
| - Rogue Nations Systems  |
| - Intel Assessments      |
| - Toolbox Diversity      |
| - Research               |
+--------------------------+
             |
             |
             v
+--------------------------+         +--------------------------+
|       Acquisition        |<--------|         Sources          |
+--------------------------+         +--------------------------+
             |                       | - Industry               |
             v                       | - Academia               |
+--------------------------+         | - NTOC, ANO, TAO         |
|        Evaluation        |         | - Services               |
+--------------------------+         | - CNO Community Agencies,|
             |                       |   Partners               |
             v                       +--------------------------+
+--------------------------+ 
|  Productized/Integration |<-----------(Code Modifications)
+--------------------------+
             |
             v
+--------------------------+
|          Testing         |
+--------------------------+
             |
             v
+--------------------------+         +--------------------------+
|          Release         |-------->|      ROC Submission      |
+--------------------------+         +--------------------------+

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN


TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

CNTD Overview

Forensics and Engineering Branch (FEB)

  • Mission:
    • (TS//SI//NF) Evaluate, Reverse Engineer, Exploit, and Repurpose software for use in CNE, CCNE and CNA operations.
  • Purpose:
    • (TS//SI//NF) Reverse engineer and evaluate software from malware, nation-state, and commercial sources for the purpose of identifying tradecraft signatures and vulnerabilities.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN


Questions???