Article
Core Secrets: NSA Saboteurs in China and Germany
Documents published with this article 9
-
Exceptionally Controlled Information Compartments (January 2013) [pdf]
This document, dated January 2013, provides a list of Exceptionally Controlled Information (ECI) compartments utilized by the NSA and its Five Eyes partners. This document categorizes highly sensitive intelligence programs by their codenames, three-letter trigraphs, and the specific organizations responsible for them. The primary organizations listed include TAO, NCSC, and CES. These compartments represent the highest level of information security, designed to restrict access to sensitive technical data and specific intelligence sources even among individuals with high-level security clearances.
Programs: AMBULANT · APERIODIC · AUNTIE · BLACKANT · BLACKAXE · BLACKBALL · BLACKCLOUD · BLACKHOLE · BLACKJACK · BLACKTIE · BLACKVULTURE · BLACKWIDOW · BOXWOOD · CELESTIALGLOBE · CHIEFDOM · CLICKUMBER · CRIMSONREGENT · CRIMSTONSTEAL · CRUMPET · DECKSTOP · DEVILFISH · DIXIESPRING · DOMINATE · FASTIDIOUS · FIRESCREEN · FIRSTDOWN · FISSURESALUTE · FLYLEAF · FORBIDDEN · FORBORNE · FOXHEAT · FREELUNCH · FROTHYTWOPACK · FURTIVERELIANCE · GOLDENCALF · HELLFIRE · HISTORY · HYSSOP · INVEIGH · KESSELRUN · LIGHTNINGTHIEF · LITTLECROWN · LONGSERPENT · MAGICSTROKE · MERCURYTAO · MUSICBOX · NITEHAWK · OCELLUS · PAINTEDEAGLE · PAWLEYS · PAWNSHOP · PENDLETON · PENDRAGON · PERKYAUTUMN · PHENYLDOUR · PICARESQUE · PICAROON · PIEDMONT · PITCHFORD · PLACEBO · POMPANO · PRESSURETWIN · REDHARVEST · REEFPOINT · REFRACTOR · REVELRY · RIVERROAD · RUBIOUS · SAILWINDS · SCABBARD · SILVERCLOUD · SINKGOAL · STAIRWELL · STARCHART · SUITESWIVEL · TRICKSHOT · WAXOFF · WHIPGENIE -
CLASSIFICATION GUIDE FOR ECI PAWLEYS (PAW) [pdf]
This 2006 NSA classification guide outlines the protocols for ECI PAWLEYS (PAW). PAWLEYS is an Exceptionally Compartmented Information (ECI) category designed to protect clandestine operations—both physical (HUMINT) and digital (CNE)—specifically aimed at acquiring foreign cryptographic information and material. The document confirms that the NSA actively seeks to circumvent encryption through clandestine HUMINT and computer network access aimed at cryptographic information and material, rather than relying solely on traditional codebreaking.
Programs: PAWLEYS -
NSA/CSS EXCEPTIONALLY CONTROLLED INFORMATION (ECI) 2003 [pdf]
This document acts as the definitive "master list" of the NSA’s Exceptionally Controlled Information (ECI) compartments as of September 2003. While standard Top Secret information is shared among those with the appropriate clearance and a "need to know," ECIs are even more restricted—they are "silos" of information where access is granted only by the Director of the NSA (DIRNSA). This list provides a rare architectural view of the NSA's most sensitive secrets, ranging from illegal money laundering stings to the subversion of global encryption standards.
Programs: PAWLEYS · ABEYANT · APERIODIC · AUNTIE · AMBULANT · FIRSTDOWN · BOATMEN · BOXWOOD · BULLET · CHILLY · CLERIC · CONQUERER · KLAMATH · DECKSTOP · DICHOTOMY · DILEMMA · RAMPART-M · DOMINATE · FLEXURE · ENSIGN · STAIRWELL · ESCAPEE · STATEROOM · EVADEYIELD · FORBIDDEN · FORBORNE · GRAYSCALE · HELLFIRE · HISTORY · INVEIGH · INVENT · LYSERGIC · MISCHIEF · RAGTIME · BLARNEY · OPALESCE · TAREX · PENDLETON · PIEDMONT · PITCHFORD · REFRACTOR · RUBIOUS · STEREO · STRESSFUl · TAXONOMY · VISITOR · WASHBURN -
CNO Core Secrets Slide Slices [pdf]
This document outlines the Security Framework for a joint national initiative between the NSA/CSS and JFCC-NW, detailing the highly compartmented structure used to protect cyber and intelligence secrets. It utilizes a concentric security framework diagram to visualize the layers of sensitivity, placing the most critical technical capabilities at the absolute center of the intelligence community's protection.
Programs: SENTRY-EAGLE · SENTRYHAWK · SENTRYFALCON · SENTRYOSPREY · SENTRYRAVEN · SENTRYCONDOR · SENTRYOWL -
CNO Core Secrets Security Structure [pdf]
A 3-slide NSA presentation outlining the classification architecture of Sentry Eagle, a national cyber operations initiative, showing how its most sensitive components — covering network hacking, encryption sabotage, and covert industry relationships — are locked behind ECI and SAP designations accessible only to a tiny circle of government officials.
Programs: SENTRYEAGLE · SENTRYHAWK · SENTRYFALCON · SENTRYOSPREY · SENTRYRAVEN · SENTRYCONDOR · SENTRYOWL -
Sentry Eagle Brief Sheet [pdf]
A classified NSA/JFCC-NW briefing document formally inducting cleared personnel into Sentry Eagle — the agency's most sensitive umbrella program protecting core secrets about its cyber operations — and enumerating, tier by tier, what the NSA conceals about its covert industry partnerships, encryption sabotage, network hacking, computer network defense, and human intelligence relationships.
Programs: SENTRYEAGLE · SPARECHANGE · WHIPGENIE · AUNTIE · AMBULANT · OPALESCE · REVELRY · REFRACTOR · SENTRYHAWK · SENTRYFALCON · SENTRYOSPREY · SENTRYRAVEN · SENTRYCONDOR · SENTRYOWL · BLUESASH · TAREX -
CLASSIFICATION GUIDE FOR THE NSA/CSS TARGET EXPLOITATION (TAREX) PROGRAM [pdf]
A 2012 NSA/CSS classification guide for the TAREX program — the agency's clandestine human intelligence and close-access signals intelligence unit — establishing what information about TAREX's operations, locations, methodologies, and interagency relationships must be protected, revealing forward-based presences in Germany, South Korea, and Beijing, and confirming that TAREX personnel operate undercover at U.S. embassies worldwide.
Programs: TAREXPeople: Shea, Teresa H. -
ECI WHIPGENIE Classification Guide [pdf]
A 2004 NSA classification guide for ECI WHIPGENIE, covering the agency's Special Source Operations relationships with US corporate partners for cable collection and domestic wire access, including FISA-warranted collection and FBI-assisted compelled and cooperative partnerships.
Programs: WHIPGENIE · FAIRVIEW · STORMBREW · BLARNEY · POWERPLANT · TUMBRIL · WEALTHYCLUSTER · RAGTIME · PLUS · YELLOWSTONE · SSO -
Computer Network Exploitation (CNE) Classification Guide / 2-59 [pdf]
A NSA/TAO classification guide establishing the precise classification level for 41 categories of information about computer network exploitation operations — covering remote and physical subversion methods, CNE tools and techniques, supply chain operations, hardware implants, off-net field operations, zero-day vulnerabilities, and cryptographic material acquired through CNE.
“Core Secrets: NSA Saboteurs in China and Germany” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-10-10) · “The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · Maass, Peter · Poitras, Laura · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael