Article
The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle
Documents published with this article 35
-
Expanding Endpoint Operations SIDtoday [pdf]
Tailored Access Operations, NSA's elite hackers, are expanding their endpoint operations -- hacking directly into computers to steal information -- and are establishing the new endpoint operations remote operations center, scheduled to come online in the summer of 2005, that "is capable of managing and conducting endpoint operations on a scale that will dramatically expand collection." The physical office space of this new center will allow TAO to "grow from the current average of 20-25 of these operations per day to over 100 per day," and will allow TAO to increase the number of "active implants," or actively monitored pieces of malware, from 100-150 to thousands.
“How the NSA Plans to Infect ‘Millions’ of Computers with Malware” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-03-12) · The Intercept ↗ (2017-04-24) · “The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · Gallagher, Ryan · Greenwald, Glenn · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael -
The ROC: NSA's Epicenter for Computer Network Operations SIDtoday [pdf]
The Remote Operations Center (ROC) conducts computer network operations against U.S. adversaries and foreign governments. Its motto is: "Your data is our data, your equipment is our equipment, anytime, any place, by any legal means."
The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael -
CSEC SIGINT Cyber Discovery: Summary of the current effort [pdf]
This document provides a overview of the Communications Security Establishment Canada (CSEC) cyber operations, detailing its SIGINT, CNE (Computer Network Exploitation), and cyber counterintelligence programs, including tools like WARRIORPRIDE, REPLICANTFARM, and EONBLUE for threat detection, anomaly discovery, and metadata production. It outlines operational procedures, analytic methodologies, and collaborative frameworks with domestic and Five Eyes partners for sharing intelligence, tipping/cueing, and integrating cyber and traditional counterintelligence efforts.
Programs: REPLICANTFARM · SLIPSTREAM · WARRIORPRIDE · DAREDEVIL · CHORDFLIER · NAMEDROPPER · WORMWOOD · OBELIX · SHEPHERD · CARBON · REGBACKUP · DOGHOUSE · WALKER · ALOOFNESS · BLAZINGANGEL · TINYWEB · QUIVERINGSQUAB · WINDO · DIESELRATTLE · WIDOWKEY · CIVETCAT · WINBEE · SSLINST · PULLEDPORK · EONBLUE · SNIFFLE · QUANTUM · XKEYSCORE · HALTERHITCH · FASTFLUX · DEADSEA · NSPACES · PPF · SSO · TKB“The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · “Communication Security Establishment's cyberwarfare toolbox revealed” - CBC News ↗ (2015-03-23) · “Documents Reveal Canada’s Secret Hacking Tactics” - The Intercept ↗ (2015-03-23) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael · Seglins, Dave · Hildebrandt, Amber · Pereira, Michael · Greenwald, Glenn · Gallagher, Ryan -
CNE End Point Requirements [pdf]
This NSA/GCHQ document outlines comprehensive requirements for an endpoint surveillance systems that enables analysts to systematically identify intelligence collection needs and discover appropriate tools for data extraction from compromised computers. The framework covers capabilities for remote data collection, cross-platform intelligence integration, query functions, tasking procedures, and visualization tools across implanted networks.
Programs: STARGATE · LOOKING GLASS · QUANTUM · GOLDENEYE · XKEYSCORE · MARINA · JTRIG · BROADOAK · UTT · GLOBALREACH · GLOBALSURGE · THUGGEE · EREPO · DANCINGBEAR · HAUSTORIUM · SHAREOWN · MUTANTBROTH · MOONRAKER · CARBONROD · RUFFLE · ROCKOPERA · QUINCEY · ECLIPSE · MUGSHOT · HIGHNOTE · UDAQ2 · EKB · TURBINE · ACNO · FLAMECARPET · FUMECUPBOARD · JACKPOT · SLIPSTREAM · B13B · PSC · QUINCY · DAREDEVIL · ROADBED -
QUANTUMTHEORY (2010 SIGINT Development Conference) [pdf]
This 2010 NSA presentation reveals QUANTUMTHEORY, a suite of "man-on-the-side" network attack technologies that enable real-time injection and manipulation of TCP/IP connections through passive surveillance infrastructure. The system encompasses multiple specialized attack techniques including HTML redirection, DNS hijacking, botnet takeover, and database injection, deployed at Five Eyes surveillance sites worldwide.
Programs: QUANTUMTHEORY · TRAFFICTHIEF · TURMOIL · TURBINE · QUANTUM · NINJANIC · ISLANDTRANSPORT · SURPLUSHANGER · DAREDEVIL · STRAIGHTBIZARRE · QUANTUMINSERT · QUANTUMSKY · QUANTUMBOT · QUANTUMBISCUIT · QUANTUMDNS · QUANTUMBOT2 · QUANTUMCOPPER · QUANTUMMUSH · HUFFMUSH · QUANTUMSPIM · QUANTUMSQUEEL · QUANTUMSQUIRREL · INCENSOR · SMOKEYSINK · SARATOGA · QUANTUMDEFENSE · TURBULENCE“How the NSA Plans to Infect ‘Millions’ of Computers with Malware” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-03-12) · “The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · Gallagher, Ryan · Greenwald, Glenn · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael -
-
TURBULENCE - APEX - Active/passive Exfiltration [pdf]
This 2009 NSA presentation details APEX (Active/Passive Exfiltration), a TURBULENCE program component that combines passive collection infrastructure with active TAO implants to exfiltrate VPN and VoIP traffic from deep within target networks back to NSA collection systems. The system uses the FASHIONCLEFT protocol to tunnel captured packets through compromised routers and network devices, enabling decryption of VPN tunnels and collection of voice communications that would otherwise be invisible to passive surveillance.
Programs: TURBULENCE · TURMOIL · HAMMERSTEIN · HAMMERCHANT · FASHIONCLEFT · TUTELAGE · TURBINE · TRAFFICTHIEF · XKEYSCORE · ANALYTICS · PRESSUREWAVE · TOYGRIPPE · POISONNUT · FLAXENPRECEPT · FOGYNULL · FUNNELAPS · SHELLGREY · METROTUBE · VINYLSEAT · OLYMPUS · UNITEDRAKE · FIGBUILD · SURPASSPIN · ROOTKNOT · OPTICPINCH · SEAGULFARO · TREBLECLEF · CONVEY · PINWALE · SWEEPFORWARD · QUANTUM · KEYCARD · ASDF · TUBE · PUZZLECUBE · WEALTHYCLUSTER2 · COALSHOVEL · HAMMERMILL · ISLANDTRANSPORT · FASCIA · TURBINIE · APEX · PPF · AEG · FIP · SSO · PICARESQUE · PSP · IVE · PSC · CHIMNEYPOOL · CORESSC · FLASHHANDLE · IBRIDGE · CORALREEF · VAO · NUCLEON · PIQBLADE“The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · “How the NSA Plans to Infect ‘Millions’ of Computers with Malware” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-03-12) · “How the NSA Plans to Infect ‘Millions’ of Computers with Malware” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-03-12) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael · Gallagher, Ryan · Greenwald, Glenn -
Analytic Challenges from Active-Passive Integration [pdf]
This NSA presentation examines metadata attribution challenges arising when active TAO implants exfiltrate traffic through passive TURMOIL collection infrastructure, creating conflicts where intercepted data carries dual classification markings, case notations, and legal authorities from both collection systems. The briefing highlights how existing databases and analytic tools were not designed to handle traffic with two simultaneous sets of metadata parameters, requiring enterprise-wide solutions to consistently attribute and track actively-shaped intelligence collection.
Programs: BRAVENICKEL · HAMMERMILL · APEX · MARINA · TURMOIL · PRESSUREWAVE · METROTUBE · TOYGRIPPE · HAMMERSTEIN · HAMMERSTONE · METAWAVE · TURBULENCE · SSO -
The FASHIONCLEFT Protocol [pdf]
This October 2008 NSA technical specification details FASHIONCLEFT, the encryption and exfiltration protocol used by TAO implants to securely tunnel captured network packets from compromised devices back to the NSA's Common Data Receptor using layered RSA and RC6 encryption with authentication. The document addresses technical integration challenges of implementing FASHIONCLEFT packet reception within TURMOIL's passive collection infrastructure, particularly cache buffering requirements and metadata handling for exfiltrated traffic.
Programs: FASHIONCLEFT · FOGYNULL · FUNNELAPS · SHELLGREY · TURMOIL · SURPASSPIN · PUZZLECUBE · FLASHHANDLE · HAMMERCHANT · AEG · PPF · ISLANDTRANSPORT -
Moving Data Through Disconnected Networks - Delay-Tolerant Networking and the IC [pdf]
This June 2012 NSA Laboratory for Telecommunications Sciences presentation details Delay-Tolerant Networking (DTN) applications for surveillance operations, including covert communications in denied areas, data exfiltration from isolated networks, unwitting data mules, and integration with TAO's CHIMNEYPOOL implant framework. The document reveals R4 development of FUZZYLINT, an ultra-lightweight DTN implementation designed to enable multi-hop exfiltration from implants without requiring direct physical access.
People: Vahdat, Amin · Becker, David · Juang, Philo · Oki, Hidekazu · Wang, Yong · Martonosi, Margaret · Peh, Li-Shiuan · Rubenstein, Daniel · Grossglauser, Matthias · Tse, David N. C. · Fall, Kevin · Shah, Rahul C. · Roy, Sumit · Jain, Sushant · Brunette, Waylon · Lindgren, Anders · Doria, Avri · Schelen, Olov · Small, Tara · Haas, Zygmunt J. · Zhao, Wenrui · Ammar, Mostafa · Zegura, Ellen · Ginzboorg, Philip · Kärkkäinen, Teemu · Nagata, Akira · Lenders, Vincent · Legendre, Franck · May, Martin · Karlsson, Gunnar · Du, Bowei · Demmer, Michael · Brewer, Eric · Ott, Jörg · Pitkänen, Mikko Juhani · Han, Bo · Hui, Pan -
FASHIONCLEFT - Interface Control Document (15 June 2009) [pdf]
This 2009 NSA Interface Control Document provides comprehensive technical specifications for FASHIONCLEFT, the protocol that acts as a covert shipping system enabling TAO malware implants to send stolen network data back to NSA collection servers with minimal computer processing requirements—using multiple encryption layers (RSA-1024 and RC6-128) to disguise the traffic as it travels across the internet while allowing NSA's Common Data Receptor to reassemble and authenticate the original intercepted packets. The document details how implants make modified copies of captured network traffic (changing destination addresses to point toward NSA instead of legitimate recipients), apply various levels of encryption or scrambling ("munging") depending on how powerful the infected computer is, attach metadata instructions explaining how to reconstruct the original packets, and use pattern-matching algorithms to ensure NSA systems can identify which stolen packets belong to which collection operation.
Programs: FASHIONCLEFT · FLAXENPRECEPT · SHELLGREY · SURPASSPIN · SEAGULLFARO · ROOTKNOT · FIGBUILD · OPTICPINCH · VINYLSEAT · OLYMPUS · UNITEDRAKE · HOGTECH · SWEEPFORWARD · CONVEY · PINWALE · TREBLECLEF · FOGYNULL · FUNNELAPS · FLASHHANDLE -
HIDDENSALAMANDER - Alerting and Characterization of Botnet Activity in TURMOIL [pdf]
This NSA briefing describes HIDDENSALAMANDER, a TURMOIL component that detects, tracks, and characterizes botnet command-and-control traffic on passive collection sensors worldwide, generating enriched metadata about bot herders, infected machines, attack commands, and malware families while providing low-latency defensive alerts when botnet activity involves high-value targets or protected networks. The system extends beyond traditional signature matching by decrypting Zeus RC4-encrypted traffic, extracting payload details like target IPs and DDoS commands, tracking C2 servers across multiple sessions, and categorizing botnet lifecycle stages (configuration, infection, reconnaissance, C&C communication, attack, exfiltration) to support both offensive attribution and defensive response.
Programs: HIDDENSALAMANDER · TURMOIL · CLOUDSHIELD · NETEZZA · TUTELAGE · GMPLACE · RONIN · CYBERCLOUD · MARINA · GHOSTMACHINE · QBOT · ASDF · MARIPOSA · XKEYSCORE · GOGADGET · TURQI · TRAFFICTHIEF · FALLOUT · POUNDSAND · BLUESMOKE · AEG · TURNABOUT · QUANTUMBOT -
Is there "fifth party" collection? [pdf]
This NSA internal Q&A forum discussion reveals "fifth party collection"—where the NSA passively intercepts data from one intelligence service (South Korea) that has compromised another service's (North Korea) computer network exploitation operations, creating a three-layer chain where NSA exploits Actor One's access to Actor Two's CNE activities against shared targets. The thread provides concrete examples including NSA leveraging South Korean implants on North Korean officials' computers (who themselves were conducting CNE operations) and stealing zero-day exploits from unidentified foreign intelligence services by passively monitoring their successful attacks.
-
'4th Party Collection': Taking Advantage of Non-Partner Computer Network Exploitation Activity SIDtoday [pdf]
This January 2008 SIDtoday article from Menwith Hill Station describes "4th Party Collection"—an NSA technique exploiting non-Five Eyes nations' computer network operations by passively intercepting their stolen data—with the example of NSA monitoring Kurdistan Democratic Party's deployment of Perfect Keylogger commercial spyware against targets in Iran and Iraq, including people with links to the Kurdistan Regional Government and Iraqi Ministry of Foreign Affairs computers, capturing keystrokes, passwords, chat logs, and documents that traditional signals intelligence would never collect. The operation reveals KDP intelligence services systematically compromised internet cafés and Iraqi Ministry of Foreign Affairs computers, with exfiltrated data routing to email addresses in Erbil registered to terminals associated with Kurdish intelligence, which NSA then intercepts and repurposes for its own intelligence production.
-
NSA's Offensive and Defensive Missions: The Twain Have Met SIDtoday [pdf]
The document outlines a case where NSA’s defensive malware analysis enabled offensive SIGINT teams to gain sustained access to a Chinese command-and-control server, allowing NSA to intercept intelligence China had stolen from the United Nations through a method known as fourth-party collection.
-
TRANSGRESSION Overview for Pod58 [pdf]
The TRANSGRESSION overview describes an NSA capability focused on discovering, decrypting, and exploiting foreign computer network exploitation activity to support fourth-party collection, TAO cyber operations, and network defense missions across NSA and FVEY partners.
Programs: TRANSGRESSION · MAKERSMARK · BYZANTINEHADES · VOYEUR · WALKERBLACK · WALKERRED · CROWNROYAL · CROWNPRINCE · SHEPHERD · ZEBEDEE · MAVERICK CHURCH · POPROCKS · GHOSTRECON · NIGHTTRAIN · SHADOWDRAGON · RECORDER · PLAIDDIANA · INCAADAM · TWEEZERS · SNOWGLOBE · WIDOWKEY · SUPERDRAKE · XKEYSCORE · POLARSTARKEY · TUNINGFORK · SCISSORS · PINWALE · CLOUD · BYZANTINEFOOTHOLD · ADJUTANTVENTURE · RAPTORROLEX · RAPTORJOY · RAPTORSAD · BYZANTINERAPTOR -
SNOWGLOBE: From Discovery to Attribution [pdf]
This document describes how CSEC identified and analyzed the SNOWGLOBE intrusion set, using passive collection, implant reverse engineering, and infrastructure analysis to attribute the campaign with moderate confidence to a French intelligence service targeting Iranian and international scientific, diplomatic, and political organizations.
Programs: SNOWGLOBE · WARRIORPRIDE · REPLICANTFARM · SNOWBALL · SNOWMAN · EONBLUE · SPECIALSOURCE · CANDLEGLOWPeople: Roshal, Alexander“The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · “Quand les Canadiens partent en chasse de « Babar »” - Le Monde ↗ (2014-03-21) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael · Follorou, Jacques · Untersinger, Martin -
Fourth Party Opportunities [pdf]
This presentation document explains how NSA identifies, prioritizes, and exploits “fourth party” opportunities by passively or actively leveraging foreign computer network exploitation operations, including victim stealing and tool repurposing, to collect intelligence without initiating original intrusions.
Programs: VOYEUR · UIS · PINWALE · YNKE · TUNINGFORK · DIRTSHED · SEEKER · CLOUD · ABR · SILVERBOLT · DEADSEA · XKEYSCORE · BYZANTINERAPTOR · HAWALA · ZEBEDEE · DATAFLURRY · ECLECTICPLOT · HAPPYFOOT · BLUESMOKE · CROSSBONES2 · CYBERQUEST · VICDB · PLAIDDIANA · TRANSGRESSION -
TUTELAGE 411 [pdf]
TUTELAGE is a SIGINT-driven cyber defense and counterintelligence platform that enables NSA to observe, intercept, redirect, block, and manipulate adversary network activity at DoD gateways, transforming intrusion response from post-incident reporting into real-time mitigation and intelligence generation.
Programs: TUTELAGE · CYBERQUEST · XKEYSCORE · GNOMEVISION · POPQUIZ · BISHOPKNIGHT · BLACKENERGY · BLINDMARKSMEN · BYZANTINEFOOTHOLD · BYZANTINEVIKING · CARBONPEPTIDE · CONFICKER · DANCING PANDA · DISCOVERY · GNOMEFISHER · MAKERSMARK · MAVERICKCHURCH · NATIVEDANCER · WEASELWAGGLE · SUBTLESNOW · WIDOWKEY · ZEUS · GHOSTMACHINE · PANDORASMAYHEM · TURBINE · QUANTUM · BYZANTINEHADES · AMULETSTELLAR · TURNABOUT -
BYZANTINE HADES: An Evolution of Collection [pdf]
A classified NSA SIGINT briefing from 2010 describes “BYZANTINE HADES,” a collection of Chinese computer network exploitation activities, with a focus on the BYZANTINE CANDOR actor set and U.S. efforts to analyze, attribute, and counter those intrusions. The document details targeting patterns, technical tradecraft, and a TAO-led counterintelligence operation that successfully penetrated the attackers’ infrastructure and personal systems.
Programs: BYZANTINEHADES · BYZANTINECANDOR · BYZANTINERAPTOR · BYZANTINEANCHOR · BISHOPKNIGHT · BYZANTINEVIKING · MAVERICKCHURCH · BISHOP · BYZANTINETRACE · DIESELRATTLE · BYZANTINEFOOTHOLD · BYZANTINEPRAIRIE · SEEDSPHERE · CARBONPEPTIDE · TITANRAIN · PINWALE · XKEYSCORE · CROSSBONES · TUNINGFORK · ARROWECLIPSE · CUTEBOY · POPROCKS · BYZANTINE -
Chinese Exfiltrate Sensitive Military Technology [pdf]
This TOP SECRET NSA SIGINT development briefing describes large-scale Chinese cyber espionage that exfiltrated sensitive U.S. military technologies and inflicted extensive operational, financial, and strategic damage on Department of Defense systems. The document emphasizes both the scale of losses and the role of SIGINT in detecting, understanding, and mitigating adversary malware.
Programs: BYZANTINEHADES -
Pay attention to that man behind the curtain: Discovering aliens on CNE infrastructure [pdf]
CSEC briefing from 2010 outlines Canada’s counter–computer network exploitation efforts to detect, analyze, and pursue foreign and friendly cyber actors operating on shared CNE infrastructure. It details tools, methods, and a case study showing how hidden implants and overlapping state-sponsored operations were uncovered and attributed.
Programs: SNOWGLOBE · WARRIORPRIDE · DAREDEVIL · SLIPSTREAM · CHORDFLIER · NAMEDROPPER · WORMWOOD · REPLICANTFARM · OBELIX · SHEPHERD · CARBON · ALOOFNESS · REGBACKUP · DOGHOUSE · WALKER · CHOCOPOP · BLAZINGANGEL · WINDO · QUIVERINGSQUAB · DIESELRATTLE · CYDLL · CIVETCAT · WIDOWKEY · LASEX · PULLEDPORK · MAKERSMARK · FANNER · SEEDSPHERE · BYZANTINE · VOYEUR · SUPERDRAKE · GOSSIPGIRL · WATERMARK · DOURMAGNUM -
DEFIANTWARRIOR and the NSA's Use of Bots [pdf]
This TOP SECRET NSA presentation from 2010 documents the DEFIANTWARRIOR effort to identify, seize, and operate botnets using SIGINT-enabled infrastructure, detailing both early failures and subsequent operational successes. The document reveals how bot herding was integrated into broader offensive cyber and intelligence collection strategies across the Five Eyes.
Programs: DEFIANTWARRIOR · OLYMPUS · UNITEDRAKE · TURBULENCE · QUANTUMBOT · TURMOIL · TURBINE · SNIPERS · XKEYSCORE · INCENSER · STELLABLUE · SMOKYSINK · STOVEPIPES · ISLANDTRANSPORT · FESTIVEWRAPPER · FREEFLOW · PRESSUREWAVE · HANGARSURPLUS · SURPLUSHANGER · WAITAUTO · DEEPFRIEDPIG · SEAGULLFARO · COLOSSUS · STORMPIG · YELLPIG · PASTEPIG · SHOUTPIG · ZORPIG · MAILORDER · TREASUREMAP · MARINA · WARNVOLCANO · STRAITBIZARRE · BOTINSTANCES · PUZZLECUBE · SEEKER · SURPLUSHANGAR -
Interview with a SID "Hacker" -- Part 1: How Does TAO Do Its Work? SIDtoday [pdf]
A SIDToday interview from July 2012 with a counterterrorism subject-matter expert in TAO's Requirements and Targeting organisation, explaining how TAO plans and executes computer network exploitation operations.
“The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · “Arbeiten mit geheimen Snowden-Dokumenten” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-07-03) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael · Eckert, Svea · Stark, Holger -
Computer Network Exploitation (CNE) Classification Guide / 2-59 [pdf]
A NSA/TAO classification guide establishing the precise classification level for 41 categories of information about computer network exploitation operations — covering remote and physical subversion methods, CNE tools and techniques, supply chain operations, hardware implants, off-net field operations, zero-day vulnerabilities, and cryptographic material acquired through CNE.
“Core Secrets: NSA Saboteurs in China and Germany” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-10-10) · “The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · Maass, Peter · Poitras, Laura · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael -
NIOC MARYLAND ADVANCED COMPUTER NETWORK OPERATIONS COURSE [pdf]
Programs: GENIE · HAWKEYE · EINSTEIN · TUTELAGE · NEPTUNETHUNDER · BLINDDATE · HAPPYHOUR · NITESTAND · WAITAUTO · MATCHCRIMP -
Case Studies of Integrated Cyber Operation Techniques [pdf]
Programs: AURORAVNC · TUTELAGE · QUANTUM · TURBINE · BOXINGRUMBLE · CLOUDSHIELD · PANDORASMAYHAM · TURMOIL · QUANTUMTHEORY · QUANTUMDNS · TAOSHOOTER · DEFIANTWARRIOR · QUANTUMINSERT · QUANTUMBOT · QUANTUMBISCUIT · QUANTUMHAND · QUANTUMPHANTOM · QUANTUMSKY · QUANTUMCOPPER · QUANTUMSMACKDOWN · QUANTUMSANDMAN · FOXACID“The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · “How the NSA Plans to Infect ‘Millions’ of Computers with Malware” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-03-12) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael · Gallagher, Ryan · Greenwald, Glenn -
CNE Presence in CT10 Status Report [pdf]
A TOP SECRET NSA status report from April 2008 describing how a counterterrorism analysis team began importing data from the agency's hacking operations into their tracking system — specifically logs from FOXACID, an NSA tool that infects targets' computers mainly through their web browsers — enabling real-time alerts when new targets were successfully hacked, with plans to expand into tracking four named surveillance implants (VALIDATOR, UNITEDRAKE, OLYMPUS and STRAITBIZARRE) as they phone home to NSA servers for instructions and stolen data.
-
COMPUTER NETWORK OPERATIONS - GENIE [pdf]
A TOP SECRET Congressional Budget Justification entry for the NSA/CSS GENIE project — the Tailored Access Operations programme underpinning all endpoint Computer Network Operations — requesting $651.7 million and 1,870 military and civilian positions for FY2013, with plans to maintain 85,000-96,000 implant points-of-presence worldwide and 9,000-10,000 active accesses, including $25.1 million for covert purchase of software vulnerabilities and a $3.4 million supply chain implant operation targeting al-Qaeda.
-
S3285/InternProjects [pdf]
A WikiInfo page from NSA's Persistence Division (S3285) listing intern project proposals covering firmware implants, BIOS-level persistence, hard drive exploitation and CNA capabilities — including IRATEMONK hard drive firmware implants across multiple vendors, POLITERAIN destructive attack tools, BERSERKR BIOS-resident backdoor, GOPHERRAGE hypervisor implant and CASTLECRASHER Windows payload execution.
Programs: POLITERAIN · PASSIONATEPOLKA · ARGYLEALIEN · BARNFIRE · IRATEMONK · SADDLEBACK · ALTEREDCARBON · FAKEDOUBT · PLUCKHAGEN · EASYKRAKEN · CASTLECRASHER · JUMPDOLLAR · MOPNGO · BERSERKR · GOPHERRAGE · WISTFULTOLL · CENTRICDUD · STYLISHCHAMP · SIERRAMIST · WICKEDVICAR · SPITEFULANGEL · ROGUESAMURAI · SIERRAMISTFREE · VALIDATOR · MOUSETRAP · BORGERKING · KIRKBOMB · SODAPRESSED · BENTWHISTLE · TWISTEDKILT · TORNSTEAK -
iPhone target analysis and exploitation with unique device identifiers [pdf]
A GCHQ technical paper from November 2010 describing iPhone target analysis and exploitation using the QUANTUM system — covering UDID-based target tracking and correlation across MUTANT BROTH and AUTOASSOC, a Safari PDF exploit delivering WARRIORPRIDE implants to target iPhones via QUANTUM redirection, and a confirmed successful exploitation of a jailbroken target phone yielding address book, SMS, call logs, notes, WiFi logs, browser history and images.
Programs: QUANTUM · DEBITCARD · AUTOASSOC · HARDASSOC · MUTANTBROTH · BROKER · HANDEX · WARRIORPRIDE · ABSOLINEEPILSON · BROADOAK · SOLARSHOCK · BLACKHOLE · SHORTSHEET · XKEYSCORE · MARINA · LOOKINGGLASS · OVERLIT · SLIDE · SEP · PRESTON · WHIPSAW · CROWNPRINCE · CORINTH · MVR · SOCIALANTHROPOID -
SNIPs of SIGINT [pdf]
A monthly notes entry from June 2012 by an NSA analyst on exchange at DSD Australia, describing two CNA/CNE tool development projects — PITIEDFOOL, a Windows file system destruction suite that kills the MFT and volume shadow copies and was successfully tested inside FUZZYEBOLA, and PANT SPARTY, an OpenSSH daemon backdoor granting covert root access while suppressing log entries — alongside a briefing to the US Ambassador to Australia on CNA/CNE work and TAO collaboration.
-
QUANTUM Shooter SBZ Notes [pdf]
An NSA WikiInfo technical reference page describing the QUANTUM shooter infrastructure — covering how compromised internet hosts are configured with STRAITBIZARRE implants using FELONYCROWBAR and Deployed Node Documents, the CHIMNEYPOOL/FRIEZERAMP communications architecture linking shooters to TURBINE via SURPLUSHANGAR and HANGARSURPLUS diodes, and GCHQ's distinct MHS shooter configuration that suppresses callbacks entirely.
Programs: QUANTUM · QUANTUMSHOOTER · FREEFLOW · CHIMNEYPOOL · FELONYCROWBAR · STRAITBIZARRE · SURPLUSHANGAR · HANGARSURPLUS · PASSAGEHILL · FORESTPLACE · FUSSYKEEL · FINGERGNOME · FROZENEARTH · FRIEZERAMP · ISLANDTRANSPORT · GENIE · MIDDLEMAN · WEBSNIPERGATEWAY · WAITAUTO · ZOMBIEARMY · FIPTRIX · TURBINE -
Stealthy Techniques Can Crack Some of SIGINT's Hardest Targets SIDtoday [pdf]
A SIDToday article from June 2010 describing TAO's supply chain interdiction operations — where shipments of network devices are covertly intercepted, implanted with beacon implants at a secret load station, and repackaged for delivery — illustrated by a specific operation against the Syrian Telecommunications Establishment whose implanted backbone devices unexpectedly provided access to Syria's previously unexploited GSM network, enabling automatic exfiltration of call detail records and voice content.
“The Digital Arms Race: NSA Preps America for Future Battle” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2015-01-17) · “No Place to Hide” - Metropolitan Books ↗ (2014-05-13) · Appelbaum, Jacob · Gibson, Aaron · Guarnieri, Claudio · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Rosenbach, Marcel · Ryge, Leif · Schmundt, Hilmar · Sontheimer, Michael · Greenwald, Glenn -
Mobile apps doubleheader: BADASS Angry Birds [pdf]
A joint GCHQ/GTE/CSEC presentation describing BADASS — the BEGAL Automated Deployment and Survey System for rapidly developing and deploying mobile app exploitation rules — illustrated through detailed analysis of Angry Birds' Dataflurry analytics traffic leaking IMEI, IMSI, cell network metadata and device identifiers, alongside AdMob, Mobclix and Mydas ad network traffic leaking UDIDs and IMEIs across iOS, Android, BlackBerry and Windows Phone 7 platforms.
Programs: BADASS · BEGAL · SEM · UNIQUELYCHALLENGED · BLACKHOLE · MOUNTAINVIEW · VOB · BABELFISH · BISHOP · MVR · PPF · AEG · DATAFLURRY