CASCADE - Joint Cyber Sensor Architecture
Open PDFDocument date: -
Pages: 66
Genre: slides
Banner: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: REL FVEY
This presentation outlines the Communications Security Establishment’s (CSE) plans to unify and expand its cyber sensor networks (ITS and SIGINT) to create a comprehensive, multi-layered national cyber defense system, enabling threat detection, intelligence collection, and defensive operations across Canadian and foreign networks. It emphasizes standardizing sensor deployments, integrating analytic capabilities, and preparing for “Effects” operations to mitigate cyber threats by 2015. The presentation is duplicated from page 33 onwards - three slides of the duplicated slides have internal CSE comments.
My notes
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CASCADE
Joint Cyber Sensor Architecture
[REDACTED]
[REDACTED]
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Overview
- Project Overview
- Current Status
- Proposed Architecture
- Towards 2015
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Project Overview
- Alignment of passive cyber sensor capabilities and architecture in the SIGINT and ITS missions
- Goals
- Common sensor technology and architecture
- Address scalability issues in sensor deployments
- Scope
- Passive sensors and supporting infrastructure are in scope
- Analytic tools are out of scope
- Host based capability is out of scope (caveat: passive messaging is in scope)
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Our Sensors
SIGINT / ITS
- Photonic Prism
- Monitoring of GC Networks
- Includes:
- Full-Take Packet Capture
- Signature Based Detection
- Anomaly Based Discovery
- Analytic Environment
- Oversight Compliance Tools
- EONBLUE
- Monitoring in Passive SIGINT
- Includes:
- Full-Take (on specific accesses)
- Signature Based Detection
- Anomaly Based Discovery
- Additional Functions are offloaded and exist further downstream:
- Analytic Environment
- Dataflow / Targeting
- Oversight and Compliance Tools
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Shades of Blue
=> 10Gbps
EONBLUE
* DELL R610 1U Platform
* TS//SI Processing
* - Tracking / Discovery
* => Content Metadata
=> Multiple 10Gbps
INDUCTION
* Distributed Processing (Cloud)
* TS//SI Processing
* Tracking / Discovery
* PXE Boot Infrastructure
* => Content Metadata
=> Multiple 1Gbps
THIRD-EYE
* Cyber Metadata Processor
* UNCLASSIFIED Processing
* Metadata Production
* => Metadata
=> 10Gbps
CRUCIBLE
* Secure Sensor
* TS//SI Derived (in UNCLASS)
* Tracking
* => Metadata
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Current Status – SIGINT Deployments
- Special Source
- 100% INDUCTION coverage of main SSO sites + metadata production
- THIRD-EYE metadata production at select new sites
- CRUCIBLE deployments to newly emerging sites pre-SCIF environment (survey)
- Increase in link speeds
- Warranted Collection
- EONBLUE sensor deployment – full take collection
- FORNSAT
- Recently upgraded to current EONBLUE code base, leveraging GCHQ
- CHOKEPOINT solution to integrate with environment (Virtualized)
- Working on SUNWHEEL / SMO
- CHOKEPOINT system enroute to CASSIOPEIA
- No SUNWHEEL presence as of yet, plans to leverage CHOKEPOINT capability
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Current Status – IT Security Deployments
- Deployment at 3 edge gateway GC departments
- Dynamic defence is enabled at two of these sites
- Deployment at the main government backbone
- Dual 10Gbps links (~3Gbps loading)
- Data volumes continue to increase due to Internet Access Point aggregation
- Currently performing full take and storage of all monitored traffic
- System performance issues, overall analyst usability issues
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Divergence – Sensor Deployments
- While both ITS/SIGINT currently leverage EONBLUE software:
- The architectures are not aligned
- Configuration differs greatly
- Software versions are not standard across programs
- The full capability of EONBLUE is not being leveraged equally across programs
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Proposal
CASCADE: A Way Forward
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Problem Statement
- Divergence
- Sensor architectures have diverged between ITS/SIGINT
- Within each area, versions are not standardized
- Management and Scalability
- Some configurations will not scale
- Difficult to manage current sensor environment
- High cost to grow existing solution (people, HW/SW costs)
- Duplication of Effort
- Divergence creates duplication of effort
- Limited resources are not focused on innovation and new challenges
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
A Phased Approach
| Tracking & Metadata Alignment | Full-Take Strategy | Sensor Interoperability | Unified Sensor Environment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Address performance / stability issues with SCNET | Improve Query Performance for Full-Take Data | Extend Native Messaging Between Business Lines | Shared Mission Space |
| Ensure that SIGINT / ITS approach to Tracking / Metadata Production are aligned | Develop / Implement strategy to better do Full-Take | Ensure Targeting is Unified | Single Interconnected Sensor Grid |
| Simplify Version Management | Host / Network Interoperability |
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Tracking and Metadata
Ensure EONBLUE is deployed in a standard fashion across all environments
| Upgrade SCNET to 10Gbps EONBLUE | Update all SIGINT collection sites to latest code release |
|---|
Produce Standard Metadata
| DNS Response Harvesting | HTTP Client / Server Headers | IP-to-IP Flow Summarizations |
|---|
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Full-Take Strategy
Address SCNET Scalability
| Reconfiguration / Design of Storage Solution | Improved / Enforced data indexing and quering |
|---|
Leverage Third-Eye Architecture
| Distributed Collection Grid (at multiple clients) | Queries are Federated and Centrally Managed | Enables unique data ingest at client department (i.e. Firewall Logs) |
|---|
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Full-Take Strategy
- Benefits
- Improve Performance
- Better data indexing techniques
- Federated queries across multiple systems
- Reduced Cost (Storage local to client departments)
- 10,000$ -> 25,000$ per client
- Re-use of back-end Storage
- Enable departmental security officers / operators
- Capability of Third-Eye exceeds what is commercially available
- Improve Performance
- Cons
- Requires network connections to each GC Department
- Requires footprint within each departments datacenter
- Complexity of distributed processing
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Sensor Interoperability
EONBLUE sensors exchange messages to enable more robust selection and filtering
| Messages should be automatically exchanged between SIGINT and ITS/CTEC | The sensor environment will be connected to enable seamless message flows |
|---|
Targeting selectors for Cyber Threats will be unified
| When updates are made to SIGINT sensors the selectors will be automatically replicated for ITS | JAZZFLUTE should support ITS analysts targeting SIGINT systems |
|---|
Simplify Sensor Version Management
| Rapid deployment of new capability seamless across all programs / sites | Distributed Induction (Across WAN) | EBSH: Sensor has custom CLI like a switch and supports inline binary updates |
|---|
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Interoperability enables Synchronization
- ITS access to data collected by SIGINT sensors
- Outputs should be common to enable a common analyst platform
- Sensor environment should be seamlessly integrated
- Capability remains at cutting-edge
- Single release for all collection programs in SIGINT, all points of presence, and across both missions
- Management is simplified for operators, focusing on sensor expansions
- Standardized OS Versions and Optimizations
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Unified Sensor Environment
All Cyber Sensors form a complete eco-system
- Access point is Mandate / Authority Agnostic
- Sensors are Multi-Modal (Defence or Intelligence from any sensor, anytime)
Extend Messaging to Host Based Capabilities
- IT Security Host Based Agents
- CNE implants
Cyber Processing and analytic environments converge
Two-Tier Environment
- Automated / GUI rich environment for operators
- Command-Line Driven RAW access for Discovery
Shared Network Resources for Common Services
- Wiki / Blog / Chat
- NIS / NTP / DNS / Messaging / etc
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Synchronized Deployment Strategy
- Where do you deploy sensors to maximize detection capabilities for Foreign Intelligence collection and Network Defence
- Coverage-based deployment considerations – what are the gaps?
- [REDACTED]
- [REDACTED]
- [REDACTED]
- Threat-based deployment considerations – what are the gaps?
- Based on EPRs
- Threat trends and forecasting reports
- Adversary TTPs
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Canadian Cyber Sensor Grid
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────┐┌─────────────────────────────┐
│ ││ │
│ ┌───────┐ ││ │
│ ┌───────┐ │GC Dept│ ││ │
│ ┌───────┐ │GC Dept│ └┬──────┘ ││ ┌────────────────┐ │
│ │GC Dept│ └────┬──┘ │ ┌───────┐ ││ │Foreign Internet│ │
│ └──┬────┘ │ │┌────────┼GC Dept│ ││ │Space │ │
│ │ │ ││ └───────┘ ││ └──────────┬─────┘ │
│ │ ┌─────┴───────┴┤ ┌───────┐ ││ │ │
│ └─────┤Secure Channel┼────────┼GC Dept│ ││ │ │
│ └─────────────┬┘ └──┬────┘ ││ │ │
│ │ │ ││ │ │
│ │ │ ││ │ │
│ │ │ ││ │ │
│ Defensive Monitoring │ │ ││ FORNSAT │ │
└────────────────────────┼────────────┼───────┘└───────────────┼─────────────┘
┌────────────────────────┼────────────┼───────┐ │
│ ┌──────────────────┴────┐ │ │ ┌─────────────┴──┐
│ │Canadian Internet Space├───────┘ │ │Foreign Internet│
│ └──┬──────────────────┬┬┴───────────────┼──┤Space │
│ │ ││ │ └────────────────┘
│ │ │└────────────────┼──┬────────────────┐
│ ┌─────┴────┐ ┌──┴─────────────┐ │ │Foreign Internet│
│ │System of │ │Foreign Internet│ │ ┌┼Space ├──────────┐
│ │Importance│ │Space │ │ │└────────────────┘ │
│ └──────────┘ └────────────────┘ │ │ ┌────────┐ │
│ │ │ │Foreign │ │
│ │ │ │Internet│ │
│ Special Source / Special Access │ │ │Space │ │
│ Warranted Access │ │ GAZEBO Access └────────┘ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────┘ └────────────────────────────┘
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Towards 2015
Beyond sensor unification
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
CSEC 2015
- Strategic Priorities for CSEC
- Strengthen "Team CSEC" and Prepare for Our New Facility
- Adopt Innovative and Agile Business Solutions
- Expand Our Access Footprint
- Improve Analytic Tradecraft
- Automate Manual Processes
- Synchronize the Cryptologic Enterprise for Cyber Security Mission
- Enable "Effects" for Threat Mitigation
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Cyber Sensor in 2015
- Expand Our Access Footprint
- We will increase SPECIAL SOURCE access to include all international gateways accessible from Canada.
- We will deploy a sensor system that creates a protective grid at multiple layers over Government operations in Canada, and at all classification levels.
- Improve Analytic Tradecraft
- We will equip SIGINT and cyber defence analysts with tools for flexible manipulation and customized analysis of large scale data sets.
- We will build analytic tradecraft that understands, anticipates, and exploits the methodology of threat agents to provide comprehensive cyber- situational awareness based on multiple sources of cryptologic data.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Cyber Sensor in 2015
- Synchronize the Cryptologic Enterprise for the Cyber Security Mission
- We will improve how we anticipate, identify, track and mitigate cyber threats on government systems through new concepts of joint operations.
- We will design and develop joint SIGINT-ITS systems, including common data repositories, joint tasking and analytic systems.
- We will increase operational capacity by ensuring SIGINT, ITS, and cryptologic partner sensors interoperate seamlessly.
- We will synchronize and use ITS and SIGINT capabilities and complementary analyses to thwart cyber threats.
- Enable "Effects" for Threat Mitigation
- We will seek the authority to conduct a wide spectrum of Effects operations in support of our mandates.
- We will build the technical infrastructure, policy architecture and tradecraft necessary to conduct Effects operations.
- We will further integrate ITS and SIGINT authorities and operations to leverage common sensors, systems and capabilities necessary for active and expanded dynamic cyber defence measures.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
The Network Is The Sensor
Principles
Security needs to be transparent to the user in order to be effective
Security is a right for all Canadians
- Federal Government
- Municipal/Provincial Gov
- Critical Infrastructure
- Industry
- The Citizen
End-Users should incur little cost for security
IT Assets should be distributed
Access is mandate / authority agnostic
Goals
Detect threats as they enter our national networks, not at the Gateway
Identify Exfiltration, Command and Control, anywhere in our national networks
The network is your defence for all infrastructure
Rationale
We can't keep pace with our adversary
Gateway / Device / End-Node protection is not sufficient (essential, yes)
Rather than plugging one hole at a time, build better layered defence
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Principles Explained
- Security is Transparent
- If security inhibits functionality, or interferes with user experience it will be bypassed
- Security is a right
- Attempting to protect everybody with end-node / gateway defenses is not feasible.
- IT Assets should be distributed
- We run an open market, network providers will compete to provide access
- Consolidated gateways creates single points of failure
- Cost / Redundancy considerations
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Goals
- Detection before attack hits target
- If we wish to enable defence we must have intelligence to know when attacks enter our national infrastructure
- Identify Exfiltration / Command and Control
- Some attacks will slip through or can't be seen (i.e. shaping)
- Exploit our temporal advantage - aggressively pursue these implants as they will communicate 'home' for instruction
- The Network IS your Defence
- In some cases, in cooperation with our partners we can affect change at the CORE of the Internet on detection:
- Modify traffic routes
- Silently discard malicious traffic (hygiene filtering)
- Insert payload to disrupt adversaries
- In some cases, in cooperation with our partners we can affect change at the CORE of the Internet on detection:
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Rationale
- Keeping pace with the Adversary
- From the time a malicious PDF is opened, till SEEDSPHERE has interactive control of a workstation is <3 minutes
- There are countless malicious actors (state, crime, generic malware)
- Gateway / End-Node Defence by itself is insufficient
- It is only one part of the problem
- Over 600,000 Apps in the iTunes Appstore (How do you secure that?)
- Defence in Depth includes network monitoring, and network interaction
- Build better Defence
- Our current MO is to resolve one incident at a time
- Automate the defence through a robust network capable of not only detection, but manipulation of malicious traffic
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
What does it Mean?
- EONBLUE will be integrated into the Network
- Monitoring Government of Canada
- Monitoring Core Infrastructure (Special Source) extending the reach to view national infrastructure
- Monitoring foreign Internet Space
- EONBLUE will enable defensive operations
- Through robust communication with host-based capabilities
- Through direct manipulation of network communications
- Through interaction with Teleco infrastructure to affect change
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Food for Thought
Changing the way we think
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Changing the way we think
- Tipping and Cueing
- If the purpose is to enable defence of national infrastructure it becomes unnecessary in a 5-eyes context
- We have full visibility of our national infrastructure
- The chance of 'beating' the internet for latency of an attack is minimal
- The network will perform the filtering
- What if instead T&C enables intelligence collection (Cyber Session Collection)?
- If the purpose is to enable defence of national infrastructure it becomes unnecessary in a 5-eyes context
- Targeting and Tasking
- We all share common targets and we will all target using our national capability the cyber threats we know about
- No need for 2nd party tasking / targeting requests. Instead expose cyber information across the community
- What if instead we focus on analytic collaboration and knowledge transfer
- TEXPRO information, federated repositories (malware/traffic), etc
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Changing the way we think
- Foreign SIGINT Intercept
- Becomes the 'hunting ground' for discovery of new threats
- Enables attribution and counter-intelligence reporting
- Defence is taken care of by 'The Network'
- Mobile Platforms are the next frontier, what is their implication on Cyber?
- Domestic Defence
- We will exhaust the treasury deploying network appliances to perform dynamic defence
- The same capabilities will be integrated into the CORE of the Internet
- Defence in Depth through complimentary capabilities on end-nodes, at the gateway, and in the core of the Internet.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Conclusion
- CASCADE
- The harmonization of ITS/SIGINT Sensor capabilities
- Lays the foundation for long-term integration of Cyber within the Cryptologic Enterprise
- Towards 2015
- The Network is the Sensor
- Defence, Mitigation, Intelligence all formed from a single comprehensive network creating a perimeter around Canada
- Extending our reach through 5-eyes partnerships to ensure mutual defence of national assets.
- The Network is the Sensor
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CASCADE
Joint Cyber Sensor Architecture
[REDACTED]
[REDACTED]
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Overview
- Project Overview
- Current Status
- Proposed Architecture
- Towards 2015
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Project Overview
- Alignment of passive cyber sensor capabilities and architecture in the SIGINT and ITS missions
- Goals
- Common sensor technology and architecture
- Address scalability issues in sensor deployments
- Scope
- Passive sensors and supporting infrastructure are in scope
- Analytic tools are out of scope
- Host based capability is out of scope (caveat: passive messaging is in scope)
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
What is the project about?
Define the goal of this project
Is it similar to projects in the past or is it a new effort?
Define the scope of this project
Is it an independent project or is it related to other projects?
- Note that this slide is not necessary for weekly status meetings
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Our Sensors
SIGINT / ITS
- Photonic Prism
- Monitoring of GC Networks
- Includes:
- Full-Take Packet Capture
- Signature Based Detection
- Anomaly Based Discovery
- Analytic Environment
- Oversight Compliance Tools
- EONBLUE
- Monitoring in Passive SIGINT
- Includes:
- Full-Take (on specific accesses)
- Signature Based Detection
- Anomaly Based Discovery
- Additional Functions are offloaded and exist further downstream:
- Analytic Environment
- Dataflow / Targeting
- Oversight and Compliance Tools
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Shades of Blue
=> 10Gbps
EONBLUE
* DELL R610 1U Platform
* TS//SI Processing
* - Tracking / Discovery
* => Content Metadata
=> Multiple 10Gbps
INDUCTION
* Distributed Processing (Cloud)
* TS//SI Processing
* Tracking / Discovery
* PXE Boot Infrastructure
* => Content Metadata
=> Multiple 1Gbps
THIRD-EYE
* Cyber Metadata Processor
* UNCLASSIFIED Processing
* Metadata Production
* => Metadata
=> 10Gbps
CRUCIBLE
* Secure Sensor
* TS//SI Derived (in UNCLASS)
* Tracking
* => Metadata
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Current Status – SIGINT Deployments
- Special Source
- 100% INDUCTION coverage of main SSO sites + metadata production
- THIRD-EYE metadata production at select new sites
- CRUCIBLE deployments to newly emerging sites pre-SCIF environment (survey)
- Increase in link speeds
- Warranted Collection
- EONBLUE sensor deployment – full take collection
- FORNSAT
- Recently upgraded to current EONBLUE code base, leveraging GCHQ
- CHOKEPOINT solution to integrate with environment (Virtualized)
- Working on SUNWHEEL / SMO
- CHOKEPOINT system enroute to CASSIOPEIA
- No SUNWHEEL presence as of yet, plans to leverage CHOKEPOINT capability
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
- If any of these issues caused a schedule delay or need to be discussed further, include details in the next slide.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Current Status – IT Security Deployments
- Deployment at 3 edge gateway GC departments
- Dynamic defence is enabled at two of these sites
- Deployment at the main government backbone
- Dual 10Gbps links (~3Gbps loading)
- Data volumes continue to increase due to Internet Access Point aggregation
- Currently performing full take and storage of all monitored traffic
- System performance issues, overall analyst usability issues
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Divergence – Sensor Deployments
- While both ITS/SIGINT currently leverage EONBLUE software:
- The architectures are not aligned
- Configuration differs greatly
- Software versions are not standard across programs
- The full capability of EONBLUE is not being leveraged equally across programs
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Proposal
CASCADE: A Way Forward
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Problem Statement
- Divergence
- Sensor architectures have diverged between ITS/SIGINT
- Within each area, versions are not standardized
- Management and Scalability
- Some configurations will not scale
- Difficult to manage current sensor environment
- High cost to grow existing solution (people, HW/SW costs)
- Duplication of Effort
- Divergence creates duplication of effort
- Limited resources are not focused on innovation and new challenges
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Duplicate this slide as necessary if there is more than one issue.
This and related slides can be moved to the appendix or hidden if necessary.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
A Phased Approach
| Tracking & Metadata Alignment | Full-Take Strategy | Sensor Interoperability | Unified Sensor Environment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Address performance / stability issues with SCNET | Improve Query Performance for Full-Take Data | Extend Native Messaging Between Business Lines | Shared Mission Space |
| Ensure that SIGINT / ITS approach to Tracking / Metadata Production are aligned | Develop / Implement strategy to better do Full-Take | Ensure Targeting is Unified | Single Interconnected Sensor Grid |
| Simplify Version Management | Host / Network Interoperability |
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Tracking and Metadata
Ensure EONBLUE is deployed in a standard fashion across all environments
| Upgrade SCNET to 10Gbps EONBLUE | Update all SIGINT collection sites to latest code release |
|---|
Produce Standard Metadata
| DNS Response Harvesting | HTTP Client / Server Headers | IP-to-IP Flow Summarizations |
|---|
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Full-Take Strategy
Address SCNET Scalability
| Reconfiguration / Design of Storage Solution | Improved / Enforced data indexing and quering |
|---|
Leverage Third-Eye Architecture
| Distributed Collection Grid (at multiple clients) | Queries are Federated and Centrally Managed | Enables unique data ingest at client department (i.e. Firewall Logs) |
|---|
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Full-Take Strategy
- Benefits
- Improve Performance
- Better data indexing techniques
- Federated queries across multiple systems
- Reduced Cost (Storage local to client departments)
- 10,000$ -> 25,000$ per client
- Re-use of back-end Storage
- Enable departmental security officers / operators
- Capability of Third-Eye exceeds what is commercially available
- Improve Performance
- Cons
- Requires network connections to each GC Department
- Requires footprint within each departments datacenter
- Complexity of distributed processing
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Sensor Interoperability
EONBLUE sensors exchange messages to enable more robust selection and filtering
| Messages should be automatically exchanged between SIGINT and ITS/CTEC | The sensor environment will be connected to enable seamless message flows |
|---|
Targeting selectors for Cyber Threats will be unified
| When updates are made to SIGINT sensors the selectors will be automatically replicated for ITS | JAZZFLUTE should support ITS analysts targeting SIGINT systems |
|---|
Simplify Sensor Version Management
| Rapid deployment of new capability seamless across all programs / sites | Distributed Induction (Across WAN) | EBSH: Sensor has custom CLI like a switch and supports inline binary updates |
|---|
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Interoperability enables Synchronization
- ITS access to data collected by SIGINT sensors
- Outputs should be common to enable a common analyst platform
- Sensor environment should be seamlessly integrated
- Capability remains at cutting-edge
- Single release for all collection programs in SIGINT, all points of presence, and across both missions
- Management is simplified for operators, focusing on sensor expansions
- Standardized OS Versions and Optimizations
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Unified Sensor Environment
All Cyber Sensors form a complete eco-system
- Access point is Mandate / Authority Agnostic
- Sensors are Multi-Modal (Defence or Intelligence from any sensor, anytime)
Extend Messaging to Host Based Capabilities
- IT Security Host Based Agents
- CNE implants
Cyber Processing and analytic environments converge
Two-Tier Environment
- Automated / GUI rich environment for operators
- Command-Line Driven RAW access for Discovery
Shared Network Resources for Common Services
- Wiki / Blog / Chat
- NIS / NTP / DNS / Messaging / etc
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Synchronized Deployment Strategy
- Where do you deploy sensors to maximize detection capabilities for Foreign Intelligence collection and Network Defence
- Coverage-based deployment considerations – what are the gaps?
- [REDACTED]
- [REDACTED]
- [REDACTED]
- Threat-based deployment considerations – what are the gaps?
- Based on EPRs
- Threat trends and forecasting reports
- Adversary TTPs
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Canadian Cyber Sensor Grid
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────┐┌─────────────────────────────┐
│ ││ │
│ ┌───────┐ ││ │
│ ┌───────┐ │GC Dept│ ││ │
│ ┌───────┐ │GC Dept│ └┬──────┘ ││ ┌────────────────┐ │
│ │GC Dept│ └────┬──┘ │ ┌───────┐ ││ │Foreign Internet│ │
│ └──┬────┘ │ │┌────────┼GC Dept│ ││ │Space │ │
│ │ │ ││ └───────┘ ││ └──────────┬─────┘ │
│ │ ┌─────┴───────┴┤ ┌───────┐ ││ │ │
│ └─────┤Secure Channel┼────────┼GC Dept│ ││ │ │
│ └─────────────┬┘ └──┬────┘ ││ │ │
│ │ │ ││ │ │
│ │ │ ││ │ │
│ │ │ ││ │ │
│ Defensive Monitoring │ │ ││ FORNSAT │ │
└────────────────────────┼────────────┼───────┘└───────────────┼─────────────┘
┌────────────────────────┼────────────┼───────┐ │
│ ┌──────────────────┴────┐ │ │ ┌─────────────┴──┐
│ │Canadian Internet Space├───────┘ │ │Foreign Internet│
│ └──┬──────────────────┬┬┴───────────────┼──┤Space │
│ │ ││ │ └────────────────┘
│ │ │└────────────────┼──┬────────────────┐
│ ┌─────┴────┐ ┌──┴─────────────┐ │ │Foreign Internet│
│ │System of │ │Foreign Internet│ │ ┌┼Space ├──────────┐
│ │Importance│ │Space │ │ │└────────────────┘ │
│ └──────────┘ └────────────────┘ │ │ ┌────────┐ │
│ │ │ │Foreign │ │
│ │ │ │Internet│ │
│ Special Source / Special Access │ │ │Space │ │
│ Warranted Access │ │ GAZEBO Access └────────┘ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────┘ └────────────────────────────┘
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Towards 2015
Beyond sensor unification
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
CSEC 2015
- Strategic Priorities for CSEC
- Strengthen "Team CSEC" and Prepare for Our New Facility
- Adopt Innovative and Agile Business Solutions
- Expand Our Access Footprint
- Improve Analytic Tradecraft
- Automate Manual Processes
- Synchronize the Cryptologic Enterprise for Cyber Security Mission
- Enable "Effects" for Threat Mitigation
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Cyber Sensor in 2015
- Expand Our Access Footprint
- We will increase SPECIAL SOURCE access to include all international gateways accessible from Canada.
- We will deploy a sensor system that creates a protective grid at multiple layers over Government operations in Canada, and at all classification levels.
- Improve Analytic Tradecraft
- We will equip SIGINT and cyber defence analysts with tools for flexible manipulation and customized analysis of large scale data sets.
- We will build analytic tradecraft that understands, anticipates, and exploits the methodology of threat agents to provide comprehensive cyber- situational awareness based on multiple sources of cryptologic data.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Cyber Sensor in 2015
- Synchronize the Cryptologic Enterprise for the Cyber Security Mission
- We will improve how we anticipate, identify, track and mitigate cyber threats on government systems through new concepts of joint operations.
- We will design and develop joint SIGINT-ITS systems, including common data repositories, joint tasking and analytic systems.
- We will increase operational capacity by ensuring SIGINT, ITS, and cryptologic partner sensors interoperate seamlessly.
- We will synchronize and use ITS and SIGINT capabilities and complementary analyses to thwart cyber threats.
- Enable "Effects" for Threat Mitigation
- We will seek the authority to conduct a wide spectrum of Effects operations in support of our mandates.
- We will build the technical infrastructure, policy architecture and tradecraft necessary to conduct Effects operations.
- We will further integrate ITS and SIGINT authorities and operations to leverage common sensors, systems and capabilities necessary for active and expanded dynamic cyber defence measures.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
The Network Is The Sensor
Principles
Security needs to be transparent to the user in order to be effective
Security is a right for all Canadians
- Federal Government
- Municipal/Provincial Gov
- Critical Infrastructure
- Industry
- The Citizen
End-Users should incur little cost for security
IT Assets should be distributed
Access is mandate / authority agnostic
Goals
Detect threats as they enter our national networks, not at the Gateway
Identify Exfiltration, Command and Control, anywhere in our national networks
The network is your defence for all infrastructure
Rationale
We can't keep pace with our adversary
Gateway / Device / End-Node protection is not sufficient (essential, yes)
Rather than plugging one hole at a time, build better layered defence
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Principles Explained
- Security is Transparent
- If security inhibits functionality, or interferes with user experience it will be bypassed
- Security is a right
- Attempting to protect everybody with end-node / gateway defenses is not feasible.
- IT Assets should be distributed
- We run an open market, network providers will compete to provide access
- Consolidated gateways creates single points of failure
- Cost / Redundancy considerations
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Goals
- Detection before attack hits target
- If we wish to enable defence we must have intelligence to know when attacks enter our national infrastructure
- Identify Exfiltration / Command and Control
- Some attacks will slip through or can't be seen (i.e. shaping)
- Exploit our temporal advantage - aggressively pursue these implants as they will communicate 'home' for instruction
- The Network IS your Defence
- In some cases, in cooperation with our partners we can affect change at the CORE of the Internet on detection:
- Modify traffic routes
- Silently discard malicious traffic (hygiene filtering)
- Insert payload to disrupt adversaries
- In some cases, in cooperation with our partners we can affect change at the CORE of the Internet on detection:
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Rationale
- Keeping pace with the Adversary
- From the time a malicious PDF is opened, till SEEDSPHERE has interactive control of a workstation is <3 minutes
- There are countless malicious actors (state, crime, generic malware)
- Gateway / End-Node Defence by itself is insufficient
- It is only one part of the problem
- Over 600,000 Apps in the iTunes Appstore (How do you secure that?)
- Defence in Depth includes network monitoring, and network interaction
- Build better Defence
- Our current MO is to resolve one incident at a time
- Automate the defence through a robust network capable of not only detection, but manipulation of malicious traffic
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
What does it Mean?
- EONBLUE will be integrated into the Network
- Monitoring Government of Canada
- Monitoring Core Infrastructure (Special Source) extending the reach to view national infrastructure
- Monitoring foreign Internet Space
- EONBLUE will enable defensive operations
- Through robust communication with host-based capabilities
- Through direct manipulation of network communications
- Through interaction with Teleco infrastructure to affect change
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
Food for Thought
Changing the way we think
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Changing the way we think
- Tipping and Cueing
- If the purpose is to enable defence of national infrastructure it becomes unnecessary in a 5-eyes context
- We have full visibility of our national infrastructure
- The chance of 'beating' the internet for latency of an attack is minimal
- The network will perform the filtering
- What if instead T&C enables intelligence collection (Cyber Session Collection)?
- If the purpose is to enable defence of national infrastructure it becomes unnecessary in a 5-eyes context
- Targeting and Tasking
- We all share common targets and we will all target using our national capability the cyber threats we know about
- No need for 2nd party tasking / targeting requests. Instead expose cyber information across the community
- What if instead we focus on analytic collaboration and knowledge transfer
- TEXPRO information, federated repositories (malware/traffic), etc
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Changing the way we think
- Foreign SIGINT Intercept
- Becomes the 'hunting ground' for discovery of new threats
- Enables attribution and counter-intelligence reporting
- Defence is taken care of by 'The Network'
- Mobile Platforms are the next frontier, what is their implication on Cyber?
- Domestic Defence
- We will exhaust the treasury deploying network appliances to perform dynamic defence
- The same capabilities will be integrated into the CORE of the Internet
- Defence in Depth through complimentary capabilities on end-nodes, at the gateway, and in the core of the Internet.
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY
GLOBAL ACCESS Cyber Defence Operation
Conclusion
- CASCADE
- The harmonization of ITS/SIGINT Sensor capabilities
- Lays the foundation for long-term integration of Cyber within the Cryptologic Enterprise
- Towards 2015
- The Network is the Sensor
- Defence, Mitigation, Intelligence all formed from a single comprehensive network creating a perimeter around Canada
- Extending our reach through 5-eyes partnerships to ensure mutual defence of national assets.
- The Network is the Sensor
CLASSIFICATION: TOP SECRET // COMINT // REL FVEY