Internet Anonymity 2011
Open PDFDocument date: 2011
Pages: 51
Genre: slides
Banner: TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: REL TO USA, FVEY
A TOP SECRET NSA presentation from 2011 providing a comprehensive survey of Internet Anonymity Technologies (IAT) — covering HTTP proxies, VPN anonymity providers, multi-hop networks including Tor and JAP, anonymous remailers and circumvention tools — alongside NSA's capabilities and limitations against each, including XKEYSCORE fingerprints for VPN identification, the PARTNERSNIPPET Tor deanonymisation team, GOLDENFORTIN Netflow data, and a candid assessment that Tor offers "no passive exploitation."
My notes
(C//REL) Internet Anonymity 2011
- NSA (S31323)
- [REDACTED]
- [REDACTED]
- [REDACTED] NSTS
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
1
(C//REL) What is Internet Anonymity?
- (U) Many Possible Meanings/Interpretations
- (S//REL) Simply Not Using Real Name for Email
- (S//REL) Private Forum with Unadvertised Existence
- (S//REL) Unlocatable Endpoint on Internet
- (S//REL) This Talk Concerns Endpoint Location
- (S//REL) The Network Address (IP Address) is Crucial
- (S//REL) It is Not Always Sufficient, However
- (S//REL) Dynamic IP Address
- (S//REL) Mobile Device
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
2
(C//REL) What is Internet Anonymity?
- (S//REL) Anonymity Is Not Simply Encryption
- (S//REL) Encryption Can Simply Hide Content
- (S//REL) Anonymity Masks the MetaData and hence association with user
- (S//SI//REL) Importance of MetaData to SIGINT post-2001 can not be overstated
- (S//REL) There is also anonymity specifically for publishing information
- (S//REL) Beyond the Scope of this Talk!
- (U) Anonymity is the antithesis of most business transactions (but encryption may be crucial)
- (U) Authentication for monetary exchange
- (U) Marketing wants to know customer well
- (U) The same goes for Taxing Authorities :-)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
3
(C//REL) Who Wants Internet Anonymity?
- (U) All Technology is Dual-Use
- (U) Nuclear Weapon to Plug Oil Well
- (U) Homicide by Hammer
- (U) Internet Anonymity for Good
- (U) Anonymous Surveys (Ex: Diseases)
- (U) Human Rights Bloggers
- (U) HUMINT Sources
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
4
(C//REL) Who Wants Internet Anonymity?
- (U) Internet Anonymity for Bad (Semi to Really)
- (U) Copyright Violators (File Sharing)
- (U) Internet Scam Artists
- (U) Pedophiles
- (C//REL) Foreign Intelligence Agents
- (S//REL) Terrorist Actors (Our Concern)
- (U) Both Cases Use Internet Anonymity Technology (IAT)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
5
(S//REL) Internet Censorship: A "Dual"
- (U) Different Scenario
- (U//FOUO) User IP Address known
- (U//FOUO) User Blocked from accessing certain site IP Addresses
- (U//FOUO) Users get around it with Circumvention Technology - Mostly the same as Internet Anonymity Technology (IAT)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
6
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) Single Hop Proxies
- (S//REL) Web Site Proxies
- (S//REL) HTTP/SOCKS Proxies
- (S//REL) Browser Configured to Access
- (S//REL) Proxy Aggregator Sites for Both
- (S//REL) May support SSL/TLS
- (S//REL) HTTP Sites: Only User → Proxy
- (S//REL) SSL Sites (HTTPS)
- (S//REL) Transparent (Just Pass the Bits)
- (S//REL) Man-in-the-Middle (MITM)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
7
(C//REL) Types Of IAT: HTTP Proxies/Aggregators
- (S//REL) Web-Site Proxy Aggregator sites
- (S//REL) May list thousands of proxies
- (S//REL) Taxonomy may be country where hosted
- (S//REL) Taxonomy may be ego/business related
- (S//REL) Taxonomy may be proxy software related
- (S//REL) Taxonomy may be provider related
- (S//REL) Proxy Information IS Temporal
- (S//REL) Requires active confirmation
- (S//REL) Requires revisits
- (S//REL) May list thousands of proxies
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
8
(C//REL) Types Of IAT: HTTP Proxies/Aggregators
- (S//REL) Web Proxy Sites (and Aggregator sites) – Info We Want
- (S//REL) Domain Name (obvious :-) )
- (S//REL) Associated IP address(es)
- (S//REL) Can get live (nslookup, host, dig, etc)
- (S//REL) Can maybe get internally (Foxtrail, NKB, etc.)
- (S//REL) "Exit" IP address (where does user appear?)
- (S//REL) Obtaining manually easy (http://checkip.dyndns.org)
- (S//REL) How to Automate?
- (S//REL) Proxy Discoverer (Originally S31323)
- (S//REL) Other miscellaneous (cookie modification, SSL support, etc.)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
9
(C//REL) Types Of IAT: HTTP Proxies/Aggregators
- (S//REL) Web Proxy Aggregator sites Analysis
- (S//REL) Proxy Discoverer
- (S//REL) Scrapes Aggregator (ie www.proxy.org)
- (S//REL) For each proxy, GET www.checkin.dyndns.org
- (S//REL) Iterate over software, variations
- (S//REL) Glype, PHProxy, CGIProxy, ASP.NET, cURLProxy, Surrogafier, Zelune
- (S//REL) Try multiple times
- (S//REL) Aggregator may give software hints
- (S//REL) Failure may indicate site down, or proxy SW modification
- (S//REL) Results from Proxy Discoverer must bridge low->high
- (S//REL) Operationalized by NAC/RONIN with NTOC support (project PONTENTPOTABLES)
- (S//REL) See SDC2011: [REDACTED]
- (S//REL) Proxy Discoverer
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
10
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Provider may offer multiple servers
- (S//REL) Different Sovereign Nations
- (S//REL) Different Bandwidths
- (S//REL) Most fee based: Can vary on time/number of servers
- (S//REL) May offer multiple VPN protocols
- (S//REL) PPTP (No client software)
- (S//REL) SSH
- (S//REL) OpenVPN
- (S//REL) L2TP/IPSEC
- (S//REL) SSTP
- (S//REL) Communications User ↔ Server Encrypted
- (S//REL) Provider may offer multiple servers
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
11
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Plethora of providers (I found about 200)
- (S//REL) 12VPN, Ace VPN, Air VPN, AlwaysVPN, Ananoos, AnoCentral, Anonine, Anonyproz, AnonymityNetwork, Anonymizer, Anti-Hadopi, Arethusa, ArtofPing, Astrill, BananaVPN, BeeVPN, BlackLogic, BlackVPN, BolchVPN, BuyProxyService, Change-Mon-IP, Cienen, ClearVPN, ConnectInPrivate, ConnectionVPN, CrackIP, Cryptline, Cryptocloud, CyberGhostVPN, DarknetVPN, DrakkerVPN, DoubleVPN, ExpressVPN, Eztun, FBVPN, FlashVPN, FQVPN, Freedur, FreeVPN, GateVPN, GoldenFrogVyprVPN, GoTrusted, HappyVPN, HideIPVPN, HideMyAss, Hideway, High-Speed-VPN, HostSpotVPN, HotspotShield, IAPSSecurityStore, ibVPN, IdealVPN, InvisibleBrowsing, iOpusiPig, IPJET, Ipredator, ItsHidden, Ivacy, IVPN, Ksecure, KeyVPN, Kryptnet, LamniaVPN, LeVPN, LibertyVPN, LifeVPN, Linkideo, Loki, MadVPN, MetroPipe, MicroVPN, MonkeyVPN, Mullvad, MyOpenGateway, MyVPN, Overplay, oVPN, PacketIX, PC-Streaming, PerfectPrivacy, Privacy.io, Privacy.li, PrivacyTunnel, PrivateInternetAccess, PrivateVPN, PRQtunnel, PublicVPN, PureVPN, Relakks, RemoteVPN, RoadWarriorVPN, RootPanama, RoxNetworks, SaferSurf, SecretsLine, SecureNetics, SecureSwiss, SecureTunnel, SecureVPN, SlickyProxy, SmallVPN, SofanetSofaLINK, SteganosInternetAnonymVPN, StrongVPN, SuperVPN, SurfBouncer, SurfoNym, SurfRescue, SwissPVN, SwitchVPN, TheSafety, Tiggerswelt, tonVPN, Trackbuster, trilightzone, TorrentFreedeom, Tunnelr, TUVPN, UkiVPN, UltraVPN, UnblockVPN, USAIP, VIPAccounts, VIPVPN, VPN4ALL, VPNDeutschland, VPNDog, VPNGates, VPNMaster, VPNonline.ru, VPNPrivacy, VPNProNet, VPNSeek, VPNSteel, VPNSwiss, VPNtraffic, VPNTunnel, vpntunnel.se, VPNSecure, VPNod, VPNout, VPNWorld, VyprVPN, Witopia, WorldVPN, WOWVPN, XeroBank, xtra-vpn, YourFreedom, YourPrivateVPN
- (S//REL) Plethora of providers (I found about 200)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
12
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Range of Sovereign Nations/Localities in this set huge!
- (S//REL) Multiple Cities in more popular countries
- (S//REL) Most fee based: Can vary on time/number of servers
- (S//REL) Most notable exception: Hotspot Shield (Provider AnchorFree)
- » (S//REL) Advertising supported
- » (S//REL) Multiple OSINT reports of "most popular"
- (S//REL) About a half dozen others claim they are free
- (S//REL) Most notable exception: Hotspot Shield (Provider AnchorFree)
- (S//REL) Package deals (Europe, any 3 servers, etc.) sometimes available
- (S//REL) Poster child for location selection: IAPS (www.intl-alliance.com)
- (S//REL) AE, AG, AI, AM, AN, AQ, AT, AU, AW, BB, BD, BG, BM, BR, BS, BZ, CA, CH, CL, CN, CO, CR, CU, CY, DK, DO, EE, EG, FJ, GB, GD, GI, GL, GR, GT, HK, HU, ID, IE, IL, IN, IR, IS, JM, JO, JP, KN, KP, KR, KW, KY, LC, LI, LU, MA, MC, MH, MK, MN, MT, MX, MY, NI, NO, NP, NZ, OM, PA, PE, PF, PG, PH, PK, PR, PS, PY, QA, RO, RU, SA, SB, SC, SE, SG, SI, SK, SN, TC, TH, TR, TV, TW, UA, US, UZ, VA, VE, VG, VI, VU, ZA,
- (S//REL) Range of Sovereign Nations/Localities in this set huge!
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
13
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Search of SIGINT Forensics Lab Holdings for OpenVPN
- (S//REL) Using SNAPE Portal
- (S//REL) OpenVPN specifically because a client is required
- (S//REL) Listing is just name of IAT provider
- (S//REL) HotSpot Shield
- (S//REL) Steganos Anonymous VPN
- (S//REL) Securenetics
- (S//REL) General references to using OpenVPN products
- (S//REL) Several references to IP address only: Need more products in RONIN!
- (S//REL) Search of SIGINT Forensics Lab Holdings for OpenVPN
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
14
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) What “we” want
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
- (S//SI//REL) SIGINT: Obvious – target using such a service
- » (S//SI//REL) One hop, so enough coverage means success!
- (S//SI//REL) Compliance: FAA – Is target in US is important!
- (S//SI//REL) SIGINT: Obvious – target using such a service
- (S//REL) Exploiting User ↔ VPN traffic
- (S//SI//REL) Very case by case
- » (S//SI//REL) Coverage (may need 2 sided collection)
- » (S//SI//REL) Protocol (may or may not have vulnerabilities)
- » (S//SI//REL) Settings (implementation important)
- » (TS//SI//REL) “Collateral” - NCSC, TAO, FISA, etc.
- » (S//SI//REL) Request sent to CES if important
- (S//SI//REL) Very case by case
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
- (S//REL) What “we” want
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
15
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
- (S//SI//REL) Manual work with Covered Internet (Linux/Windows)
- » (S//SI//REL) Sometimes info derived from documentation
- » (S//SI//REL) Sometimes need to access service
- » (S//SI//REL) May be a trial version to get "seed"
- » (S//SI//REL) Even if paid may only get some servers
- » (S//SI//REL) Some providers give you the works, YMMV
- » (S//SI//REL) Try to minimize work!
- » (S//SI//REL) Try to extend seed(S//REL)
- » (S//SI//REL) DNS “Pattern”, ex. vpn01.hidegood.net
- » (S//SI//REL) Use scripting/free Linux tools to exhaust space (try nslookup on vpn01.hidegood.net, vpn02.hidegood.net, etc.)
- » (S//SI//REL) Open source DNS enumeration scripts (brief look)
- » (S//REL) Where do results go? (Again, See NAC/RONIN talk)
- (S//SI//REL) Manual work with Covered Internet (Linux/Windows)
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
16
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
- (S//SI//REL) Use the XKEYSCORE, Luke – AKA Fun with X.509
- (S//SI//REL) Prompted by Hotspot Shield (HSS), the free service for which server lists are NOT readily available (Software Reverse Engineering required)
- (S//SI//REL) OpenVPN, as well as SSL/SSTP, send a server x.509 certificate to client as part of setup
- (S//SI//REL) XKEYSCORE sees a LOT of traffic worldwide
- (S//SI//REL) XKEYSCORE fingerprints aren't too hard
- » (S//SI//REL) Need unique string, usually CN and/or DN
- » (S//SI//REL) Check for valid X.509 certificate
- (S//SI//REL) Query safe: Traffic encrypted (still do 1-side defeat)
- (S//SI//REL) Use the XKEYSCORE, Luke – AKA Fun with X.509
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
17
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) VPN Anonymity Providers
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
- (S//SI//REL) Use the XKEYSCORE, Luke – AKA Fun with X.509
- (S//SI//REL) Prompted by Hotspot Shield (HSS), the free service for which server lists are NOT readily available (Software Reverse Engineering required)
- (S//SI//REL) fingerprint('encryption/hotspot_shield/x509') = $pkcs and $udp and 'metrofreefivpn';
- (S//SI//REL) fingerprint('encryption/easy_hide_ip/x509') = $tcp and from_port(8881) and ('\x06\x09\x2a\x86\x48\x86\xf7\x0d\x01\x01\x01'c) /RSA/ and'www.easy-hide-ip.com';
- (S//SI//REL) fingerprint('encryption/comodo_trustconnect/x509') = $tcp and from_port(443) and ('\x06\x09\x2a\x86\x48\x86\xf7\x0d\x01\x01\x01'c) /RSA/ and 'ComodoVPNS-';
- (S//SI//REL) Use the XKEYSCORE, Luke – AKA Fun with X.509
- (S//REL) Server enumeration
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
18
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) Proprietary Multi-Hop Networks (Usually Circumventor Motivated)
- (S//REL) Freegate
- (S//REL) Ultrasurf
- (S//REL) Gpass
- (S//REL) Garden
- (S//REL) Haystack (by Austin Heap – ruled bogus by community)
- (S//REL) Movement to Secure US Government Support to Providers (Congress)
- (S//REL) US Dept of State
- (S//REL) Broadcasting Board of Governors (Independent USG Agency)
- (S//REL) Has instructions for "Getting around Internet Blockage" on Radio Free Asia (RFA) and VOA Persian news sites
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA, FVEY
20
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
- (S//REL) Anonymous Remailers (Multi-Hop)
- (S//REL) Most Secure
- (S//REL) Main examples: Mixmaster and Mixminion
- (S//REL) Extremely High Latency (Random Delays)
- (S//REL) Only useful for email, other store and forward communications
- (S//REL) Not much use
- (S//REL) NOTE 1: Usability and Anonymity are Foes!
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
21
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
(S//REL) Miscellaneous IAT Technologies (Single Hop)
- (S//REL) PSIPHON
- (S//REL) Discussed in Censorship Circumvention Circles
- (S//REL) Technology for known associate to setup in appropriate place
- (S//REL) Access via knowing obscure URL and Username/Password w/HTTPS
- (S//REL) Miscellaneous Multi-Selectors
- (S//REL) Some are just "HTTP and/or Socks Proxy Aggregators"
- (S//REL) EasyHideIP.com
- (S//REL) Real-Hide-IP.com
- (S//REL) Found researching this presentation!
- (S//REL) Both of these yield list with HTTP GET!
- (S//REL) Postprocessing: Shell/PERL/etc. script to extract another to check w/Covered Internet (simple proxy option to wget)
- (S//REL) NAC/RONIN will track these
- (S//REL) Some are just "HTTP and/or Socks Proxy Aggregators"
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
22
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
(S//REL) Miscellaneous IAT Technologies (Single Hop)
- (S//REL) Miscellaneous Multi-Selectors
- (S//REL) Proprietary Proxy Provider/Chooser
- (S//REL) Paid product, Client Software
- (S//REL) Usually involves obfuscation and/or encryption
- (S//REL) GHOSTSURF
- » (S//REL) First analyzed 2006 – uses obfuscaton
- » (S//REL) Server list has changed but all else same
- (S//REL) Easy-Hide-IP
- » (S//REL) Analyzed in 2011 – uses TLS on port 8881
- » (S//REL) Over 400 servers in 7 countries
- (S//REL) Hide-IP
- » (S//REL) Analyzed in 2006 – New product now
- » (S//REL) Need to re-analyze
- (S//REL) Proprietary Proxy Provider/Chooser
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
23
(C//REL) Types Of IAT
(S//REL) Miscellaneous IAT Technologies (Single Hop)
- (S//REL) Bot-Based Proxy Networks
- (U//FOUO) Kudos to [REDACTED], NGA, for pointing this out in her Intelink-TS blog, Sphinx1121 (Pointer to krebsonsecurity.com)
- (S//REL) Bot owners drop socks proxies on compromised computers
- (S//REL) Said proxies are then rented out to "customers" for anonymity
- (S//REL) OSINT indicates a "product" called XSOX available on underground forums as a C&C for such a network
- (S//REL) General Note for IAT analysts: Details IMPORTANT
- (S//REL) Proof by example: EasyHideIp.com NOT the same as Easy-Hide-IP.com (Of course domains are not case sensitive)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
24
(C//REL) Types of IAT
- (S//REL) Open Source Multi-Hop Networks
- (S//REL) Jondo Anonymous Proxy (JAP)
- (S//REL) Championed by German University (Dresden)
- (S//REL) (Mostly?) Open source software – some Docs in German
- (S//REL) Uses a technology known as Cascades
- (S//REL) Each cascade is set of 2 or 3 Mixes
- (S//REL) All internal traffic encrypted
- (S//REL) Free service AN.ON: 5 Cascades
- (S//REL) Premium service JonDoNym: 10 Cascades
- (S//REL) Countries: BG, CA, CH, CZ, DE, DK, FR, GB, IT, LU, US,
- (S//REL) Less than 50 mixes total
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
25
(C//REL) Types of IAT
- (S//REL) Open Source Multi-Hop Networks
- (S//REL) Jondo Anonymous Proxy (JAP)
- (S//REL) Comparison with Tor
- (S//REL) Not nearly as well studied
- (S//REL) Much smaller contained development community
- (S//REL) More centralized structure (all mixes centrally approved)
- (S//REL) Not as diverse geographically or scalable
- (S//REL) Not as well used or publicized
- (S//REL) Not analyzed in great detail here at NSA (or FVEY?)
- (TS//SI//REL) Much better chance for Global Adversary (SIGINT :-) )
- (TS//SI//REL) Sessionization of DNI still would be a problem
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
26
(C//REL) Types of IAT
- (S//REL) Open Source Multi-Hop Networks
- (S//REL) JonDo Anonymous Proxy (JAP)
Browser User A
JAP
Browser User B
JAP
Browser User XYZ
JAP
InfoService
Mix 1 (First Mix)
Mix 2 (Middle Mix)
Mix 3 (Last Mix)
Cache-Proxy
Cache-Proxy
Cache-Proxy
Cache-Proxy
Internet
bidirectional TCP/IP connection
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
27
(C//REL) Types of IAT
- (S//REL) Open Source Multi-Hop Networks
- (S//REL) Tor
- (S//REL) Very widely used worldwide
- (S//REL) Open Source
- (S//REL) Active Development
- (S//REL) Mitigates Threats
- (S//REL) Very Secure
- (S//REL) Low enough latency for most TCP uses
- (S//REL) Still the King of high secure, low latency Internet Anonymity
- (S//REL) There are no contenders for the throne in waiting
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
28
(S//REL) Tor Operation (1)
EFF How Tor Works: 1
Alice
Step 1: Alice's Tor client obtains a list of Tor nodes from a directory server.
Dave
Jane
Bob
Tor node
unencrypted link
encrypted link
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
29
(S//REL) Tor Operation (2)
EFF How Tor Works: 2
Alice
Step 2: Alice's Tor client picks a random path to destination server. Green links are encrypted, red links are in the clear.
Dave
Guard
Middle
Exit
Jane
Bob
Tor node
unencrypted link
encrypted link
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
30
(S//REL) Mom: Where Do Tor Relays Come From?
- (S//REL) Recall there is (well actually more than 1) Tor Directory server?
- (S//REL) This is the pool
- (S//REL) Choices made in terms of advertised capabilities:
- (S//REL) Bandwidth
- (S//REL) Uptime
- (S//REL) Supported Protocols
- (S//REL) Tor client has total final say
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
31
(S//REL) Mom: Where Do Tor Relays Come From?
- (S//REL) Pool is still currently about 1500
- (S//REL) Many countries represented
- (S//REL) Most in DE
- (S//REL) Second most in US
- (S//REL) Anyone can set one up and register it
- (S//REL) Exit nodes are scary (Kiddie Porn)
- (S//REL) Many countries represented
- (S//REL) How about a private pool? (heh-heh)
- (S//REL) Note 2: Private Resources and Anonymity are foes!
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
32
(S//REL) Bridges: Special Tor Relays
- (S//REL) Having the set of relays public makes it easy for government censors
- (S//REL) Just block access to all relays from that country
- (S//REL) Tor Project staffed with smart people!
- (S//REL) Introduce new concept: Bridge Nodes
- (S//REL) Unadvertised Entry Nodes distributed "out-of-band"
- (S//REL) Project will hand out three at a time (weekly)
- (S//REL) Email or surf bridges.torproject.org
- (S//SI//REL) SIGINT: Use Tor Against Itself! (Bridge requests from exit nodes)
- (S//REL) Circa April 2011: Tor Project claims around 600 Bridges
- (S//REL) Introduce new concept: Bridge Nodes
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
33
(S//SI//REL) Tor and NSA Targets
- (TS//SI//REL) Sophisticated CT Targets use TOR to access Terrorist Web Forums
- (TS//SI//REL) Web Forums: al-Faloja, CEMF, al-Hisbah, shumukh, TRSC
- (TS//SI//REL) Persona: DLW, Song of Terror, Time of Terror
- (TS//SI//REL) Visible exit traffic allows for "All except the Client IP" SIGDEV
- (TS//SI//REL) Solving (attempting to solve :-( ) this IP address problem was the work of NSA PARTNERSNIPPET team
- (S//SI//REL) Also 80+ CT email selectors who have used Tor
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
34
(S//SI//REL) Passive Traffic Analysis
- (S//SI//REL) For Normal SIGINT flow, need to identify Tor traffic!
- (S//SI//REL) Only outer TLS layer visible → How to Distinguish?
- (S//SI//REL) Tor developers attempt to remain anonymous by blending in with myriad other TLS traffic
- (S//SI//REL) Tor TLS has changed over the years
- (S//SI//REL) There ARE some server → client features which are recognizable NOW
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
35
(S//SI//REL) Passive Traffic Analysis (2)
- (S//SI//REL) Tor TLS (server → client) startup features
- (S//SI//REL) Certificate: Specific Diffie-Hellman (DH) Modulus (just string match)
- (S//SI//REL) Certificate: Issuer and Subject random names of same form – ex: CN=www.ofzgkdjxvjrss.net (regex match)
- (S//SI//REL) Certificate: Always 2-hour lifetime (ASN.1 format → more intensive computation)
- (S//SI//REL) Several XKS fingerprints and a plugin implemented
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
36
(S//REL) Tor Project Recent Activity
- (S//REL) Driven by Censorship Circumvention, Hide Signature
- (S//REL) New bridge nodes blocked in China
- (S//REL) Researching better bridge distribution strategies
- (S//REL) Claim by Tor Project is 8000 requests/day for <1000 total
- (S//REL) Around Feb 2011, changed the TLS handshake
- (S//REL) Signature more like Apache web-server
- (S//REL) Different DH Modulus
- (S//SI//REL) New XKS Signatures address this
- (S//REL) Signature more like Apache web-server
- (TS//SI//REL) Proposed eventual change will kill identification!
- (S//REL) Each Tor node will generate randomish signatures in a volatile way specifically designed to look like normal website TLS traffic!
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
37
(S//REL) Tor Project Recent Activity
- (S//REL) Tor on non-traditional platforms
- (S//REL) ORBOT, Tor for Android smartphones
- (S//REL) Tor Router Project
- (S//REL) Modified Linksys Router – everything over Tor
- (S//REL) Hide-My-IP-Address
- (S//REL) Proprietary replacement for Tor Browser Bundle
- (S//REL) From "WCCL Network" not part of Tor Project
- (S//SI//REL) Looked at based on reference by CT target
- (S//REL) Tor Project working on better strategies to distribute bridges
- (S//REL) Tails: Complete Bootable OS on CD for anonymity
- (S//REL) Tor is a crucial component
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
38
(S//REL) Tor Hidden Service URLs
- (S//REL) Tor Hidden Services (HS) for anonymous publishing
- (S//REL) Not real reliable, but Tor Project research continues
- (U//FOUO) I said outside scope, sorry
- (S//REL) Tor HS accessed via Tor only by http://xxxxxx.onion
- (S//REL) There is the tor2web.com site which is a HTTP to Tor proxy
- (S//REL) Loses some anonymity but easy to use
- (S//REL) Good tool for Covered Internet research
- (S//REL) Site on WikiInfo to document Tor HS URLs
- (S//REL) "The Onion Realm" - [REDACTED]
- (U//FOUO) Kudos to CES/CTSO (S314) for populating this
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
39
(S//REL) Public IAT Resources Inside
- (U//FOUO) General IAT
- (S//REL) [REDACTED]
- (S//REL) Tor
- (S//REL) [REDACTED]
- (S//REL) [REDACTED]
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
40
(S//REL) References to IAT in SIGINT
- (S//REL) “Grep” in SIGINT reports for relevant phrases (ex anonymity)
- (S//REL) Most is FVEY (cited here) Majority US, also UK, CAN
- (S//SI//REL) Format is TOPI / Type of Info
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Discuss Tor (6 reports)
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use Tor or another proxy
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Create modified Tor
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Mandate use of Tor
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Tor for Censorship Circumvention
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use Tor and a VPN (UltraVPN)
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Instructions for using Tor and other US Proxy
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Discuss us of (non-specified but non-US) VPN
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Discuss Tor and HTTP Proxies for anonymity
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Discuss Tor and RealHideIp (previously unknown IAT)
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Discuss use of Kproxy.com (HTTP Proxy)
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
41
(S//REL) References to IAT in SIGINT
- (S//REL) “Grep” in SIGINT reports for relevant phrases (ex anonymity)
- (S//SI//REL) Format is TOPI / Type of Info
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of PimpMyIp (HTTP Proxy)
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of (masked US Company) VPN (L2TP protocol) for anonymity
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Instructions for use of VPNs for anonymity
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of VPN (HotSpotShield) and SSH tunnels
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of Tor and an unspecified VPN
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of Easy-Hide-IP (Socks proxy chooser)
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of unspecified anonymizing proxy
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Instructions on use of Tor and name-masked US program
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of VPN (Cyberghost)
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Use of unspecified HTTP proxy
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Questions on whether Tor is compromised
- (TS//SI//REL) CT / Questions on whether associated compromised by IAT non-use
- (S//SI//REL) Format is TOPI / Type of Info
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
42
(S//REL) References to IAT in SIGINT
- (S//REL) “Grep” in SIGINT reports for relevant phrases (ex anonymity)
- (S//SI//REL) Format is TOPI / Type of Info
- (TS//SI//REL) Iran / Use of Freegate and Ultrasurf
- (TS//SI//REL) India / Use of unknown proxy for anonymity
- (TS//SI//REL) India / Use of Tor to access a webmail account
- (TS//SI//REL) India / Use of Tor for hacking (2 reports)
- (TS//SI//REL) India / Provision of list of socks proxies to use
- (TS//SI//REL) Iran / Provision of list of socks proxies to use
- (TS//SI//REL) India / Use of unknown proxy for anonymity
- (TS//SI//REL) Cuba / Use of unknown proxy for anonymous research
- (TS//SI//REL) Turkey / Use of Tor
- (S//SI//REL) Format is TOPI / Type of Info
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
43
(U) Backup Slides
- (S//REL) From Last years SDC Tor Talk
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
44
(S//REL) Tor (The onion router)
- (S//REL) Development originally NRL funded
- (S//REL) Original developers from Anonymous Remailer Research Community
- (S//REL) Project now a US non-profit (www.torproject.org)
- (S//REL) User to Internet site interaction uses 3 hops through Tor "Relays"
- (S//REL) Entry
- (S//REL) Middle
- (S//REL) Exit
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
45
(S//REL) Tor Security
- (S//SI//REL) As you can see from the diagram, everything except for final hop is encrypted.
- (S//SI//REL) The final hop may be also in the case of Bob being an SSL site.
- (S//SI//REL) Two-layer TOR encryption: Pipe between any 2 nodes TLS encrypted (Only thing seen externally).
- (S//SI//REL) Inside the TLS is the Onion Routing (see following diagram):
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
46
(S//REL) Tor Security (2)
- (S//SI//REL) So each node can only decrypt data between its predecessor and itself and only knows about its predecessor and successor.
- (S//SI//REL) The exit node can read the final traffic if it is not SSL.
- (S//SI//REL) The user Tor client is in control of everything
- (S//SI//REL) Setting up keys for cryptography
- (S//SI//REL) Choosing the Entry, Middle, and Exit
- (TS//SI//REL) Tor is very good – No passive exploitation :-(
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
47
(S//REL) Tor Onion Encryption
Layers of the onion
Router A Key
Router B Key
Router C Key
Message
Routing path
Source -> Router A -> Router B -> Router C
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
48
(S//SI//REL) Passive Traffic Analysis (3)
- (S//REL) NSA Network Analysis Center (NAC) data source GOLDENFORTIN
- (S//REL) Cisco Netflow Records
- (U) From IP Address
- (U) To IP Address
- (U) Time Up
- (U) Time Down
- (U) Number of Bytes
- (U) Number of Packets
- (S//REL) Heavy Representation of Tor Relays
- (S//REL) Cisco Netflow Records
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
49
(S//SI//REL) Passive Traffic Analysis (4)
- (S//SI//REL) How to use Tor network data?
- (S//SI//REL) Attempt to work back from known exit traffic of interest all the way back to client user
- (S//SI//REL) This is “Circuit Reconstruction”
- (S//SI//REL) Requires great coverage
- (S//SI//REL) Geography might be your friend sometimes
- (S//SI//REL) Attempt to correlate known exit traffic to a small set of putative client traffic
- (S//SI//REL) Client Geographical Assumption Required
- (TS//SI//REL) No smoking gun yet :-( Optimism still lives!
- (S//SI//REL) Attempt to work back from known exit traffic of interest all the way back to client user
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
50
(TS//SI//REL) Active: Traffic Shaping
- (S//SI//REL) This primarily means deny/degrade to date
- (TS//SI//REL) If target is behind a choke point to Internet
- (TS//SI//REL) Block all or a major subset of Tor Relays
- (TS//SI//REL) Block all Tor TLS handshakes
- (TS//SI//REL) Try to force target to use alternate communications means
- (TS//SI//REL) If target is behind a choke point to Internet
- (S//SI//REL) Always the (potential) Exploit vs Attack Tradeoff
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
51
(TS//SI//REL) Active: Implants
- (S//SI//REL) TorButton: A Thorn in the side of SIGINT
- (S//REL) One of the components of The Tor Browser Bundle – AKA "Tor for Dummies"
- (S//REL) Firefox browser plugin – on/off switch for Tor
- (S//REL) Locks down browser REAL good (disables all active content things, sandboxes state, etc.)
- (TS//SI//REL) No current bypass methods for CNE Exploits
- (TS//SI//REL) Only hope is implanting web server with poisoned content document intended for target
TOP SECRET//COMINT REL TO USA,FVEY
52