TURMOIL VPN PROCESSING

Open PDF
Creating agency: NSA National Security Agency (US)
Document date: 2009-10-27
Pages: 20
Genre: slides
Banner:
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: REL TO USA, FVEY

A TURMOIL VPN Processing technical briefing from October 2009 describing the full architecture for intercepting and decrypting IPSec VPN traffic within the TURMOIL passive collection platform — covering IKE/ESP protocol handling, five distinct data flow types, the Dell LPT hardware implementation, and live operational metrics showing over 8 million packets decrypted at Menwith Hill and 1.4 million at SMOKYSINK during a single week in October 2009.

Long Description:
This is a TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY technical briefing dated 27 October 2009, published by Der Spiegel under the German title "Verarbeitung von Daten aus angegriffenen VPN im TURMOIL Programm" ("Processing of data from attacked VPNs in the TURMOIL programme"). The document provides a comprehensive technical overview of how TURMOIL intercepts, processes and decrypts IPSec VPN traffic, covering protocol fundamentals, customer requirements, data flow architectures, hardware implementation and live operational statistics. The document opens with unclassified protocol background covering the four IPSec components TURMOIL targets: ISAKMP for key exchange framework, IKE for the key exchange mechanism itself, ESP for encrypted payload traffic, and AH for authentication and integrity. Packet header diagrams for IKE/ISAKMP (UDP port 500), ESP (IP protocol 50) and AH/ESP (IP protocol 51) are provided. A key operational constraint is stated explicitly: collection requires dwell time and link diversity because there is no guarantee that IKE and ESP traffic will traverse the same cable link — meaning a collection site may see the key exchange but not the encrypted payload, or vice versa, requiring multiple selectors targeting both external VPN tunnel IP addresses for decryption and internal IP addresses for content targeting. The customer needs section maps four NSA organisations to their VPN intelligence requirements. SIGINT analysts (TOPI) need decrypted traffic for reporting. The Network Analysis Center (NAC) needs IKE and ESP metadata to identify target VPNs and report their IP addresses and links. The Office of Target Pursuit (OTP) needs metadata, encrypted surveys and unencrypted surveys to search for VPNs of intelligence value. The Systems Analysis Office (SAO) needs metadata, encrypted surveys and decryption quality data to identify VPN technologies and vulnerabilities. Five distinct data flow types are described, each serving different customer needs. The Metadata Dataflow provides full-take IKE/ISAKMP metadata and sampled ESP metadata (1/16th sampling rate) routed through TUBE, FALLOUT and EXOPUMP to TOYGRIPPE and PRESSUREWAVE. The Transform Dataflow decrypts selected VPN sessions and re-injects the recovered plaintext application sessions back into TURMOIL for standard selection and forwarding to TUBE, EXOPUMP and PRESSUREWAVE. The Survey Dataflow combines decryption with forwarding to XKEYSCORE, routing decrypted sessions to SIGDEV analysts for target development. The Analyze Dataflow captures raw encrypted IKE and ESP sessions without attempting decryption, forwarding them to PRESSUREWAVE via EXOPUMP for cryptanalytic analysis. The TransformQA Dataflow captures sessions that fail decryption using the POISONNUT-provided key, routing them for quality assurance investigation. The Transform and Survey dataflow diagrams show the full component chain in detail: TURMOIL's PIQ Blade communicates with POISONNUT via ISLANDTRANSPORT with ISLANDHIDEAWAY encryption, sending IKE messages and ESP key requests and receiving decrypted session keys. The CES XML Gateway and CES Firewall mediate communications between TURMOIL and the CES enclave. GRAM (Grid Resource Allocation Manager) manages HPC resources for cryptanalytic processing, with CORAL REEF providing cryptovariable management. VPN Metrics are separately tracked. The Dell LPT hardware implementation section shows a three-ENDACE-card architecture across two physical chassis, with POISONNUT handling IKE sessions and ESP key requests, PIQ Services performing decryption, and an IP Payload Decompressor and Packet Injector re-inserting recovered packets back into the TURMOIL Stage 1 pipeline via MBUS. A CCM/KEYCARD component handles IP address targeting for the re-injection stream. The IKE metadata sequence diagram shows the detailed processing pipeline: raw IKE packets enter through FSPF keyword matching, pass through an AEG and DFID Allocator, proceed to IKE EventToBME for metadata extraction, through IKE SMG for sessionisation, to the ASDF Reporter, then via TUBE and FALLOUT to TOYGRIPPE. The operational metrics section provides live statistics for the week of 14-22 October 2009 across four deployed systems. MHS_LIVE (Menwith Hill Station live system) processed 26,501 key requests, received 12,200 key responses, and decrypted 8,041,883 packets. SMK6 (SMOKYSINK) processed 43,087 key requests, received 4,755 responses, and decrypted 1,413,532 packets. MHS_DEV and MHS_LPT show zero key responses and zero packets decrypted, indicating development systems not yet in operational use. The SMK6 designation confirms this document was written contemporaneously with the SPIN 15 VPN Story document describing the SMOKYSINK deployment, with operational decryption already underway at that site by October 2009. Taken together this document is the most technically detailed published account of how TURMOIL's VPN decryption pipeline actually functions end to end — from passive interception of encrypted traffic at cable taps, through key recovery via POISONNUT, to re-injection of decrypted plaintext back into the collection stream for analyst access. The live metrics confirm the system was operational at scale at Menwith Hill and SMOKYSINK at the time of writing.

TURBULENCE

TURMOIL VPN PROCESSING

27 October 2009

[REDACTED]

The overall classification for this brief is:
[TOPSECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY]


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Agenda

  • VPN Technology Overview
  • Dataflows and Interfaces
  • LPT Implementation
  • Metrics

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY
TURBULENCE

Overview – VPN Mission Opportunity

(S//SI//REL) Exploit Virtual Private Network (VPN) communications that use IP Security (IPsec) algorithms and protocols:

  • (U) ISAKMP – Internet Security Association and Key Management Protocol (RFC2407, RFC2408) provides an authentication and key exchange framework.
  • (U) IKE – Internet Key Exchange (RFC2409) provides authentication and key exchange mechanisms.
  • (U) ESP - Encapsulating Security Payload (RFC2406) provides traffic confidentiality (encryption) and optional integrity protection.
  • (U) AH – Authentication Header (RFC2402) provides integrity protection that includes IP Header. Sometimes AH is used to wrap ESP for additional integrity.
ISAKMP/IKE Phase 1
Unencrypted Handshake
ISAKMP/IKE Phase 1
ISAKMP/IKE Phase 2
Encrypted Handshake
ISAKMP/IKE Phase 2

ISAKMP SA
Security Association Database
ESP SA
Cleartext
ESP
IP Source
Encrypted Data
ESP
Cleartext
IP Destination
Security Association Database
ISAKMP SA
ESP SA

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

IKE-ISAKMP Protocol

                           UNCLASSIFIED

               Internet Key Exchange (IKE – RFC 2409)
               Internet Security Association and Key Management
                        Protocol (ISAKMP - RFC 2408)

0                   1                   2                   3
 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|Version|  IHL  |Type of Service|          Total Length         | IP
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|         Identification        |Flags|      Fragment Offset    |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|  Time to Live | Protocol = 17 |         Header Checksum       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                         Source Address                        |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                      Destination Address                      |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|       Source Port = 500       |    Destination Port = 500     | UDP
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|             Length            |            Checksum           |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                                                               |
|                        Initiator Cookie                       | IKE /
----------------------------------------------------------------- ISAKMP
|                                                               | Header
|                        Responder Cookie                       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|  Next Payload | Mj Ver| Mn Ver| Exchange Type |     Flags     |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                           Message ID                          |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                             Length                            |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                                                               |
|                     Key Management Data ...                   |
|                                                               |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
                           UNCLASSIFIED

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

ESP Protocol

                           UNCLASSIFIED

               Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP - RFC 2406)

0                   1                   2                   3
 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|Version|  IHL  |Type of Service|          Total Length         | IP
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|         Identification        |Flags|      Fragment Offset    |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|  Time to Live | Protocol = 50 |         Header Checksum       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                         Source Address                        |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                      Destination Address                      |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                   Security Parameter Index (SPI)              | ESP
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|                         Sequence Number                       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                                                               |
|                       Encrypted Data ...                      |
|                                                               |
-----------------------------------------------------------------

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

AH-ESP Protocol

                           UNCLASSIFIED

               Authentication Header (AH - RFC 2402)
           Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP - RFC 2406)

0                   1                   2                   3
 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|Version|  IHL  |Type of Service|          Total Length         | IP
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|         Identification        |Flags|      Fragment Offset    |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|  Time to Live | Protocol = 51 |         Header Checksum       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                         Source Address                        |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                      Destination Address                      |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
| Next Header=50|  Header Length |           Reserved           | AH
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|                   Security Parameter Index (SPI)              |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                         Sequence Number                       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                                                               |
|                Integrity Check Value (ICV)                    |
|                      (Variable Length)                        |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                   Security Parameter Index (SPI)              | ESP
----------------------------------------------------------------- Header
|                         Sequence Number                       |
-----------------------------------------------------------------
|                                                               |
|                       Encrypted Data ...                      |
|                                                               |
-----------------------------------------------------------------

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Overview – VPN IPsec Collection

00:00                                                                                                  24:00
Hours                                                                                                  Hours
                                  
                 Internal IP Addresses     Internal IP Addresses            Internal IP Addresses 
           (10.160.0.84 to 10.161.27.111)  (10.160.0.84 to 10.161.27.111)   (10.160.0.76 to 10.161.27.112)
                 Tunneled IP Sessions      Tunneled IP Sessions             Tunneled IP Sessions
                   /-------------\        /------------\         /------------\
  +-------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+-------+-----+
  |  IKE  |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |  IKE  | AH/ |
<-| Phase | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase | Phase | ESP |->
  |   1   |   2   |              |   2   |              |   2   |              |   1   |   2   |     |
  +-------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+-------+-----+
  |                                                                                                  |
  \__________________________________________________________________________________________________/
                                    VPN Tunnel External IP Addresses
                                    (172.3.105.3 to 192.168.100.86)
  • (TS//SI//REL) Collection requires dwell time to capture IKE associated with ESP
  • (TS//SI//REL) Collection requires link diversity to capture IKE associated with ESP
    (S//SI//REL) There is no guarantee that IKE and ESP will use the same link.
  • (S//SI//REL) Collection requires multiple selectors to target external and tunneled sessions
    (S//SI//REL) VPN Tunnel External IP Addresses – To Target Decryption
    (S//SI//REL) Strong Selectors on Internal IP Links – To Target VPN Content

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Overview – Customer Needs

Customer Functions Needs
SIGINT Analyst (TOPI) •Target and Analyze Traffic
•Report SIGINT
•Target IDs, Target Links, Target Value
•Unencrypted Targeted Traffic
Network Analysis Center (NAC) •Identify target VPN's
•Report VPN Target IDs and Links
•VPN IKE and ESP Metadata
Office of Target Pursuit (OTP) •Search and survey for VPN's of interest
•Report VPN Traffic Intelligence Value
•VPN IKE and ESP Metadata
•VPN Encrypted Surveys
•VPN Unencrypted Surveys
Systems Analysis Office (SAO) •Identify VPN Technologies
•Identify VPN Vulnerabilities
•Support VPN Exploitation
•VPN IKE and ESP Metadata
•VPN Encrypted Surveys
•VPN Decryption Quality
00:00                                                                                              24:00
Hours                                                                                              Hours
                       OTP                    OTP                     OTP
                       TOPI                   TOPI                    TOPI
                Tunneled IP Sessions   Tunneled IP Sessions    Tunneled IP Sessions
                   /------------\        /-------------\         /------------\
  +-------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+-------+-----+
  |  IKE  |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |  IKE  | AH/ |
<-| Phase | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase | Phase | ESP |->
  |   1   |   2   |              |   2   |              |   2   |              |   1   |   2   |     |
  +-------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+-------+-----+
   \_____________/ \____________/ \____/  \____________/ \_____/ \____________/ \_____________/
         NAC            OTP         NAC        OTP         NAC        OTP             NAC
         OTP            SAO         OTP        SAO         OTP        SAO             OTP
         SAO                        SAO                    SAO                        SAO

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Overview – VPN Products

Target Protocol
   * IP Security (IPsec)
   * Internet Key Exchange (IKE)
   * Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)

TURBULENCE
VPN

Target Protocol
   * IP Security (IPsec)
   * Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP)

Target Protocol
   * IP Security (IPsec)
   * Authentication Header (AH) /
   * Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP)

IP Address Selector Actions
   * Transform
   * Transform & NoTransformQA
   * Transform & Survey
   * Transform & Survey & NoTransformQA
   * Analyze
   * Transform & Analyze
   * Transform & Analyze & NoTransformQA
   * Transform & Analyze & Survey
   * Transform & Analyze & NoTransformQA & Survey

Products / Dataflows
   * VPN metadata with full-take IKE and sampled ESP (Metadata Dataflow)
   * Selected application sessions recovered from VPN sessions selected for decryption and re-injection (Transform dataflow)
   * VPN sessions selected for decryption and survey (Survey dataflow)
   * Encrypted VPN sessions selected for analysis (Analyze Dataflow)
   * Encrypted VPN sessions selected for decryption that fail to decrypt using VAO provided key (TransformQA Dataflow)

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Overview - Needs and Products

Customer Needs Products
SIGINT Analyst (TOPI) •Target IDs, Target Links, Target Value
•Unencrypted Targeted Traffic
•Transform Dataflow
Network Analysis Center (NAC) •VPN IKE and ESP Metadata •Metadata Dataflow - IKE Fulltake
•Metadata Dataflow – ESP Samples
Office of Target Pursuit (OTP) •VPN IKE and ESP Metadata
•VPN Encrypted Surveys
•VPN Unencrypted Surveys
•Metadata Dataflow – IKE Fulltake
•Metadata Dataflow – ESP Samples
•Analysis Dataflow
•Survey Dataflow
Systems Analysic Office (SAO) •VPN IKE and ESP Metadata
•VPN Encrypted Surveys
•VPN Decryption Quality
•Metadata Dataflow - IKE Fulltake
•Metadata Dataflow – ESP Samples
•Analysis Dataflow
•TransformQA Dataflow
00:00                                                                                              24:00
Hours                                                                                              Hours

                               Transform Dataflow     Survey Dataflow
                                       \              /
                                        \            /
                       OTP               \    OTP   /                 OTP
                       TOPI               \   TOPI /                  TOPI
                Tunneled IP Sessions   Tunneled IP Sessions    Tunneled IP Sessions
                   /------------\        /-------------\         /------------\
  +-------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+-------+-----+
  |  IKE  |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |              |  IKE  |  IKE  | AH/ |
<-| Phase | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase |    AH/ESP    | Phase | Phase | ESP |->
  |   1   |   2   |              |   2   |              |   2   |              |   1   |   2   |     |
  +-------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+--------------+-------+-------+-----+
   \_____________/ \____________/ \____/  \____________/ \_____/ \____________/ \_____________/
   |     NAC   |        OTP   |     NAC        OTP   |     NAC        OTP  |       |  NAC
   |     OTP   |        SAO   |     OTP        SAO   |     OTP        SAO  |       |  OTP
   |     SAO   |              |     SAO              |     SAO             |       |  SAO
   |            \             \                      \                     |        \
   |             \             \                      \                    |         \
Metadata       Metadata       Metadata              Analysis           TransformQA    Analysis
Dataflow       Dataflow       Dataflow              Dataflow           Dataflow       Dataflow

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Dataflows and Interfaces - Metadata (Classic)

  Internet Key Exchange (IKE) / Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)
 <================================================================================>
       AH / ESP (Authentication Header / Encapsulating Security Payload)
 <================================================================================>

 +----------+        +--------+        +-----------+
 |          |  VPN8  |        |  VPN5  |           |
 | EXOPUMP  |<-------+  TUBE  |<-------+  TURMOIL  |
 |          |        |        |        |           |
 +----------+        +--------+        +-----------+
      |                                      |
      |  VPN8:                    VPN5:      |
      |  T: MAILORDER             T: Socket Connection
      |  C: IKE/AH/ESP Records    C: IKE/AH/ESP Records
      |  F: SOTF                  F: SOTF
      |
      | VPN10                         VPN12              VPN13
      | T: ITx (JMS)                  T: ITx (JMS)       T: MAILORDER
      | C: IKE/AH/ESP Records         C: IKE Records     C: IKE Sessions
      | F: XML/SOTF                   F: SOTF            F: TGIF
      |
      v
 +-----------+        +--------------------+        +-----------+
 |           |        |    METROTUBE       |        |           |
 | PRESSURE- +------->+  +--------------+  +------->| TOYGRIPPE |
 |   WAVE    |        |  | VPN Analytic |  |        |           |
 |           |        |  +--------------+  |        |           |
 +-----------+        +--------------------+        +-----------+

 Interface Key:
   T = Transport
   C = Content
   F = Format
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN IKE/ISAKMP Metadata in TOYGRIPPE is full-take
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN ESP Metadata Sessions in PRESSUREWAVE is sampled (1/16th)
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN AH/ESP Metadata Sessions in PRESSUREWAVE is sampled (1/16th)

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Dataflows and Interfaces – IKE Metadata (New and Improved!)

                 SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
   Internet Key Exchange (IKE) / Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)
<===============================================================================================>
                                               VS-IKE-MD1
VS-IKE-MD2                                     T: Socket Connection
T: MAILORDER                                   C: IPsec/IKE Records
C: IPsec/IKE Metadata     ___________+------+  F: SOTF                 +---------+   Interface Key
F: ASDF                  |           | TUBE |------------------------->| TURMOIL |   T = Transport
                         |           +------+  VS-IKE-MD3              +---------+   C = Content
                         |                     T: MAILORDER                          F = Format
                         v                     C: IPsec/IKE Metadata
                  +---------+                  F: ASDF                   +-----------+
                  | FALLOUT |------------------------------------------->| TOYGRIPPE |
                  +---------+                                            +-----------+
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN IKE/ISAKMP Metadata in TOYGRIPPE is full-take
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN ESP Metadata Sessions in PRESSUREWAVE is sampled (1/16th)
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN AH/ESP Metadata Sessions in PRESSUREWAVE is sampled (1/16th)

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Dataflows and Interfaces - ESP Metadata

                 SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
     Authentication Header (AH) / Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP)
<===============================================================================================>
                                               VS-ESP-MD1
VS-ESP-MD2                                     T: Socket Connection
T: MAILORDER                                   C: IPsec/ESP Metadata Bundles
C: IPsec/ESP Metadata     ___________+------+  F: ASDF in SOTF         +---------+   Interface Key
F: ASDF                  |           | TUBE |------------------------->| TURMOIL |   T = Transport
                         |           +------+  VS-ESP-MD3              +---------+   C = Content
                         |                     T: MAILORDER                          F = Format
                         v                     C: IPsec/ESP Metadata
                  +---------+                  F: ASDF                   +-----------+
                  | FALLOUT |------------------------------------------->| TOYGRIPPE |
                  +---------+                                            +-----------+

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Dataflows and Interfaces - Analyze

     Internet Key Exchange (IKE) / Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)
<=====================================================O=========================================>
                                                      |   Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP)
<=====================================================c==O======================================>
         VPN6                                         |  |    VPN1
         T: Socket Connection                         |  |    T: Socket Connection
         C: IKE & ESP Sessions selected for Analysis  v  v    C: Selector Hit Query/Response
+------+ F: SOTF                                 +---------+  F: Binary                   +---------+
| TUBE |<--------------------------------------->| TURMOIL |<---------------------------->| KEYCARD |
+------+                                         +---------+                              +---------+
   |        VPN9                                          VPN11                                         Interface Key
   |        T: MAILORDER                                  T: ITx (JMS)                                  T = Transport
   v        C: IKE / ESP Sessions Selected for Analysis   C: IKE & ESP Sessions Selected for Analysis   C = Content
+---------+ F: SOTF                                       F: XML/SOTF          +--------------+         F = Format
| EXOPUMP |------------------------------------------------------------------->| PRESSUREWAVE |
+---------+                                                                    +--------------+
  • (U//FOUO) KEYCARD IP Target Action must be ANALYZE
  • (U//FOUO) Full-take of IKE/ESP Sessions.
  • (U//FOUO) No Analytic at this time

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Dataflows and Interfaces - Survey

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

Internet Key Exchange (IKE) / Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)
<================================O==========================================================================>
                                 |     Authentication Header (AH) / Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP)
<================================c====O=====================================================================>
                                 |    |                                                                     Interface Key  
                                 |    |         VPN1                                                        T = Transport
                                 v    v         T: Socket Connection                                        C = Content
                                +---------+     C: Selector Hit Query/Response                              F = Format
                                | TURMOIL |     F: Binary                               +---------+
                                |         |<------------------------------------------->| KEYCARD |                      +-----------+
VPN7                            |         |                                             +---------+                      | HPC       |
T: Socket Connection            |         |     VPN18                                                                    | RESOURCES |
C: Encrypted and Decrypted      |         |     T: Secure Socket (SSL)                                                   +-----------+
   Application Sessions         |         |     C: PIQ Blade Management                                 +------------+      ^
F: SOTF                         | --------|     F: WebSA                                +-----------+   | Grid       |      |
                                | |  PIQ  |<------------------------------------------->| DOC / CES |   | Resource   |<------
+-----------+                   | | Blade |                                             +-----------+   | Allocation |
| XKEYSCORE |<------------------| |       |     VPN4                 +----------+   +-------------+     | Manager    |
+-----------+                   | |       |     T: ITx               | CES      |   | VPN Metrics |     | (GRAM)     |
                                | |       |     C: IKE Messages      | XML      |   +-------------+     +------------+
                                | |       |     F: IH(SOAP)          | Gateway  |        ^                   ^
                                | |       |--------------------------|----------|-->+----|---------+         |
                                | |       |     VPN3                 |          |   | POISON NUT   |<---------
                                | |       |     T: ITx               | CES      |   | Attack       |
                                | |       |     C: ESP Key Req/Res   | Firewall |   | Orchestrator |                 +-------+
                                | |       |     F: IH(SOAP)          |          |   | (AO)         | <-------------->| CORAL |  
                                +---------+<-------------------------|----------|-->|              | Cryptovariables | REEF  |
                                                                     +----------+   +--------------+                 +-------+
  • (U//FOUO) KEYCARD IP Target Action must be TRANSFORM & SURVEY
  • (TS//SI//REL) Candidate Sessions for Decryption include BME:
    vpnID = "08000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001”
  • (TS//SI//REL) Decrypted Sessions include BME:
    vpnID ≠ "08000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001"

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Dataflows and Interfaces - Transform

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

Internet Key Exchange (IKE) / Internet Security Association Key Management Protocol (ISAKMP)
<==========================================O==========================================================================>
                                           |     Authentication Header (AH) / Encapsulating Security Payload (ESP)
<==========================================c====O=====================================================================>
         VPN6                              |    |                                                                   Interface Key
         T: Socket Connection              |    |       VPN1                                                        T = Transport
         C: Selected Application Sessions* v    v       T: Socket Connection                                        C = Content
         F: SOTF                     +------------+     C: Selector Hit Query/Response                              F = Format
+------+                             | TURMOIL    |     F: Binary                               
| TUBE |<----------------------------|            |                                             +---------+
+------|                             |            |<------------------------------------------->| KEYCARD |
 |                                   |            |                                             +---------+
 |         Note                      |            |
 | * Selected Application Sessions   |            |
 | are identified and selected from  |            |
 | the decrypted packets extracted   |            |
 | from the VPN tunnel and inserted  |            |
 | into the TURMOIL input stream.    |            |
 |                                   |            |
 |                                   |            |                                                                              +-----------+
 | VPN9                              |            |                                                                              | HPC       |
 | T: MAILORDER                      |            |     VPN18                                                                    | RESOURCES |
 | C: Selected Application Sessons*  |            |     T: Secure Socket (SSL)                                                   +-----------+
 | F: SOTF                           |                  C: PIQ Blade Management                                 +------------+      ^
 |                                   | -----------|     F: WebSA                                +-----------+   | Grid       |      |
 v                                   | |  PIQ     |<------------------------------------------->| DOC / CES |   | Resource   |<------
+---------+                          | | Services |                                             +-----------+   | Allocation |
| EXOPUMP |                          | |          |     VPN4                 +----------+   +-------------+     | Manager    |
+---------+                          | |          |     T: ITx (JMS)         |          |   | VPN Metrics |     | (GRAM)     |
 |                                   | |          |     C: IKE Messages      | CES      |   +-------------+     +------------+
 |                +-----------+      | |          |     F: IH(SOAP)          | XML      |        ^                   ^
 ---------------> | PRESSURE- |      | |          |                          | Gateway  |        |
 VPN11            | WAVE      |      | |          |--------------------------|----------|-->+--------------+         |
 T: ITx (JMS)     +-----------+      | |          |     VPN3                 |          |   | POISON NUT   |<---------
 C: Selected Application Sessions*   | |          |     T: ITx (JMS)         | CES      |   | Attack       |
 F: XML/SOTF                         | |          |     C: ESP Key Req/Res   | Firewall |   | Orchestrator |                 +-------+
                                     | |          |     F: IH(SOAP)          |          |   | (AO)         | <-------------->| CORAL |
                                     +------------+<-------------------------|----------|-->|              | Cryptovariables | REEF  |
                                                                             +----------+   +--------------+                 +-------+
  • (TS//SI//REL) PIQ Blade provides PIQ-Services, PICARESQUE ECI Compartmented
  • (TS//SI//REL) Transform is Sanitization of Decrypt
  • (S//SI//REL) VPN AH/ESP Session Transform capability is not available in Spin 12
  • (U//FOUO) KEYCARD IP Target Action must be TRANSFORM
  • (TS//SI//REL) Decrypted sessions have BME vpnID ≠ "08000000-0000-0000-0000-000000000001"

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

VPN on Dell LPT

TOP SECRET//COMIN T//REL TO USA, FVEY

                                                                                                                                 |        ENDACE 2                                                                                  |
                                                                                                                                 |    +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+     |
               ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--->| Stage 1                                               +--------------------+ VPN      |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    |                                                       | VPN TE             | Sessions |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    |                                                       | +-----+   +------+ |          |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    |                                               _______>| | FIP |-->| TDAL | |--------  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    | +-------+       +-----+          +--------+   |       | +-----+   +------+ |       |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    | | Delay |------>| FCP |--------> | Packet |----       +--------------------+       |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    | +-------+       +-----+          | Router |   |       +---------------------+      |  |     |
               | TBUS                                                                                                            |                                       +--------+   ------->| Other TE's          |      |  |     |
               | Packets                                                                                                         |                                     s Hits)                | +-----+    +------+ |      |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |                                                            | | FIP |--->| TDAL | |----  |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |                                                            | +-----+    +------+ |   |  |  |     |
               |                                                      ___________________________________________________________|______________________________________                      +---------------------+   |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |       ENDACE 1                                                                                 |                                       Sessions |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |  +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+     |---------+  Metadata                            |  |  |     |
               -------------------------------------------------------|->| Stage 1                                               +--------------------+ VPN      |     |etadata  |-------                               |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |  |                                                       | VPN TE             | Sessions |     |rocessor |      v                               |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |  |                                                       | +-----+   +------+ |          |     |---^-----+-+---------+--------------------------|--|--+     |
               |                                                      |  |                                               _______>| | FIP |-->| TDAL | |------    |     |   |       | Stage 2 |<--------------------------  |        |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+       +-----+          +--------+   |       | +-----+   +------+ |      |   |     |___|_______+---------+_____________________________|________|
               |                                                      |  | | Delay |------>| FCP |--------> | Packet |----       +--------------------+      |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+       +-----+          | Router |   |       +---------------------+     |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |     ^              ^             +--------+   ------->| Other TE's          |     |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |     |              | ppfEvents (Hits)                 | +-----+    +------+ |     |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |     |              |                                  | | FIP |--->| TDAL | |---- |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+        +-----+                              | +-----+    +------+ |   | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | | XFPSF |------->| PPF |                              +---------------------+   | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+        +-----+                                               Sessions | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |                     |        +-----------+  Metadata                            | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |           ppfEvents -------->| Metadata  |-------                               | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |           (Metadata)         | Processor |      v                               | |   |     |   |                                               |
      +----------------+                                              |  +------------------------------+-----^-----+-+---------+--------------------------|-|---+     |   |                                               |
      | Stage 0        |                                              |                                       |       | Stage 2 |<-------------------------- |         |   |                           ____________________|
      |        +-----+ |          SRI                                 |_______________________________________|_______+---------+____________________________|_________|   |                           |
      |        | DFA | |-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------                           |
      |        +-----+ |                                                                      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
      +-----------^----+                                             _________________________|________________________________________________________________________________________________________|____
                  |                                                  |                        |                 CCM / KEYCARD                                                                          |   |
                  |                                                  |                        |              +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ |   |
                  |                                                  |                        |              | Stage 1                                               +--------------------+ VPN      | |   |
* IKE Sessions    |       +-----------------+                        |      +------+    +-----v------+       |                                                       | VPN TE             | Sessions | |   |
* ESP Req/Resp    |       |      PIQ        |  Encrypted             |      | VPN  |    | IPSec      |       |                                                       | +-----+   +------+ |          | |   |
+--------+        |       |       __________|________________________|______| TDAL |<---| Forwarding |       |                                               _______>| | FIP |-->| TDAL | |----------|--   |
| POISON |        |       |   +---v------+  |  Sessions              |      +------+    +------------+       | +-------+       +-----+          +--------+   |       | +-----+   +------+ |          |     |
|  NUT   |<-------|-------|-> | PIQ      |  |                        |                                       | | Delay |------>| FCP |--------> | Packet |----       +--------------------+          |     |
+--------+        |       |   | Services |__|________________________|__________                             | +-------+       +-----+          | Router |   |       +---------------------+         |     |
                  |       |   +----------+  |  Decrypted Packets     |         |                             |     ^              ^             +--------+   ------->| Other TE's          |         |     |
                  |       +-----------------+                        |         v                             |     |              | ppfEvents (Hits)                 | +-----+    +------+ |         |     |
                  |                                                  |   +--------------+                 -->|     |              |                                  | | FIP |--->| TDAL | |----     |     |
                  |                                                  |   | IP Payload   |                 |  | +-------+        +-----+                              | +-----+    +------+ |   |     |     |
                  |--------------------------------------------------|-->| Decompressor |                 |  | | XFPSF |------->| PPF |                              +---------------------+   |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   +--------------+                 |  | +-------+        +-----+                                               Sessions |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   +----------+                     |  |                     |        +-----------+  Metadata                            |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   | Packet   | MBUS Packets (SOTF) |  |           ppfEvents -------->| Metadata  |-------                               |     |     |
                  |--------------------------------------------------|-->| Injector |_____________________|  |           (Metadata)         | Processor |      v                               |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   +----------+                        +------------------------------+-----^-----+-+---------+--------------------------|-----+     |
                  |                                                  |                                                                            |       | Stage 2 |<--------------------------           |
                  |                                                  |____________________________________________________________________________|_______+---------+______________________________________|
                  |                                                                                                                               |
                  |--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

VPN on Dell LPT

TOP SECRET//COMIN T//REL TO USA, FVEY

                                                                                                                                 |        ENDACE 2                                                                                  |
                                                                                                                                 |    +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+     |
               ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--->| Stage 1                                               +--------------------+ VPN      |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    |                                                       | VPN TE             | Sessions |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    |                                                       | +-----+   +------+ |          |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    |                                               _______>| | FIP |-->| TDAL | |--------  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    | +-------+       +-----+          +--------+   |       | +-----+   +------+ |       |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    | | Delay |------>| FCP |--------> | Packet |----       +--------------------+       |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |    | +-------+       +-----+          | Router |   |       +---------------------+      |  |     |
               | TBUS                                                                                                            |                                       +--------+   ------->| Other TE's          |      |  |     |
               | Packets                                                                                                         |                                     s Hits)                | +-----+    +------+ |      |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |                                                            | | FIP |--->| TDAL | |----  |  |     |
               |                                                                                                                 |                                                            | +-----+    +------+ |   |  |  |     |
               |                                                      ___________________________________________________________|______________________________________                      +---------------------+   |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |       ENDACE 1                                                                                 |                                       Sessions |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |  +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+     |---------+  Metadata                            |  |  |     |
               -------------------------------------------------------|->| Stage 1                                               +--------------------+ VPN      |     |etadata  |-------                               |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |  |                                                       | VPN TE             | Sessions |     |rocessor |      v                               |  |  |     |
               |                                                      |  |                                                       | +-----+   +------+ |          |     |---^-----+-+---------+--------------------------|--|--+     |
               |                                                      |  |                                               _______>| | FIP |-->| TDAL | |------    |     |   |       | Stage 2 |<--------------------------  |        |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+       +-----+          +--------+   |       | +-----+   +------+ |      |   |     |___|_______+---------+_____________________________|________|
               |                                                      |  | | Delay |------>| FCP |--------> | Packet |----       +--------------------+      |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+       +-----+          | Router |   |       +---------------------+     |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |     ^              ^             +--------+   ------->| Other TE's          |     |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |     |              | ppfEvents (Hits)                 | +-----+    +------+ |     |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |     |              |                                  | | FIP |--->| TDAL | |---- |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+        +-----+                              | +-----+    +------+ |   | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | | XFPSF |------->| PPF |                              +---------------------+   | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  | +-------+        +-----+                                               Sessions | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |                     |        +-----------+  Metadata                            | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |           ppfEvents -------->| Metadata  |-------                               | |   |     |   |                                               |
               |                                                      |  |           (Metadata)         | Processor |      v                               | |   |     |   |                                               |
      +----------------+                                              |  +------------------------------+-----^-----+-+---------+--------------------------|-|---+     |   |                                               |
      | Stage 0        |                                              |                                       |       | Stage 2 |<-------------------------- |         |   |                           ____________________|
      |        +-----+ |          SRI                                 |_______________________________________|_______+---------+____________________________|_________|   |                           |
      |        | DFA | |-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|--------------                           |
      |        +-----+ |                                                                      ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|
      +-----------^----+                                             _________________________|________________________________________________________________________________________________________|____
                  |                                                  |                        |                 CCM / KEYCARD                                                                          |   |
                  |                                                  |                        |              +---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------+ |   |
                  |                                                  |                        |              | Stage 1                                               +--------------------+ VPN      | |   |
* IKE Sessions    |       +-----------------+                        |      +------+    +-----v------+       |                                                       | VPN TE             | Sessions | |   |
* ESP Req/Resp    |       |      PIQ        |  Encrypted             |      | VPN  |    | IPSec      |       |                                                       | +-----+   +------+ |          | |   |
+--------+        |       |       __________|________________________|______| TDAL |<---| Forwarding |       |                                               _______>| | FIP |-->| TDAL | |----------|--   |
| POISON |        |       |   +---v------+  |  Sessions              |      +------+    +------------+       | +-------+       +-----+          +--------+   |       | +-----+   +------+ |          |     |
|  NUT   |<-------|-------|-> | PIQ      |  |                        |                                       | | Delay |------>| FCP |--------> | Packet |----       +--------------------+          |     |
+--------+        |       |   | Services |__|________________________|__________                             | +-------+       +-----+          | Router |   |       +---------------------+         |     |
                  |       |   +----------+  |  Decrypted Packets     |         |                             |     ^              ^             +--------+   ------->| Other TE's          |         |     |
                  |       +-----------------+                        |         v                             |     |              | ppfEvents (Hits)                 | +-----+    +------+ |         |     |
                  |                                                  |   +--------------+                 -->|     |              |                                  | | FIP |--->| TDAL | |----     |     |
                  |                                                  |   | IP Payload   |                 |  | +-------+        +-----+                              | +-----+    +------+ |   |     |     |
                  |--------------------------------------------------|-->| Decompressor |                 |  | | XFPSF |------->| PPF |                              +---------------------+   |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   +--------------+                 |  | +-------+        +-----+                                               Sessions |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   +----------+                     |  |                     |        +-----------+  Metadata                            |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   | Packet   | MBUS Packets (SOTF) |  |           ppfEvents -------->| Metadata  |-------                               |     |     |
                  |--------------------------------------------------|-->| Injector |_____________________|  |           (Metadata)         | Processor |      v                               |     |     |
                  |                                                  |   +----------+                        +------------------------------+-----^-----+-+---------+--------------------------|-----+     |
                  |                                                  |                                                                            |       | Stage 2 |<--------------------------           |
                  |                                                  |____________________________________________________________________________|_______+---------+______________________________________|
                  |                                                                                                                               |
                  |--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

Sample stats : 14-22 Oct 2009

System KeyRequests KeyResponses KeyNotRecovered Packets Decrypted
MHS_DEV 8076 0 0 0
MHS_LIVE 26501 12200 0 8041883
MHS_LPT 1725 0 0 0
SMK6 43087 4755 0 1413532

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY


TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA FVEY

TURBULENCE

IKE Metadata Sequence

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO FVEY

  • Stage 0
    • IKE Packets
  • FSPF
    • Keywords
    • Matched IKE packets
  • AEG
  • DFID Allocator
    • IKE Metadata
    • SRI & Application M/D
  • IKE EventToBME
    • IKE Metadata Bundles
  • IKE SMG
    • IKE Metadata Sessions
  • ASDF Reporter
    • ASDF Bundles
  • TUBE
    • ASDF Bundles
  • FALLOUT
    • IKE ASDF Metadata
  • TOYGRIPPE

ppf events
SOTF
ASDF events
ASDF

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA EVEY