Content-Metadata Matrix

Open PDF
Creating agency: GCHQ Government Communications Headquarters (UK)
Document date: 2010-01-20
Pages: 3
Genre: guide
Banner:
Classification: UK SECRET STRAP 1 COMINT
Dissemination: AUS,CAN,NZ,UK,US,ORCON

GCHQ's internal taxonomy sorts intercepted data into "content" or "metadata" to determine what can be searched without individual warrants—email subject lines, full URLs, and buddy lists fall on opposite sides of the line, enabling analysts to mine massive troves of IP addresses, phone numbers, location data, and browsing history with just a few keystrokes and a brief justification.

Long Description:
This document is GCHQ's operational cheat sheet for categorizing intercepted communications under UK law, specifically the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA). It provides a detailed taxonomy of digital artifacts—email headers, IP addresses, chat handles, search strings, voice calls, attachments, cookies, keystroke logs, and more—assigning each a data class code and a legal label: "content" (c) or "metadata" (m). The distinction matters enormously, as RIPA treats "communications data" (metadata) as less intrusive and thus subject to lower legal thresholds for collection than the actual content of messages. Items like email body text, voice calls, and SMS are unambiguous content; phone numbers, IP addresses, and "to/from" lines are metadata; but grey zones exist—email subject lines, URLs beyond the domain name, and address books are tagged as content, while buddy lists and folder names count as metadata. Ambiguous categories like "content-derived data" (speaker gender, language fingerprinting, content summarization) occupy a liminal space, flagged as potentially eligible for metadata treatment "due to low level of intrusion." The table underscores how legal definitions shape surveillance practice—and how agencies parse technical minutiae to maximize collection under permissive interpretations of "communications data." Coordinated across the Five Eyes (AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US), it's a shared legal playbook for lawful but expansive intercept operations.

UK SECRET STRAP1
COMINT AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US EYES ONLY ORCON

CONTENT OR METADATA?
Categorisation of aspects of intercepted communications - GCHQ policy guidance.

POCS: [REDACTED] of GCHQ OPP-LEG [REDACTED] @gchq.gov.uk) and [REDACTED] of GCHQ OPP-HQ [REDACTED] @gchq.gov.uk).
Date last verified: 20 January 2010 by [REDACTED] Version 2.

Data type sorted by data class (column B; defined below) Class (see below) Content (c) or Metadata (m) Note: For convenience, the terms "Metadata", "Events" and "Communications Data" are often used interchangeably, although only the last is defined in UK law (RIPA).
attachment to e-mail, eg routing diagram, picture, video a c
e-mail address in the body of a message a c
name of a file attached to an e-mail a c
authentication data to a communications service: login ID, userid, password ac m unless sent inside the body of a communication
an e-mail inside a message c c
bulletin board posting c c
chat-room discussions c c
content of a voice call c c
content of an e-mail c c
cookie as a whole (some elements are listed separately below) c c
DTMF data, as opposed to dialling c c
keystroke logs c c
search results c c
search strings c c
SMS or IM text c c
video c c
voice mail boxes c c
web cam transmissions c c
web forms filled in by people c c
'to' 'from', 'cc', 'bcc', and 'fwd' lines within e-mail header ca m
chat aliases, chat handles and other related or similar identifiers ca m
e-mail address from a cookie sent to set up a communication channel ca m
IMEI data ca m
IMSI caller ID ca m
IP addresses of the computers sending and receiving the message ca m
machine ID extracted from cookies (eg Yahoo B cookies) ca m

UK SECRET STRAP1
COMINT AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US EYES ONLY ORCON

UK SECRET STRAP1
COMINT AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US EYES ONLY ORCON

Data type sorted by data class (column B; defined below) Class (see below) Content (c) or Metadata (m) Note: For convenience, the terms "Metadata", "Events" and "Communications Data" are often used interchangeably, although only the last is defined in UK law (RIPA).
personal IDs extracted from cookies, mail headers, chat sessions or buddy lists ca m
telephone number ca m
content summarization cdd cdd
file type of an attachment to an email cdd cdd
language or language fingerprinting cdd cdd
speaker's gender cdd cdd
speaker's ID cdd cdd
e-mail subject line ch c
dialling, signalling, routing, addressing or signalling information d m
call charge records, including info about the time and length of a call d m
Calling Line Identification, including numbers dialled d m
details of routers and IP addresses that have handled the message d m
DTMF dialling (not data) d m
location of parties to a communication, not derived from content d m
logs of visitors to chat rooms including how often they have visited/posted d m
network management, eg billing, authentication or tracking of communicants d m
start and finish time of an internet session or phone call d m
status of chat sites, ie whether they are active and how many participants d m
URLs up to and including the domain name d m
session initiation protocols d m
website registers including owner details; assume not UKUSA owned/registered d m
creation of/access to draft message m m N.B. the contents of a draft message are Content.
history of websites browsed (full URLs) m c
buddy lists for web mail, instant messenger or social networking m m
folders used to organise e-mails m m
address books or contacts lists for web mail etc m c
crypto keys m c
password to internet or telephony services other than communications services m c
URLs beyond the domain name, ie one that may include search terms m c

UK SECRET STRAP1
COMINT AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US EYES ONLY ORCON

UK SECRET STRAP1
COMINT AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US EYES ONLY ORCON

Data type sorted by data class (column B; defined below) Class (see below) Content (c) or Metadata (m) Note: For convenience, the terms "Metadata", "Events" and "Communications Data" are often used interchangeably, although only the last is defined in UK law (RIPA).

Coding of data classes

  • a - attachment
  • ac - authentication of communications
  • c - content
  • ca - communications address
  • cdd - content derived data; some types in this class may be able to be treated as communications data due to low level of intrusion
  • ch - content header
  • d - traffic data including network management (excludes any such data sent inside the body of a communication, eg by a CSP)
  • m - miscellaneous; some types in this class may be able to be treated as communications data
  • bulk unselected: as taken from bearers without filtering or selection, save for national sensitivities

UK SECRET STRAP1
COMINT AUS/CAN/NZ/UK/US EYES ONLY ORCON