LEVITATION and the FFU Hypothesis

Open PDF
Creating agency: CSE Communications Security Establishment (Canada)
Document date: 2012
Pages: 21
Genre: slides
Banner:
Classification: TOP SECRET SI
Dissemination: REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

This document describes LEVITATION, a top-secret Canadian Communications Security Establishment (CSE) project that monitors millions of daily file uploads and downloads from free file-sharing sites to identify potential extremist activity. It details the program’s data collection methods, analytical workflow, use of partner databases, and examples of successful discoveries related to terrorist materials and hostage videos.

Long Description:
This LEVITATION document outlines a top-secret program operated by Canada’s Communications Security Establishment (CSE), developed to identify and track potential extremist activities through large-scale surveillance of free file upload (FFU) websites. The project, part of the broader Five Eyes intelligence network, used behavioral and hypothesis-based analytics to detect suspicious downloads or uploads among the roughly 10 to 15 million daily events observed across more than 100 popular file-sharing sites such as Sendspace, RapidShare, and MegaUpload. By examining patterns in user activity, CSE analysts aimed to isolate a small number of “documents of interest” related to extremist propaganda, training materials, or bomb-making guides, while filtering out vast amounts of benign content. The system’s workflow relied on automated data processing and correlation tools, integrating inputs from multiple databases and “special sources.” When a suspicious file transfer was detected, analysts used partner intelligence databases—such as the UK’s MUTANT BROTH and the NSA’s MARINA—to trace related IP addresses, cookies, and social media profiles, allowing them to map online behaviors and potentially identify individuals involved. The presentation includes examples of such findings, including the discovery of a German hostage video and an Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM) hostage strategy document. LEVITATION represents a sophisticated example of mass data mining, combining metadata analysis, behavioral modeling, and cross-agency intelligence sharing. While the document frames the project as an innovative analytical effort to automate extremist detection, it also illustrates the scale and intrusiveness of such surveillance systems, which indiscriminately capture global user data in the process of isolating a few actionable leads.
Programs:
LEVITATION, STALKER, ATOMIC BANJO, OLYMPIA, MUTANT BROTH, MARINA

People mentioned:
-

Countries:
Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, Palestine, Spain, Syria, Germany, Kuwait, Senegal, Bahrain, Canada, Jordan, Morocco, Qatar, Brazil, Portugal, Kenya, United Arab Emirates

Tags:
CSE, Five Eyes, intelligence sharing, mass surveillance, signals intelligence, metadata analysis, behavioral analysis, hypothesis-driven analysis, counterterrorism, extremism, jihad, data mining, file sharing, file upload, free file upload sites, FFU, cyber surveillance, automated analysis, web traffic analysis, HTTP, big data, pattern recognition, user profiling, machine learning, web forums, forums, internet surveillance, NSA collaboration, GCHQ collaboration, global surveillance, data repository, web operations center, CWOC, selectors, cookie tracking, Facebook, IP geolocation, user identification, anonymizers, statistical analysis, automation, data processing, network traffic analysis

Identifier:
cse-levitation-cbc-news-15-0128

PDF SHA-256:
9c87473d94f37a2211e1edb0c99a1578dfadcacf95a062b8506f6f447cfccc43

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

LEVITATION and the FFU Hypothesis

[REDACTED]
[REDACTED]@cse-cst.gc.ca


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

What is LEVITATION?

  • A behaviour-based target discovery project
  • Multi-disciplinary team
  • Prototyping and delivering advances in:
    • Behavioural tradecraft
    • Hypothesis tradecraft
    • Tradecraft automation

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Current Hypotheses

Active

FFU
[REDACTED]
[REDACTED]
[REDACTED]
Sequential numbers
Obvious selector names
Web search terms

In Development

GPS waypoints
Devices close to places
Telephony gaps
[REDACTED]
Targets of foreign SIGINT agencies
Missed calls


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

FFU Hypothesis

Extremists use Free File Upload (FFU) sites differently than the general public.

Al-Qaida uses FFU sites to distribute Jihadist propaganda

Extremists use FFU sites to distribute training materials

اصنع سلاحك بنفسك
القنابل اليدوية

GREN
FRAG
5.69 COM

مؤسسة المهاجر الإعلامية

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

What do we need?

A list of suspect documents
A list of FFU URLs referring to those documents
A list of IPs downloading those URLs

New documents are found by CWOC (CSEC Web Operations Centre) retrieval from URLs, so that's the easy part.


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

New URLs

CSEC's web forums team
2nd Party reports & alerts
Machine Learning
Learning the textual context for the URLs in web forums
HTTP Referrers
Follow URL referrers back to the originating site

Previous Correlations analysis
Using tech techniques to figure out what else that user was up to at the same time
e.g. Google analytics cookies


Get STALKER Hostnames
String operations
Build SQL for STALKER Referers
Dummy 1
Query FFU for STALKER Referers
TC Init
Generate Rows
Calculator
Build SQL for referers count
Filter out images
Memory Group by
Sort rows
Select values 2
Filter out heavy hiters
Dummy 3
Query referers count
Dummy 2
Select values
IP Geo and Network Info
Dummy 4
Dummy 5
Filter out Referer count = 1
Prepare deduping string
Filter out duplicates
Add constants
FFU Requests Master List
Remove spaces
Stream lookup
TC Init 2
Output duplicated URLs
Format Date
Mail New URLs
Get Variables
Mail Configs
Blocking Step
New URLs File
Select values 4
Output new URLs

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

FFU Events Collection

ATOMIC BANJO (Special Source) is collecting HTTP metadata for 102 known FFU sites.

sendspace

RAPIDSHARE
EASY FILEHOSTING

MEGAUPLOAD

We see about 10-15 million FFU events per day
All the FFU Events are available thru OLYMPIA


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Looking for a few good documents

We only care about the 2,200 URLs that point to documents of interest.

e.g. How to make a gas bomb
www.sendspace.com/file/[REDACTED]
Every day we sort through the 10–15M events for the interesting ones.
We're finding about 350 interesting download events per month.

- إدخال الورق
المقوى
العلبة
محتويات العلبة
من الداخل

Nestle

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Documents vary

Chloroform in a Lowes bucket

Bajadin Explosives Manual

And lots of pictures of cars on fire

شكل المنبه من الداخل
هو جري
تغذ
انه به سلکی
سلك سلك

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Filtering out Glee Episodes

Create HTTP_RLINE SQL
Dummy 1
Query HTTP_RLINE
TC Init
Geo
Sort by time
Master List Extremist Documents URLs
Create UTC Date
Get URL Length
Convert String IPs
Master FFU Hits
Add constants
Stream lookup
Create HTTP_LOCATION SQL
Dummy 2
Query HTTP_LOCATION
Filter rows
Processed FFU records
New FFU records

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Resulting events

FFU Hits
Computer shares (\\corp) (R:) Share_1 Levitation FFU FFU Hits
File Edit View Tools Help Search FFU Hits
Organize Open New folder
Favorites
Desktop
Downloads
Recent Places
Libraries
Desktop
Documents
Music
Pictures
Videos
Computer
Windows (C:)
DVD Drive (D:)
[REDACTED]\\corp\users\csec_users) (H:)
shares (\\corp) (R:)
Reserved
Share_1
Share_2
Share_3
Share_4
Share_5
Share_6
Tempshare
apps (\\corp\groups\sigint) (S:)
Network
Control Panel
Recycle Bin
CERRID DM Extension
SQL Developer
XMind
sqldeveloper-3.1.06.82
Name Date modified Type Size
01-20-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]raq 06/03/2012 10:27 File folder
01-20-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED] Iraq 06/03/2012 8:32 AM File folder
01-20-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Saudi Arabia 07/02/2012 12:15... File folder
01-21-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Yemen 19/03/2012 11:47... File folder
01-21-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Occupied Palestinian Territory 08/03/2012 10:36... File folder
01-21-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Saudi Arabia 10/02/2012 1:41 PM File folder
01-22-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Occupied Palestinian Territory 07/02/2012 12:15... File folder
01-23-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Spain 09/02/2012 10:41 File folder
01-25-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Syria 06/03/2012 12:20... File folder
01-27-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]UK 06/03/2012 12:38... File folder
01-28-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Occupied Palestinian Territory 09/02/2012 10:54... File folder
01-31-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Syria 05/03/2012 10:26... File folder
02-01-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]US 05/03/2012 10:36. File folder
02-02-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Spain 07/02/2012 12:17... File folder
02-06-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Germany 08/03/2012 9:35 AM File folder
02-13-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Yemen 23/03/2012 10:02... File folder
02-13-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]US 08/03/2012 9:52 AM File folder
02-14-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Kuwait 05/03/2012 10:57... File folder
02-15-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Senegal 22/03/2012 12:25. File folder
02-17-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Bahrain 09/03/2012 8:57 AM File folder
02-18-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Canadian Anonymizer 05/03/2012 1:16 PM File folder
02-20-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Jordan 09/03/2012 8:55 AM File folder
02-22-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Morocco 09/03/2012 8:54 AM File folder
02-24-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Yemen 09/03/2012 9:50 AM File folder
02-28-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Qatar 09/03/2012 2:26 PM File folder
02-28-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Kuwait 20/03/2012 9:33 AM File folder
02-28-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Brazil 20/03/2012 9:53 AM File folder
03-01-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Jordan 22/03/2012 12:45... File folder
03-03-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Yemen 22/03/2012 1:18 PM File folder
03-03-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Portugal 27/03/2012 10:59... File folder
03-04-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Canadian Anonymizer 22/03/2012 1:29 PM File folder
03-07-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Kenya 27/03/2012 12:58... File folder
03-07-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Yemen 28/03/2012 11:07... File folder
03-10-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Jordan 28/03/2012 11:13... File folder
03-16-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Jordan 28/03/2012 1:09 PM File folder
03-20-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED]Morocco 29/03/2012 11:18... File folder
FFU From Mathieu 09/03/2012 3:02 PM Microsoft Excel W... 19 KB
01-20-2012 FFU Hit Selecto[REDACTED] Date modified: 06/03/2012 10:27 AM Offline status: Online
File folder Offline availability Not available

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Start analysis with event info

FFU hit from selector [REDACTED] on
7/03/2012 7:46:51 geolocated to Kenya,
accessing The Explosives Course through
FFU site sendspace.com with HTTP user
agent Mozilla/5.0 (Ubuntu; X11; Linux
x86_64; rv:9.0.1) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/
9.0.1

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Correlating other selectors with the IP

FFU hit from selector [REDACTED] on
7/03/2012 7:46:51 geolocated to Kenya,
accessing The Explosives Course through
FFU site sendspace.com with HTTP user
agent Mozilla/5.0 (Ubuntu; X11; Linux
x86_64; rv:9.0.1) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/
9.0.1

Can we correlate any other selectors with this IP address?

Mutant Broth query on IP [REDACTED] for 5 hours on either side of 7/03/2012 7:46:51
682 events including 77 with an exact match of the user agent above yielding
a Facebook ID [REDACTED]a Google Prefid Cookie [REDACTED] an
M_Adnxs Uuid2 Cookie [REDACTED] an M_Quantserve Mc Cookie
and a Google Prefid Cookie [REDACTED]

New Selectors
FFU Hit Selector [REDACTED] March 7, 2012. Mutant Broth query.xlsx [REDACTED]


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Correlating Facebook cookie

FFU hit from selector [REDACTED] on
7/03/2012 7:46:51 geolocated to Kenya,
accessing The Explosives Course through
FFU site sendspace.com with HTTP user
agent Mozilla/5.0 (Ubuntu; X11; Linux
x86_64; rv:9.0.1) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/
9.0.1

Can we correlate any other selectors with this Facebook ID Cookie?

Open Source research indicates that the user of Facebook ID [REDACTED]s based in Dubai, United Arab Emirates

Marina Profile Query on Facebook User Cookie [REDACTED] observed in Mutant Broth Query above

Lots of events including registration email address [REDACTED]@gmail.com and Facebook name [REDACTED]

New Selectors
FFU Hit Selector [REDACTED] March 7, 2012. Marina Profile Query on Facebook ID [REDACTED]xlsx

Mutant Broth Sub-Query on Facebook User Cookie [REDACTED] observed in Mutant Broth Query above

946 events with 893 matching exactly the user agent above

FFU Hit Selector [REDACTED] March 7, 2012. Mutant Broth Sub-Query on Facebook ID [REDACTED]xlsx


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

IP Correlation

FFU Hits Analysis.kjb MUTANTBROTH TDIs.ktr
100%
Hide the execution results pane

Get rows from result
Multi-Threads
Cut justification to 150 chars
MUTANT BROTH
Filter Empty Result
MB Raw Results
Sort by Sequence
Group TDIs/User-Agents
Error Handling
Ignore Empty Result
MB TDIs
Calc Confidence
Sort by Confidence
Filter on User-Agent
Different U.-A.

Groups
+ [REDACTED] (27)
+ [REDACTED] (27)
+ [REDACTED] (84)
+ [REDACTED] (12)
   - Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 6.0; Win
      [REDACTED] (2)
      [REDACTED] (5)
   - Mozilla/4.0 (compatible; MSIE 8.0; Win
      [REDACTED] (5)
Document_Link Document_Title/Description EVENT_TIMESTAMP ACTIVITY DATE Confidence_Number ACTIVE USER
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:32:32 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:00Z 1.0 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:32:32 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:00Z 1.0 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:32:32 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:17Z 1.0 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:32:32 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:17Z 1.0 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:23:42 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:09:27Z 0.5 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:23:42 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:09:27Z 0.5 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:23:42 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:00Z 0.5 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:23:42 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:00Z 0.5 [REDACTED]
archive.org/almapl.mp4 German hostage video Wed Mar 28 18:23:42 GMT 2012 2012-03-28T18:18:17Z 0.5 [REDACTED]

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Automated analysis documentation

Workbook 1 20120120000848 188.51.88.22 saudi arabia.xmind
Create a relationship (Ctrl+L)

Analytic Process for FFU Hypothesis Hits

FFU hit from selector [REDACTED] on
20120120000848000GMT geolocated to
SA, accessing Inexhaustible weapons
part 2 through FFU site GET /download
/sela7_la_yndb_02/part24.mp4 HTTP
/1.1 with HTTP user agent Mozilla/5.0
(SymbianOS/9.3; U; Series60/3.2
NokiaN79-1/11.049; Profile/MIDP-2.1
Configuration/CLDC-1.1) AppleWebKit/
413 (KHTML, like Gecko) Safari/413

Can we correlate any other selectors with this IP address?

Mutant Broth query on IP [REDACTED] for 5 hours on either side of 20120120000848000GMT
(_MUTANTBROTH_EVENT_COUNT_) events with only
(_MUTANTBROTH_MATCHING_EVENT_COUNT) matching exactly the us agent above.

New Selectors
FFU Hit Selector[REDACTED]

Marina Activity query on IP [REDACTED] for 5 hours on either side of 20120120000848000GMT
(_MARINA_ACTIVITY_EVENT_COUNT_) events with possible correlation
(_MARINA_ACTIVITY_POSSIBLE_CORRELATIONS_)

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

What happens then?

  • Compare control and experimental groups to show statistical differences
  • Analyse experimental group to determine statistical power of the hypothesis
  • Assemble selectors across all hypotheses
  • Rank selectors according to the number and power of the hypothesis behaviors they show
  • Deliver an ordered list of suspects to OCT

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Scoreboard

Hypotheses

Personae FFU [REDACTED] [REDACTED] [REDACTED] ... Totals
Weights 0.6 0.55 0.52 0.48
P1 4 2 0 4 5.42
P2 4 4 0 1 5.08
P3 4 1 0 4 4.87
P4 3 4 4 0 3.14
...

Known New


TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

Successes

  • An HTTP-referred URL gave us a German hostage video from a previously unknown target.
  • An [REDACTED] FFU upload event gave us an AQIM's hostage strategy. The resulting report was disseminated widely including by the CIA to their counterparts overseas.

TOP SECRET//SI//REL CAN, AUS, GBR, NZL, USA

The End

Team Lead: [REDACTED] ([REDACTED]@cse-cst.gc.ca)

Tech Lead: [REDACTED] ([REDACTED]@cse-cst.gc.ca)

Me: [REDACTED] ([REDACTED]@cse-cst.gc.ca)