GCHQ - OPTIC NERVE

Open PDF
Creating agency: GCHQ Government Communications Headquarters (UK)
Document date: 2008-12-01
Pages: 4
Genre: other
Banner:
Classification: SECRET STRAP 1
Dissemination: -

GCHQ’s OPTIC NERVE project built a web interface to display images from Yahoo webcam sessions captured via bulk, unselected interception, then used that stream for “proportionate” target discovery. The system sampled one frame every five minutes per feed, flagged the prevalence of nudity, and bolted on imperfect face-detection “censoring” alongside warnings about handling offensive material.

Long Description:
This December 2008 report describes OPTIC NERVE as both a viewer for Yahoo webcam imagery and a discovery mechanism seeded by unselected intercept. At the time, data supply “does not select but simply collects in bulk,” trading selectivity for a coarse sampling cadence (one image every five minutes) and proposing a shift to targeted selection with faster capture for known selectors. The document situates the work as “proportionate target discovery,” i.e., trawling a broad pool to find persons of intelligence interest, then tightening collection. Analysts confronted substantial volumes of sexual content. A quick survey of 323 user IDs found 7.1% ±3.7% (95% confidence) of sampled images contained “undesirable nudity,” with Yahoo’s one‑to‑many viewing model enabling de facto porn broadcasting. GCHQ attempted automated face‑detection redaction but conceded it “does not work perfectly,” appending warnings: users uncomfortable with such material should not open it; dissemination violates the offensive material policy; retrieval/reference should be avoided per IB 150. The net effect is a candid view of webcam bulk collection plumbing, its targeting aspirations, and the compliance frictions around handling intimate imagery.
Programs:
OPTICNERVE

People mentioned:
-

Countries:
-

Tags:
Yahoo, webcams, bulk collection, unselected collection, image sampling, target discovery, face recognition, content redaction, nudity, pornography

Identifier:
gchq-optic-nerve

PDF SHA-256:
58ce6ee1eb952bc9726debe34446886e0865f0893f1c47f4a54a1f5a71f44900

SECRET STRAP1

Reference: B/7199BA/5001/5/114
Date: December 2008
Copy no:
Issued by: B18, GCHQ

OPTIC NERVE - Yahoo Webcam display and target discovery
[REDACTED]

Summary
A report on the development of OPTIC NERVE – a web interface to display Yahoo Webcam images sampled from unselected intercept and a system for proportionate target discovery


Metadata:

  • At the moment OPTIC NERVE's data supply (run by B13) does not select but simply collects in bulk, and as a trade-off only collects an image every 5 minutes. It would be helpful to incorporate selection and collect images at a faster rate (all?) for targets. CS to find out from B13 if this is feasible.

  1. Unfortunately, there are issues with undesirable images within the data. It would appear that a surprising number of people use webcam conversations to show intimate parts of their body to the other person. Also, the fact that the Yahoo software allows more than one person to view a webcam stream without necessarily sending a reciprocal stream means that it appears sometimes to be used for broadcasting pornography.
  1. A survey was conducted, taking a single image from each of 323 user ids. 23 (7.1%) of those images contained undesirable nudity. From this we can infer that the true proportion of undesirable images in Yahoo webcam is 7.1% ±3.7% with confidence 95%.

[edit] Potentially Undesirable Images
We use face detection to try to censor material which may be offensive but this does not work perfectly so you should read the following before using OPTIC NERVE:

  • It is possible to handle and display undesirable images. There is no perfect ability to censor material which may be offensive. Users who may feel uncomfortable about such material are advised not to open them.
  • You are reminded that under GCHQ's offensive material policy, the dissemination of offensive material is a disciplinary offence.
  • Retrieval of or reference to such material should be avoided; see IB 150 for guidance on dealing with offensive material