Email from GCHQ to NSA about targeting realms in MONKEY PUZZLE
Open PDFDocument date: 2009-11-24
Pages: 1
Genre: other
Classification: SECRET
Dissemination: -
Email from GCHQ's MONKEY PUZZLE development team to NSA clarifying that the system only supports deploying targeting for four specific selector realms: emailAddr, google, msnpassport, and yahoo, while still accepting other realms into the system pool.
MUSCULAR, UTT, MONKEYPUZZLE
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
-
Tags:
email addresses, Google, Microsoft, MSN, MSN Passport, Yahoo
Identifier:
EFF_-_20131126-wapo-microsoft_monkey_puzzle
PDF SHA-256:
b8d6690e4084cb84f89ed3628d0939e0a82f40085b9060452fc795ca23680048
My notes
From: [REDACTED] (TDB - Residential Contractor)
Sent: 24 November 2009 13:57
To: [REDACTED] (OPASSOS - Residential Integree); [REDACTED] (TDB -
Employee);
Cc: [REDACTED] (OPAACD - Employee); [REDACTED] (TSE -
Employee)
Subject: RE: (U) MUSCULAR and realms
Classification: SECRET
I can answer this [REDACTED]
... MP does not reject selectors based on their realm ([REDACTED] is wrong here). MP will
accept any targeting into its pool as long as it passes the policy and legality checks, aka
front door rules. These do not test the selector value or its realm. However, MP (v6) will
not deploy any targeting for realms other than emailAddr, google, msnpassport and
yahoo. So for the unsupported realms, UTT should still be getting an Added or Updated
targeting action response from MP (implying the targeting is in the pool), but an empty
targeting summary since it did not go anywhere....
NSA could send us whatever realms they like right now, but the targeting just won't go
anywhere unless it's of one of the above 4 realms. I hope they don't as we've not sized
our database to cater for all it...
Hope this all makes sense...
[REDACTED]
--
[REDACTED]
MONKEY PUZZLE Dev Team
[REDACTED]
Published in the Same Report
(1 documents)
-
Bulk collection of webmail address books and emerging protocols [pdf]
TOP SECRET NSA document details the large-scale collection of email address books and contact lists from major webmail and social media providers, emphasizing their metadata value despite low attribution rates to known targets. It also highlights ongoing efforts to identify and analyze emerging communication protocols, such as those used by Hotmail Messenger.
Related Documents
-
Bulk collection of webmail address books and emerging protocols [pdf]
TOP SECRET NSA document details the large-scale collection of email address books and contact lists from major webmail and social media providers, emphasizing their metadata value despite low attribution rates to known targets. It also highlights ongoing efforts to identify and analyze emerging communication protocols, such as those used by Hotmail Messenger.
-
SSO Collection Optimization Overview [pdf]
This excerpt is from an article in the NSA's "Intellipedia," a classified system built with the same open-source software used by Wikipedia. Like the other documents, it describes the problem of high-volume, low-value data collection — and the NSA's response — with a focus on Internet contact lists.
-
SSO Collection Optimization [pdf]
This is another presentation on problems with the National Security Agency's overcollection of address books and buddy lists and its efforts to weed out useless content. See also EFF_-_20131104-wapo-optimization_google
-
PRISM/US-984XN Overview [pdf]
A 2013 NSA training presentation revealing that major U.S. tech companies — including Google, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, and Skype — secretly gave the NSA direct access to their servers, allowing the agency to collect users' emails, chats, photos, and files in real time, with the FBI acting as intermediary.
Programs: PRISM · FAIRVIEW · STORMBREW · BLARNEY · OAKSTAR · UTT · PRINTAURA · PINWALE · NUCLEON · TRAFFICTHIEF · SCISSORS · MARINA · MAINWAY · FALLOUT · CONVEYANCE · REPRISMFISA · SSO“U.S., British intelligence mining data from nine U.S. Internet companies in broad secret program” - The Washington Post ↗ (2013-06-06) · “NSA Prism program taps in to user data of Apple, Google and others” - The Guardian ↗ (2013-06-07) · “L'ampleur de l'espionnage mondial par la NSA” - Le Monde ↗ (2013-10-21) · “NSA files decoded: Edward Snowden's surveillance revelations explained” - The Guardian ↗ (2013-11-01) · “No Place to Hide” - Metropolitan Books ↗ (2014-05-13) · “Dark Mirror: Edward Snowden and the American Surveillance State” - Penguin Press ↗ (2020-05-19) · Gellman, Barton · Poitras, Laura · Greenwald, Glenn · MacAskill, Ewen · Untersinger, Martin · Dance, Gabriel -
WINDSTOP/2P System Highlights [pdf]
A March 2013 NSA Special Source Operations internal report describing a volume management problem at MUSCULAR — the joint NSA/GCHQ programme tapping Yahoo and Google inter-datacenter fiber links — specifically concerning Yahoo's proprietary Narchive email transfer format, which was generating 15GB/day of mostly stale email data representing 25% of the collection site's daily allocation.