XKEYSCORE Sweden Meeting

Open PDF
Creating agency: NSA National Security Agency (US)
Document date: 2013-04-01
Pages: 5
Genre: report
Banner:
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: NOFORN

This document is an internal NSA memo ahead of an annually recurring summit meeting between NSA chief Keith Alexander and the FRA chief. The meeting took place on 24–26 April 2013. Six people from Sweden were to participate in the meeting, including then FRA Director-General Ingvar Åkesson and Deputy Director-General Christina Malm.

Long Description:
Among other things, that document shows that: * The FRA wants an update on the Quantum project Winterlight (see the article on Quantum), and wants to know when they will receive reports from hacking attempts and intelligence from them. * The FRA has been given access to XKeyscore, which is one of the NSA’s most powerful search tools in its enormous databases of wiretapped material. * The Swedes update the NSA that a change in Swedish legislation makes it legal for the FRA to share intelligence with the Swedish Security Service. * Since January 2013, the NSA has a counterterrorism analyst placed in Stockholm. * In the Quantum project, in which the FRA collaborates with the NSA and the British GCHQ, individual computer users are rerouted through specially tailored “links” to false attack servers, whose “shots” against the user’s computer allow spyware to be installed on the computer. In March 2013, the NSA received a report from the FRA that Quantum gave the British GCHQ 100 targets, which led to five of them being rerouted to the British Quantum servers. The goal is that the FRA will lead in the targets to the NSA’s Quantum servers instead of the GCHQ’s. * The NSA wants to continue working with the FRA for access to fibre-optic cables. This collaboration has already resulted in unique access to high-priority targets (123 reports so far, under this “budget year” alone). The FRA continues to expand its access to new cables and telecom operators, resulting in greater access for the NSA to potentially valuable targets even beyond Russia. * The NSA shared with the FRA information about a hacking attempt in November 2012 against/by the Israeli Embassy in Stockholm. They agreed that Israel could be informed about the discovery of the hacking attempt. * The FRA provides the European Cryptologic Centre in Darmstadt, Germany with Swedish linguists to analyse terrorism-related material in Swedish. * It is noted that the FRA, after four years’ temporary interruption, can now legally (sic) collaborate with the Swedish Security Service (the British GCHQ has previously congratulated the FRA on circumventing the previous ban on taking assignments from the Swedish Security Service). * The FRA’s access to fibre-optic cables through Sweden has led to unique access to intelligence about the civilian energy sector, among other things.
Programs:
XKEYSCORE, QUANTUM, WINTERLIGHT, LEGEND, NAPA-3, SSO

People mentioned:
Åkesson, Ingvar, Cusick, James M., Malm, Christina, Nyberg, Lena, Nordqvist, Mats

Countries:
Sweden, Russia, Norway, Denmark, Germany, China, South Korea, North Korea, Israel

Tags:
FRA, XKS, SÄPO, Stockholm, Europe, ECC, Darmstadt, Russian leadership, energy sector, Russian counterintelligence, NAPA, SWEDUSA, cyber division, Tailored Access Operations, Computer Network Exploitation, cable access, cable tapping, telecommunications, counterterrorism, CT analysts, video teleconference, Israeli Embassy, special project, foreign partnerships, cyber collaboration, NTOC, DIRFA, GCM, Office of Russia, Office of South Asia, Office of China, Korea, NCSC, SSO, Special Projects Office, international partnerships, intelligence sharing, cyber operations, foreign relations, operational briefings, analytic collaboration, data sharing, high-level meeting, operational planning, directorate, program management

Identifier:
EFF_-_20131211-svt-xkeyscore_sweden_meeting
Also known as:
nsa-se-fra-xkeyscore

PDF SHA-256:
e1cf5f8f6a8164288551f2bbed367be73151a6964f2bb093af9f430780d62a40

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

VISIT PRÉCIS

SWEDUSA 2013 STRATEGIC PLANNING CONFERENCE (SPC)

MR. INGVAR ÅKESSON
DIRECTOR GENERAL
FORSVARETS RADIOANSTALT (FRA)
SWEDEN
24-26 APRIL 2013

GEN A Opening Remarks: 24 April 2013//0800-0815
GEN A Hosted Discussions: 24 April 2013//1130-1200
EXDIR Hosted Lunch: 24 April 2013//1200-1245 - Canine Suite
GEN A Hosted Dinner: 25 April 2013//1830 - Quarters
Accompanying Senior: Mr. James M. Cusick, Director Foreign Affairs (DIRFA)

BACKGROUND:

  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) Mr. Ingvar Åkesson (OH-kes-son) has been the FRA Director-
    General since 2003. He was slated to retire last August, but was extended until August
    2013. He will be accompanied by Ms. Christina Malm, D/DIR, FRA. The remainder of
    the delegation includes:

Ms. Lena Nyberg, SIGINT Director, FRA
Mr. Mats Nordqvist, Technical Director, FRA
Mr. [REDACTED], Strategic Advisor Chief Studies and Development, FRA
Ms. [REDACTED], Chief Foreign Relations Officer, FRA

PURPOSE OF THE VISIT:

  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) Each year a high-level FRA delegation visits NSA/CSS to
    attend the SWEDUSA SPC. Discussions will center on topics of mutual interest and
    future areas of collaboration. It also presents an opportunity for NSA/CSS leadership to
    reiterate their commitment to the Swedish partnership.

VISITOR REQUESTED:

  • (TS//REL USA, SWE) FRA requested a WINTERLIGHT (Quantum project) update and
    asked to hear about our plans for sharing reports on Quantum tipping or intercepts from
    the Quantum tipping. FRA plans to start the conference by giving an overview of its
    SIGINT Roadmap, to include Russia, [REDACTED].
    It will also provide a Cyber update--specifically
    briefing NSA on its new cyber division, its active and passive sensors and tradecraft
    collaboration with NSA/CSS Threat Operations Center (NTOC); updates on the special

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN
Derived From: NSA/CSSM 1-52
Dated: 20070108
Declassify On: 30320108

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

project and NAPA-3; and a discussion of how new legislation has helped improve the
FRA-Swedish Security Service (SAPO) relationship.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

CDR/DCDR/DDIR GUIDANCE: (U) N/A

PREP SESSION GUIDANCE:

  • (U) Due to the nature of the visit, no specific guidance has been conveyed to other
    participants.

NSA/CSS REQUESTED:

  • (U//FOUO) Further Cyber Security/Defense Cooperation;
  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) Future CT cooperation (value of CT Deployed Analyst);
  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) Status of relationship between FRA and SÄPO under the new
    legislation;
  • (TS//REL TO USA, SWE) Computer Network Exploitation (CNE) Update;
  • (TS//REL TO USA, SWE) Update on special project;

CYBERCOM REQUESTED: (U) N/A

COMMON THREADS:

  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) Emphasize the value of the NSA-FRA partnership.

KEY TAKEAWAYS:
(S//REL USA, SWE) Recommend General Alexander and D/DIR emphasize the following
points:

Quantum Operations:

  • (TS//SI//REL TO USA, SWE) Acknowledge the success that NSA, FRA, and GCHQ
    have had on WINTERLIGHT. Last month, we received a message from our Swedish
    partner that GCHQ received FRA QUANTUM tips that led to 100 shots, five of which
    were successfully redirected to the GCHQ server. The Foreign Affairs Directorate (FAD)
    confirmed with Tailored Access Operations (TAO) that this validates the "proof of
    concept" that was originally trying to be accomplished. Additionally, FAD, TAO, and
    Enterprise Information Technology Services are still working through the technical
    solution to have FRA tip directly to NSA. S3 Data Acquisitions' goal to have a
    solution for a direct tip to FRA operational by this summer. The Quantum effort
    motivated the recent XKEYSCORE installation. FRA is currently evaluating it for use to
    support their SIGINT Development work.

Cable Access/Reporting and Analysis:

  • (TS//SI//REL TO USA, SWE) Highlight that NSA/CSS would like to continue to
    collaborate on FRA's cable access program, which has resulted in unique SIGINT
    reporting on a variety of high-priority SIGINT topics (123 reports thus far this fiscal
    year). FRA continues to gain access to more data from additional telecommunications
    companies, making the cable access potentially lucrative for NSA/CSS for targets beyond
    Russia.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

Cyber:

  • (TS//REL TO USA, SWE) Stress that NTOC is ready to seriously engage with FRA on
    cyber defense. Mr. Åkesson has reviewed the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU)
    and has no changes; therefore, we would like to have an official signing during the
    24 April 1130-1200 discussions.
  • (TS//SI//NF) NTOC shared some information with FRA about a Swedish intrusion in
    November 2012. FRA came in with questions in February 2013 that led NTOC to do
    more analysis. Subsequently, NTOC reached the same conclusion as FRA, that it
    involved the Israeli Embassy in Stockholm. FRA asked if it could alert Israel and NTOC
    agreed that it could tell Israel about the intrusion. Israel's identity was never
    compromised.

Secure VTC Capability

  • (S//REL TO USA, FVEY) Encourage FRA to set up its equipment soonest to allow for
    secure VTC capability. That capability already exists with Norway and Denmark and has
    shown benefit in expanding analytic collaboration on a myriad of issues. FRA's
    technology directorate is just waiting on requirements from its SIGINT directorate to be
    able to finalize the set-up and installation.

Counterterrorism:

  • (TS//SI//REL TO USA, SWE) NSA/CSS' Counterterrorism (CT) analysts and FRA
    continue to cooperate and collaborate on CT threat-related activities in Europe. Several
    analyst-to-analyst meetings have taken place and European Cryptologic Center (ECC) in
    Darmstadt, Germany, is formally coordinating a Staff Processing Form (SPF) to have
    Sweden assist NSA/CSS with high-priority CT Swedish language traffic that ECC is
    currently unable to fully analyze. In January 2013, CT established its first CT deployed
    analyst position in Stockholm. Also in January, FRA and SÄPO were legally allowed to
    collaborate after a 4-year hiatus.
  • (S//SI//REL TO USA, SWE) Encourage increased collaboration on CT threat streams.

Russia:

  • (S//SI//REL TO USA, SWE) Thank Sweden for its continued work on the Russian
    target, and underscore the primary role that FRA plays as a leading partner to work the
    Russian target, including Russian leadership, energy, [REDACTED] and [REDACTED], and
    counterintelligence. FRA's cable access has resulted in unique SIGINT reporting on all
    of these areas.
  • (S//SI//REL TO USA, SWE) Encourage continued collaboration and sharing of reporting
    on Russian topics.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN

VISIT FORMAT:

  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) GEN Alexander's opening remarks will set the tone for a
    productive conference.
  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) FRA will provide briefings on FRA's SIGINT Roadmap; its
    new cyber division; its relationship with the Swedish Internal Security Service, SÄPO;
    and updates on the special project and NAPA-3.
  • (U//FOUO) NSA Participants: SID DIR, DIRFA, Associate D/DIR for CT, GCM, Russia
    Production Center, GCM, Office of South Asia, GCM, Office of China/Korea, NTOC,
    NCSC, SSO, Special Projects Office (LEGEND).

PREVIOUS VISITS AND RESPECTIVE TOPICS:

  • (S//REL TO USA, SWE) Mr. Åkesson last visited NSA/CSS for SWEDUSA in May
    2012.

POTENTIAL LANDMINES: (U) None.

OTHER INFORMATION: (U) None.

RECENT PRESS INDICATIONS: (U) None.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//NOFORN