Legal issues UK regarding Sweden and Quantum
Open PDFDocument date: 2013-04-01
Pages: 1
Genre: report
Banner: TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Classification: TOP SECRET SI
Dissemination: NOFORN
An internal NSA document from April 2013 that describes the status of the relationship with a number of partners. It takes up a three-party agreement regarding the hacker programme Quantum, between the Swedish FRA, American NSA and British GCHQ, initiated by NSA chief Keith Alexander. The document shows that the project has so far resulted in a “proof of concept” – i.e., the system works, but it has not yet generated any substantial intelligence results. It also shows that the GCHQ are doubtful about continuing in the project because of restrictions in British legislation, but that the NSA’s intention all along has been to carry out the project with the Swedish FRA rather than GCHQ.
QUANTUM
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
Sweden
Tags:
FRA, GCHQ, DIRNSA, foreign partnerships, trilateral cooperation, bilateral transition, offensive cyber operations, hacker program, intelligence sharing, cryptologic cooperation, operational challenges, foreign intelligence, interagency cooperation, project management
Identifier:
EFF_-_20131211-svt-legal_issues_uk_regarding_sweden_and_quantum
Also known as:
nsa-gchq-fra-quantum
PDF SHA-256:
f7ec92476ddb41a36e2e6304b389d87bdd23293d050d15f8670d697d97ce830f
My notes
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
What You Wanted to Know
Review SID's goals for this quarterly.
Note that just about all of the accomplishments we are presenting respond to some aspect of SID's strategies for the foreign partner. The few that don't involve those niche partners for whom our strategy is to simply maintain a viable relationship that we can rely on should we need it in the future. And that these are only some of the accomplishments for FY13...there are way too many to address in just an hour.
When it comes to discussing the challenges and roadblocks that we believe are going to make it difficult if not impossible to accomplish specific items, the causative factors are divided between NSA and partner budget cuts, legal and policy impediments on the partner side, and in a few cases partner unwillingness to cooperate or meet their obligations to us.
............
............
Select Accomplishments: Production (second slide)
(TS//SI//NF) Sweden: This is the DIRNSA-initiated Quantum trilat between NSA, GCHQ, and FRA. While the overall success rate has been low, the effort can be considered a success in terms of proof of concept. Continued GCHQ involvement may be in jeopardy due to British legal/policy restrictions, and in fact NSA's goal all along has been to transition this effort to a bilat with the Swedish partner.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Published in the Same Report
(6 documents)
-
Select Accomplishments: Production - Sweden [pdf]
Slides from a presentation in April 2013 that the NSA held for its closest partners in Canada, the UK, New Zealand and Australia. It discusses Sweden’s work with the Quantum hacker project.
Programs: QUANTUM -
Baltic region [pdf]
This screenshot shows a part of a document which is about the growing relationship with the Swedish FRA, as an “extremely competent” partner. In 2011, the FRA gave the NSA access to “unique” material from its cable collection regarding, among other things, Russia and the Baltic region.
-
FINAL Agenda SWEDUSA [pdf]
Detailed list of points and participants in the summit meeting between the top brass of the FRA and the NSA in April 2013.
Programs: TURTLEPOWER · TURMOIL · XKEYSCORE · WINTERLIGHT · QUANTUM · PARTNERMALL · VIVIAN · NAPA-3 · GCE · SSO -
Quantum – from GCHQ documents dates October 2012 [pdf]
Portion of a document from the NSA’s British equivalent, the GCHQ, in which Sweden is not mentioned, but it describes an example of how Quantum has been used to attack computers in an African country where the users have visited extremist websites.
-
XKEYSCORE Sweden Meeting [pdf]
This document is an internal NSA memo ahead of an annually recurring summit meeting between NSA chief Keith Alexander and the FRA chief. The meeting took place on 24–26 April 2013. Six people from Sweden were to participate in the meeting, including then FRA Director-General Ingvar Åkesson and Deputy Director-General Christina Malm.
-
First-Ever Formal SIGINT Development (SIGDEV) Training Is Provided to SIGINT Seniors Europe (SSEUR) Partners [pdf]
This internal NSA report details the first formal training course on "SIGINT Development" (SIGDEV) offered to the "SIGINT Seniors Europe" (SSEUR) coalition, a group comprising the Five Eyes nations and nine European third-party partners. The document highlights the strategic goal of standardizing analytic tradecraft among these allies to improve collaboration on priority missions like counter-terrorism and the war in Afghanistan.
“New NSA Revelations: Inside Snowden's Germany File” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · “Read the Snowden Documents From the NSA” - SVT Nyheter ↗ (2013-12-11) · Becker, Sven · Gude, Hubert · Horchert, Judith · Müller-Maguhn, Andy · Poitras, Laura · Reißmann, Ole · Rosenbach, Marcel · Schindler, Jörg · Schmid, Fidelius · Sontheimer, Michael · Stark, Holger · Björklund, Axel
Related Documents
-
Select Accomplishments: Production - Sweden [pdf]
Slides from a presentation in April 2013 that the NSA held for its closest partners in Canada, the UK, New Zealand and Australia. It discusses Sweden’s work with the Quantum hacker project.
Programs: QUANTUM -
XKEYSCORE Sweden Meeting [pdf]
This document is an internal NSA memo ahead of an annually recurring summit meeting between NSA chief Keith Alexander and the FRA chief. The meeting took place on 24–26 April 2013. Six people from Sweden were to participate in the meeting, including then FRA Director-General Ingvar Åkesson and Deputy Director-General Christina Malm.
-
FINAL Agenda SWEDUSA [pdf]
Detailed list of points and participants in the summit meeting between the top brass of the FRA and the NSA in April 2013.
Programs: TURTLEPOWER · TURMOIL · XKEYSCORE · WINTERLIGHT · QUANTUM · PARTNERMALL · VIVIAN · NAPA-3 · GCE · SSO -
Quantum – from GCHQ documents dates October 2012 [pdf]
Portion of a document from the NSA’s British equivalent, the GCHQ, in which Sweden is not mentioned, but it describes an example of how Quantum has been used to attack computers in an African country where the users have visited extremist websites.
-
NSA Intelligence Relationship with Sweden [pdf]
A 2013 NSA information paper documenting the agency's long-standing intelligence partnership with Sweden's signals intelligence service FRA, covering joint collection on Russian targets, counterterrorism, cryptanalysis, and cyber defense — a relationship kept classified due to Sweden's official political neutrality.
“SVT avslöjar: USA hyllar FRA:s ryss-spionage” - SVT Nyheter ↗ (2013-12-05) · “Snowden files reveal Swedish-American surveillance of Russia” - SVT Nyheter ↗ (2013-12-05) · Struwe, Filip · Svensson, Anna H · Gallagher, Ryan · Greenwald, Glenn · Bergman, Sven · Dyfvermark, Joachim · Laurin, Fredrik