Pull Steering Group Minutes
Open PDFDocument date: 2008-02-29
Pages: 3
Genre: report
Banner: TOP SECRET STRAP1
Classification: TOP SECRET STRAP 1
Dissemination: -
A top secret STRAP1 GCHQ PullThrough Steering Group meeting record from February 2008 documenting the approval process for five surveillance and intelligence prototypes including KARMA POLICE — the mass internet browsing profiling system — alongside ORB FINDER for CNE operational relay box identification, SALTY OTTER for cross-media timing analysis, MOOSE MILK for telephone kiosk surveillance, and LIGHTWOOD for email address extraction used by JTRIG.
MYOFIBRIL, SALTYOTTER, PRIMETIME, KARMAPOLICE, ORBFINDER, MOOSEMILK, LIGHTWOOD, JTRIG, MERAPEAK, MONTEVISTA, KED
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
-
Tags:
PullThrough Steering Group, PTSG, JTRIG, Computer Network Exploitation, Technology Readiness Level, TRL, cross-media timing, telephone surveillance, emails, Operational Relay Box, internet profiling, prototype approval, analytical development, passive SIGINT, legal compliance, content collection, every website they visit, every visible user on the internet
Identifier:
pull-through-steering-group-minutes
PDF SHA-256:
1e97b4b72139c05abe25dd1588a1119b91e47e93d25fe3f103118cc158848614
My notes
TOP SECRET STRAP1
THQ/1202THQ/1900/0058
29 February 2008
PullThrough Steering Group Meeting #16
29 February 2008.
Distribute to: Invitees, GCWeb, SIGMOD-PU's-GCHQ-dl, T-Domain-Heads-GCHQ-dl, SigMod-BCM-Support-Team-GCHQ-dl
Present:
- [REDACTED] OPD-SDHQ
- [REDACTED] TPS
- [REDACTED] OPD-ATS
- [REDACTED] AR
- [REDACTED] Head OPD-SD
- [REDACTED] OPDTAT
Apologies:
- None
Summary of prototypes in the process:
Briefly considered – MYOFIBRIL, addressed in Better Analysis bid.
Discussion of PTSG future
The future of ‘pull through' and the PTSG was discussed in the context of programmes, themes, product centres, the four box model, evolutionary development, stripy teams etc.
The role of evaluation and championing of AR prototypes for further development within the business was recognised by all as important for continuity, however no specific conclusions were reached with respect to the relationship between the PTSG and other organisational structures arising from business change, e.g. the CCBs that have been proposed in the context of the 4 box model transition processes.
(Ed note: Worthwhile for the PTSG to consider this relationship further more formally)
New Prototypes seeking PTSG Approval:
- SALTY OTTER [REDACTED]/SALTY_OTTER- submitted at TRL
4.
B17 technique for finding cross-media timing patterns and incorporates the CLASP algorithm, which is considered to be similar, yet more general than the
1 of 3
This information is exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and may be subject to exemption under other UK information legislation. Refer disclosure requests to GCHQ on [REDACTED]
TOP SECRET STRAP1
TOP SECRET STRAP1
THQ/1202THQ/1900/0058
29 February 2008
popular PRIME TIME. looks for cross-media timing chains, e.g. a telephone call triggers a chat event.
ACTION: Ran out of time for discussion – to be brought back for next PSTG session.
- KARMA POLICE - submitted at TRL 4.
KARMA POLICE aims to correlate every user visible to passive SIGINT with every website they visit, hence providing either (a) a web browsing profile for every visible user on the internet, or (b) a user profile for every visible website on the internet.
For more details, refer to high-level overview document B/6760BA/5001/1.
Initial work with INOC shows high analyst usage of technique.
ACTION: To be progressed as a Better Analysis theme based requirement for explore.
- noted that the legalities with respect to 'content' need to be cleared.
- ORB FINDER submitted at TRL 4.
Enables the identification of potential candidate Operational Relay Boxes (ORBs) for use in CNE's active exploitation network through passive logging, providing a richer picture of the end-system, and consequently reducing CNE's active footprint by focussing attention to those candidates that meet a stricter set of criteria.
ACTION : To be progressed as a CNE theme based requirement for explore.
- MOOSE MILK [REDACTED]/MOOSE_MILK - submitted at TRL 4.
A data mining algorithm devised by CTOR to detect suspicious use of telephone kiosks in the UK. MOOSE MILK is currently being developed further by the Operational Data Mining team in OPD-TAT.
ACTION: To be progressed as a Better Analysis Agility requirement for explore.
- noted that the timeliness of the tool depends on feeds in near-real time, which have not been available so far.
- LIGHTWOOD [REDACTED]/LIGHTWOOD - submitted to allocate a TRL rating given operational usage within JTRIG.
Extracts act email addresses from any character stream. What differentiates LIGHTWOOD is its ability to distinguish valid email formats from those that appear to be email addresses but are not for open Internet (e.g. better@management).
2 of 3
This information is exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and may be subject to exemption under other UK information legislation. Refer disclosure requests to GCHQ on [REDACTED]
TOP SECRET STRAP1
TOP SECRET STRAP1
THQ/1202THQ/1900/0058
29 February 2008
The program also has a number of other email and URL detection capabilities that standard regular expression extraction rules do not have. Some of these are sensitive. Used operationally in JTRIG and to be used in MERA PEAK and MONTEVISTA.
Accepted by PTSG as having attained TRL7. No further PTSG action.
Other Business
KED
KED needs to be on the SE radar – it was not clear where the final ‘product centre' lay – [REDACTED] to talk to [REDACTED] and [REDACTED] together with [REDACTED], [REDACTED], [REDACTED] and [REDACTED].
There was some concern over programme allocation of resources to Mission Management tasks more generally. .
Date Of Next Meeting
9 May 2008 10:30 AB3-M2
[REDACTED]
TPS IP-Activity Board SE
3 of 3
This information is exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act 2000 and may be subject to exemption under other UK information legislation. Refer disclosure requests to GCHQ on [REDACTED]
TOP SECRET STRAP1
Published in the Same Report
(10 of 28 documents)
-
Supporting Internet Operations - Special Source Access [pdf]
In this document GCHQ outlines its plans for expanding internet operations, focusing on increasing access to 10G bearers and enhancing its intercept and egress capabilities by 2011. The agency highlighted that “25 percent of all internet traffic” transits the U.K. through approximately 1,600 different 10-gigabit cables, and it noted that it could “survey the majority of the 1,600” to “select the most valuable to switch into our processing systems.”
-
Event (SIGINT) [pdf]
5 p.This document explains that within GCHQ and NSA SIGINT operations, an “Event” refers to metadata about observable communications or user actions rather than message content, categorized into types like Communications, Presence, Social, and Geo-reference Events. These events are collected, stored in various databases, and analyzed through convergence and correlation processes, with standardized formats defined by Interface Control Documents such as INTERSTELLAR DUST (IDUST) and Actor Action (AA).
Programs: INTERSTELLAR DUST · HAUSTORIUM · SOCIAL ANTHROPOID · ACTOR-ACTION · SAMREF · GEOFUSION · HARD ASSOC · SALAMANCA · ASSOCIATION · BANYAN · MAINWAY · FASCIA · CULTWEAVE II · VOICESAIL · TEEDALE · PILBEAM · MUTANTBROTH · AUTOASSOC · MARBLEDGECKO · KARMAPOLICE · HRMAP · MEMORYHOLE · INFINITEMONKEYS · SOCIALANIMAL · AUTOTDI · SAMUELPEPYS · Mobile Applications Project · NGE · PPF · SLR -
Access: Vision 2013 [pdf]
This July 2010 GCHQ strategic document outlines the agency's vision for 2013 to create "the world's biggest SIGINT engine" with access to 800 10-gigabit connections (up from existing capacity), expanding overseas operations to 60% while reducing UK-based to 40%, and developing new capabilities including computer network exploitation (CNE), exfiltration, beaconry, geolocation, and collection of "Internet Pocket Litter" like cookies and browsing data. The strategy emphasizes "scale and pace," "balance," and "agility" while claiming to operate within legal frameworks of "necessity, proportionality and authorisation," and highlights partnerships with second and third parties to access "intractable and hard targets."
Marking: SECRET -
BLACK HOLE ANALYTICS, ADD/SD briefing, September 2009 [pdf]
This September 2009 GCHQ briefing describes the BLACK HOLE analytics infrastructure and Next Generation Events (NGE) project, which planned to scale from ~8 10-gigabit connections to ~200 10Gs by March 2011, storing intercepted data in massive flat-file repositories at Benhall and Bude before loading it into "Question Focused Dataset" (QFD) databases that power surveillance tools like MUTANT BROTH, KARMA POLICE, INFINITE MONKEYS, and others. The document outlines how "probes" extract Target Detection Identifiers (TDIs) from intercepted data feeds, store them in BLACK HOLE repositories, then enable analysts to profile targets' online activities, create social networks, investigate websites and forums, track web searches and Google Earth usage, and perform large-scale data mining across internet and telephony data.
Programs: BLACKHOLE · MUTANTBROTH · AUTOASSOC · INFINITEMONKEYS · KARMAPOLICE · SOCIALANIMAL · HRMAP · MEMORYHOLE · MARBLEDGECKO · HARDASSOC · SAMUELPEPYS · BLAZINGSADDLES · TELLURIAN · BUFFER · DISTILLERY · LOOKINGGLASS · NGEPeople: bin Laden, Osama -
Report on Architectural Risk 2012 - Summary [pdf]
This 2012 GCHQ report identifies that a historical under-investment in IT architecture has created significant risk, especially with new challenges like massive data growth, cyber defense, and increased partnering. The document recommends immediate, prioritized investment in big data strategies, integrated analytics frameworks, and security services to address the strain on the system.
Programs: BLACKHOLE -
Blazing Saddles [pdf]
This document describes BLAZING SADDLES, a GCHQ program designed to massively scale the storage and analysis of bulk internet surveillance data through multiple specialized databases that track website visits, online identities, communications patterns, and geolocation queries across the global internet population.
Programs: BLAZINGSADDLES · BLACKHOLE · SOCIALANTHROPOID · AUTOASSOC · HRMAP · INFINITEMONKEYS · KARMAPOLICE · MARBLEDGECKO · MUTANTBROTH · MEMORYHOLE · SAMUELPEPYS · SOCIALANIMAL · HAUSTORIUM · GOLDENAXE · NGE -
Broadcast/Internet Radio Exploitation and Analysis, 6th November 2009, GCHQ [pdf]
This GCHQ report analyzes 6.68 million internet radio listening events collected over three months in 2009, detailing global broadcasting patterns, user behaviors, and specifically examining Islamic radio stations and Pakistan-UK connections for potential radicalization intelligence, while recommending integration with bulk surveillance databases like KARMA POLICE for enhanced user profiling.
-
ICTR Cloud Efforts [pdf]
A GCHQ presentation details how the agency developed cloud-based big data analytics to achieve "population scale" surveillance—processing trillions of internet events to build geographic and behavioral profiles on every online identifier worldwide, enabling discovery of unknown targets through pattern analysis rather than traditional keyword searches.
Programs: EVERYASSOC · PROBABILITYCLOUD · SILVERLINING · CULTWEAVE · KARMAPOLICE · EVERYPOLICE · AWKWARDTURTLE · GORDIANKNOT · SANDIA · BLOODHOUND · FIVEALIVE · NGE · MAPREDUCE -
Content-Metadata Matrix [pdf]
GCHQ's internal taxonomy sorts intercepted data into "content" or "metadata" to determine what can be searched without individual warrants—email subject lines, full URLs, and buddy lists fall on opposite sides of the line, enabling analysts to mine massive troves of IP addresses, phone numbers, location data, and browsing history with just a few keystrokes and a brief justification.
-
Cyber Defence Operations Legal Policy [pdf]
GCHQ's internal wiki laying out the legal plumbing for its Cyber Defence Operations (formerly NDIST)—detailing warrant types (RIPA, ISA, CNE), data retention schedules, targeting rules for UK/Five Eyes infrastructure, XKEYSCORE query protocols, and the bureaucratic hoops analysts must jump through to search attacker IPs, fingerprint UK networks, and share malware intelligence without tripping over location/nationality safeguards or commercial sensitivities.
Programs: JTRIG · SPAY · GORDIANKNOT · CHORDAL · DISCOVER · EVENTS · CASPORT · XKEYSCORE · CONTENT CLOUD · SQUEAL · MIRAGE · MUTANTBROTH · ANXIOUS · HALTERHITCH · BROADOAK · DONKEYKONG · ZOOL · PALANTIR · OVERLINK · RT · GATEKEEPER · IRONHAND · HARUSPEX · B3M · LOOKINGGLASS · GOLDENEYE · BLAZINGSADDLES · MOONRAKER · TRITON
Related Documents
-
HIMR Data Mining Research Problem Book [pdf]
This document is a research roadmap created by GCHQ for the Heilbronn Institute for Mathematical Research (HIMR). Its purpose is to guide long-term mathematical and data-mining research that could improve signals intelligence (SIGINT) capabilities. It outlines key research problems, datasets, and collaboration plans between intelligence agencies and academic researchers. The main goal is to develop new algorithms and mathematical tools to analyze extremely large communications datasets produced by modern surveillance systems.
Programs: CLOUD · DISTILLERY · DISCOVER · PRESTON · LECKWITH · TERRAIN · BROADOAK · NGE · FIVEALIVE · CHARTBREAKER · FIRSTCONTACT · GEOFUSION · RADONSHARPEN-B · PRIMETIME · HIDDENOTTER · BAKERSDOZEN · CLASP · SALTYOTTER · BIRCH · SOLIDINK · FLUIDINK · MAMBA · GRINNINGROACH · PIRATECAREBEAR · AUTOASSOC · CROUCHINGSQUIRREL · HRMAP · KACHINA · SQUEAL · QUESTA · METEORSHOWER · SUNSTORM · GOLDMINE · HAGERAWEL · WOODY · BUZZ · SILVERLIBRARY · SILVERLINING · VALHALLA · MOUNTMCKINLEY · SEPANG · BLACKHOLE · SALAMANCA · HAGELAWEL · LUCKYSTRIKE · SPIKYROCK · MYOFIBRIL · INJUNCTION · PSYCHICSALMON · RAGINGBULLFROG · ROBOTICFISH · TIMIDTOAD · AURA · CARBONCOPY · CASK · CHORDAL · CRAN · INSTINCT · MADFORGE · SWAMP · VOLSUNGA · WHITERAVEN · MVR · PPF · JTRIG · MAPREDUCE · MAILORDERPeople: Tukey, John -
Operational Engineering November 2010 [pdf]
This internal GCHQ briefing from late 2010 documents the Events Product Centre's suite of bulk internet and communications surveillance tools — including IMMINGLE, SALAMANCA, SOCIAL ANTHROPOID, MUTANT BROTH, KARMA POLICE, SAMUEL PEPYS and GUIDING LIGHT — covering scaling targets, new data sources, and operational capabilities across telephony, webmail, instant messaging, social media, GPRS and VoIP collection.
Programs: EVENTS · IMMINGLE · SALAMANCA · GUIDINGLIGHT · B3M · HARDASSOC · MAINWAY · THUGGEE · FASCIA · HAUSTORIUM · FIRESTORM · TERRAIN · SHAREOWN · ESCHAR · BRIO · INFINITEMONKEY · KARMAPOLICE · MARBLEDGECKO · MEMORYHOLE · MUTANTBROTH · SAMUELPEPYS · SOCIALANIMAL · SOCIALANTHROPOID · HEARTBEAT · SANTHROPOID · LEAKYGATEWAYS · GTPTUNNEL · LUSTRE · GLASSBACK · COLLATERAL · HRMAP · SWORDPLAY · BROADOAK · REFORMER · ARTEMIS · MERLOT · CONTRAOCTAVE · CRYINGFOWL · CULTWEAVE · SAMDYCE · GCQUERY · BLAZZINGSADDLES · EREPO · JTRIG · SOUNDER -
Broadcast/Internet Radio Exploitation and Analysis, 6th November 2009, GCHQ [pdf]
This GCHQ report analyzes 6.68 million internet radio listening events collected over three months in 2009, detailing global broadcasting patterns, user behaviors, and specifically examining Islamic radio stations and Pakistan-UK connections for potential radicalization intelligence, while recommending integration with bulk surveillance databases like KARMA POLICE for enhanced user profiling.
-
Mobile Networks in My NOC World [pdf]
This TOP SECRET STRAP 2 GCHQ document outlines the “MyNOC” operations, a specialized Network Operations Centre used by the UK’s GCHQ to coordinate cyber exploitation of international mobile and telecom infrastructure, with a particular focus on Belgacom’s GRX network under “Operation Socialist” (OP SOCIALIST). It details operational planning, toolsets, personnel roles, network mapping, QUANTUM INSERT targeting, and successful infiltration strategies that enabled CNE (Computer Network Exploitation) access to key Belgacom systems and staff infrastructure.
Programs: HIGHNOTE · COPPERHEAD · NEXUS · CADDIS · BRENT · RUSSETT PHONE · CERBERUS · E-BEAM · PIA · JEDI · WYLEKEY · INTERACTION · EREPO · QUANTUM · WOODCUTTER · MUTANT BROTH · QUANTUM INSERT · NRTA · MERION ZETA · JTRIG · A-SPACE · GEOFUSION“Operation Socialist: The Inside Story of How British Spies Hacked Belgium’s Largest Telco” - The Intercept ↗ (2014-12-13) · “Lees hier hoe de Britse geheime dienst GCHQ Belgacom aanviel” - NRC ↗ (2014-12-13) · “Britse geheime dienst bespioneerde jarenlang Belgacom-klanten” - De Standaard ↗ (2014-12-13) · “Britain's GCHQ Hacked Belgian Telecoms Firm” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2013-09-20) · Gallagher, Ryan · Modderkolk, Huib · Vanhecke, Nikolas · Eeckhaut, Mark -
Laws on interception - Oversight - Implications for JCE (JCE UK Legalities Context) [pdf]
This GCHQ training presentation on UK surveillance laws, oversight mechanisms, and implications for Joint Collaborative Environment operations explicitly acknowledges that the UK has "a light oversight regime compared with US," detailing how RIPA, ISA, commissioners, and the Investigatory Powers Tribunal function to provide legal authorization while noting the Tribunal has "always found in our favour."
Programs: JTRIG