TSI — Legal Authorisation Flowcharts: Targeting & Collection

Open PDF
Creating agency: GCHQ Government Communications Headquarters (UK)
Document date: 2011-11-01
Pages: 4
Genre: slides
Banner:
Classification: UK CONFIDENTIAL
Dissemination: -

This document contains internal GCHQ flowcharts outlining the mandatory legal authorization required for both Targeting specific entities and Collection (interception) of communications content, based primarily on the target's location, nationality, and whether the activity involves UK or "Second Party" countries, primarily referencing the Regulation of Investigatory Powers Act (RIPA).

Long Description:
The document consists of two distinct legal authorization flowcharts: one for "Targeting" and one for "Collection," created for internal GCHQ use and subject to version control (Version 6, dated 11/08, for Targeting; Version 5, dated 11/06, for Collection). The Targeting Flowchart dictates the specific warrant or authorization regime needed before pursuing the communications of a particular company, organization, or individual. The required authorization (such as RIPA 8(1) warrant, 16(3) authorization, or STA) depends on a matrix considering the target's nationality/registration (UK, Second Party/BOT, Other/Unknown) against their location (UK, Second Party/BOT, Other/Unknown). It includes specific protocols for when a target is believed to be in the UK, requiring warrants, or if they unexpectedly arrive in the UK during an operation. The Collection Flowchart focuses on the authorization needed for intercepting communications themselves, distinct from naming a target. Intercepting only technical characteristics requires "No further authorisation." Collecting content, however, prompts checks regarding whether the collection is US-end, whether at least one end is foreign, and whether all intercept will pass through a TND or dictionary filter. Full, coarse, or unselected collection requires further consideration of proportionality and, in the case of collection involving US, Canadian, Australian, or New Zealand ends, requires a nominated Grade 6 STA (Senior Technical Advisor) or limitations on survey duration.
Programs:
-

People mentioned:
-

Countries:
-

Tags:
legal authorities, legal compliance, intelligence oversight, jurisdiction, target location, nationality, communications interception, surveillance policy, geolocation

Identifier:
gchq-tsi-target

PDF SHA-256:
00bfcb768ed7f84059678a3f9764fc23b9d6610d50e7691399b1531e58a6341d

UK CONFIDENTIAL
Version 6, dated 11/08
Side 1

The issue on GCWeb is the definitive version; printed copies may be out of date. Terms are defined in the glossary at http://www[REDACTED]/operations/pol_legal/leg/compliance/glossary.shtml.

Legal Authorisation Flowchart: TARGETING

SUMMARY

Nationality/Location UK 2nd Party /BOT Other or unknown
UK Warrant Warrant Warrant
2nd Party/BOT STA STA STA
Other or unknown STA STA Nil

Are you targeting the comms of a particular company, organisation or individual?
YES
NO
MAYBE
Is the target named on a 16(3) authorisation?
Filtering without targeting needs no additional authorisation. For tasking, consult the collection flowchart
Do you believe the target is in the UK? (see footnotes 1,2)
YES
NO/Don't know
MAYBE
Some domains/IPs/VPNs are for specific organisations, others are available to a range of users. Make a judgement.
Is the target specified on a RIPA 8(1) warrant and his comms address on the schedule?
YES
Appropriate legal authorisation in place. Go ahead.
NO
PTO

Footnotes
(1) Without authorisation, you must not indirectly target the communications of someone in the UK by using a foreign selector.
(2) In the absence of any other information, you should assume the user of a .uk email address is in the UK.
(3) In the absence of any other information, you may assume the user of a .com or other non-geographic address is not in the US.


UK CONFIDENTIAL
Version 6, dated 11/08
Side 2

The issue on GCWeb is the definitive version; printed copies may be out of date. Terms are defined in the glossary at http://www[REDACTED]/operations/pol_legal/leg/compliance/glossary.shtml.

Legal Authorisation Flowchart: TARGETING

NO
Were you already targeting their comms before their arrival in the UK?
NO
YES
You need a RIPA 8(1) warrant or 16(3) authorisation to begin collecting comms: consult OPP-LEG
Do you want to continue examination of intercept content?
NO
Targeting can remain on cover for a week or so but no examination of traffic is allowed. To establish when the target has left the UK, you should use geolocational tools if possible; otherwise you may examine one item of content every 48 hours.
NO/Don't Know
YES
You need a RIPA 16(5) authorisation from a nominated SCS to allow sustained targeting to continue up to 5 working days for NS, or 1 working day for SC & EWB; no new selectors.
Yes Beyond the validity of the RIPA 16(5)
You need a RIPA 8(1) warrant or RIPA 16(3) authorisation to continue collecting comms: consult OPP-LEG.
If you subsequently get information that the target is in the UK you must act on this new knowledge.
Is the entity in a BOT or a 2nd Party country? (see footnote 3)
YES
You need a nominated Grade 6 STA and can only use UK assets if target is in or a 2nd Party.
NO
Is the target a national of/registered in UK/BOT 2nd Party?
YES
NO
Appropriate legal authorisation in place. Go ahead.


UK CONFIDENTIAL
Version 5, dated 11/06
Side 1

The issue on GCWeb is the definitive version; printed copies may be out of date. Terms are defined in the glossary at http://www.[REDACTED]/operations/policy/legalities/authorisation/definitions.shtml.

Legal Authorisation Flowchart: COLLECTION

Will you intercept only technical characteristics?
YES
No further authorisation is required.
NO
Will you be intercepting comms content?
NO
Is one end US?
YES
You can survey for up to 2 hours' worth of data but may not return to the same bearer until you believe its composition has changed.
NO
You can assume appropriate legal authorisation is in place.
Is the collection at least one end foreign?
NO
Unlikely to be proper GCHQ business: consult OPP-LEG.
YES
Will all intercept pass through a TND or dictionary?
NO
ie this is full or coarse unselected take.
PTO
Some domains/VPNs are for specific organisations, others are available to a range of users. If you are in effect targeting a specific organisation, see the Targeting flowchart


UK CONFIDENTIAL
Version 5, dated 11/06
Side 2

The issue on GCWeb is the definitive version; printed copies may be out of date. Terms are defined in the glossary at http://www.[REDACTED]/operations/policy/legalities/authorisation/definitions.shtml.

Legal Authorisation Flowchart: COLLECTION

This is SD/survey so you should consider proportionality.

Is one end US/CAN/AUS/NZ?
NO
Assume appropriate authorisation is in place. Go ahead.
YES
Nominated Grade 6 STA is required. If the link is one end US you can survey for up to 2 hours' worth of data, but may not return to the same bearer until you believe its composition has changed