NSA Spied On Porn Habits As Part Of Plan To Discredit 'Radicalizers'
Open PDF +1 other copyDocument date: 2012-10-03
Pages: 7
Genre: report
Classification: TOP SECRET SI
Dissemination: REL TO USA, FVEY/FISA
Top-secret document reveals how NSA has been gathering records of online sexual activity and evidence of visits to pornographic websites as part of a proposed plan to harm the reputations of those whom the agency believes are radicalizing others through incendiary speeches
My notes
PREFACE (U)
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY/FISA) This SIGINT assessment examines access as one element in the process of Islamic radicalization in order to identify vulnerabilities. Using six prominent, globally-resonating foreign radicalizers as exemplars, this report focuses on the means they use to reach their intended audience and reveals potential vulnerabilities for exploitation. It should be read in conjunction with NSA report 3/RA/501518-12, which identifies vulnerabilities of authority.
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY) Information herein is based largely on Sunni extremist communications and includes disseminated SIGINT as well as collateral available between January 2008 and September 2012. The SIGINT information is from primary sources with direct access and is generally considered reliable. Greater specificity on the SIGINT sourcing is provided in the text. Included in the appendix are charts on ways that access has been affected and countermeasures taken; a comparison of radicalizers' access mechanisms; and a matrix that compares their authority, argument, countries where they resonate, and their personal vulnerabilities.
BACKGROUND (U)
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY) A previous SIGINT assessment report on radicalization indicated that radicalizers appear to be particularly vulnerable in the area of authority when their private and public behaviors are not consistent. (A) Some of the vulnerabilities, if exposed, would likely call into question a radicalizer's devotion to the jihadist cause, leading to the degradation or loss of his authority. Examples of some of these vulnerabilities include:
- Viewing sexually explicit material online or using sexually explicit persuasive language when communicating with inexperienced young girls;
- Using a portion of the donations they are receiving from the susceptible pool to defray their own personal expenses;
- Charging an exorbitant amount of money for their speaking fees and being singularly attracted by opportunities to increase their stature; or
- Being known to base their public messaging on questionable sources or using language that is contradictory in nature, leaving them open to credibility challenges.
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY) Issues of trust and reputation are important when considering the validity and appeal of the message. It stands to reason that exploiting vulnerabilities of character, credibility, or both, of the radicalizer and his message could be enhanced by an understanding of the vehicles he uses to disseminate his message to the susceptible pool of people and where he is vulnerable in terms of access.
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY) Examining how the six radicalizers establish and maintain access with different pools of people susceptible to their message -- and their perceptions of the difficulties in doing so -- suggests that there are vulnerabilities that can be exploited in terms of this access, and emerging radicalizers may be vulnerable on this point as well. Focusing on access reveals potential vulnerabilities that could be even more effectively exploited when used in combination with vulnerabilities of character or credibility, or both, of the message in order to shape the perception of the messenger as well as that of his followers.
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY/FISA) Six globally-resonating, radicalizers are used as exemplars in this assessment. The first three listed target an English-speaking audience, while the second three target an Arabic-speaking audience.
- names redacted
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY/FISA) One indicator of the potential effectiveness of these radicalizers is the extent of their resonance, i.e., the number and locations of individuals who respond to a radicalizer's message by contacting him using his publicly-known contact information. A significant proportion of the audience associated with the specified English-language radicalizers is located in Pakistan, yet none of these radicalizers appear to have any communicants in common. In addition, communications profiles of these English-language radicalizers reveal that very few of the contacts noted were associated with terrorism, suggesting that the target audience includes individuals who do not yet hold extremist views but who are susceptible to the extremist message.
|Well-known |Killing of | |-Disagrees
|cleric, |non-Muslim | identifying |with AQ on
name |extremist |occupiers is | information |some issues
redacted |financier, |justified | redacted |(e.g.
|and al- | | |targeting
|Qai'da | | |civilians)
|supporter | | |-Pragmatic
| | | |on "Arab
| | | |Spring"
--------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------
|Writings |The U.S. | |-Deceitful
|appear on |brought the | identifying |use of
name |numerous |9/11 attacks | information |funds
redacted |jihadi |upon itself | redacted |-Potential
|websites | | |for
| | | |contradic-
| | | |tory
| | | |statements
| | | |
--------------+---------------+---------------+---------------+---------------
|Well-known |Preaches | |-Charges
|cleric, |intolerance | identifying |exorbitant
name |famous for |for all | information |speaking
redacted |hostility |non-Sunni | redacted |fees
|towards |Muslims | |-Attracted
|non-Sunni | | |to fame
|Muslims | | |
| | | |
| | | |
--------------+----------------+---------------+---------------+---------------
|Well-known |The U.S. | |-Glamorous
|media |perpetrated | identifying |lifestyle
name |celebrity |the 9/11 | information |-Misinter-
redacted | |attacks | redacted |prets
| | | |Qur'an
| | | |-Possibly
| | | |misdirects
| | | |donations
--------------+----------------+---------------+---------------+---------------
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY/FISA) The third chart includes the radicalizers' presumed areas of authority, countries of resonance, and vulnerabilities as reported and documented in 3/RA/501518-12 202017Z JUN 12, "Terrorism/Islamic Radicalization: Global Radicalizers Vulnerable in Terms of Authority."
(TS//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY/FISA)
-------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------
RADICALIZERS |AUTHORITY |ARGUMENT |COUNTRIES |VULNERABILI-
| | |WITH HIGHEST |TIES
| | |RESONANCE |
-------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------
|Imprisoned |Non-Muslims | |-Online
|for inciting |are a threat | |promiscuity
name |hatred |to Islam | |-May
redacted |against | | |misdirect
|non-Muslims | | identifying |donations
| | | information |-Desire to
| | | redacted |stay out
| | | |of jail
| | | |results in
| | | |inconsistent
| | | |arguments
-------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+-------------
|Respected |Offensive | |- Online
|academic, |jihas is | |promiscuity
|promotes |justified | identifying |- Publishes
|al-Qai'da | | information |articles
|(AQ) | | redacted |without
|propaganda | | |checking
| | | |facts
-------------+-------------+-------------+--------------+--------------
Distribution for 3/OO/532318-12 - Google Chrome
about:blank
FM DIRNSA
TO NSA/TANGO ZULU
COS KINGSTON
COS PORT OF SPAIN
ZEN/ATF
ZEN/CMRCE DEPT
ZEN/CUSTOMS
ZEN/DEA
ZEN/DIA (DHS)
ZEN/DIA (JITF-CT)
ZEN/FAA
ZEN/INTERIOR
ZEN/J/STF J2/J39
ZEN/JOINT STAFF
ZEN/JUSTICE
ZEN/NRC
ZEN/SECHOME CIPD
ZEN/TRANSP DEPT
ZEN/USTR
Originator
DIRNSA
Serial
3/OO/532318-12
Report Date
03 October 2012
Who Got This Report?
Display in Original Format
Display in XML Format
Email a Copy of This Report
Dismiss Window