Secure key extraction by physical de-processing of Apple's A4 processor
Open PDFDocument date: 2011-01-01
Pages: 1
Genre: wiki
Classification: SECRET
Dissemination: NOFORN
An abstract from the CIA Trusted Computing Base Jamboree describing a physical chip decapping and de-processing attack on Apple's A4 processor to extract the embedded Global ID cryptographic key, which if successful would enable decryption of boot firmware across all A4-based Apple devices including the iPhone 4, iPod Touch and iPad.
-
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
-
Tags:
CIA, Apple, Apple A4, Global ID, GID key, AES, boot firmware, physical de-processing, chip decapping, hardware attack, iPhone 4, iPod, iPad, Samsung, Cortex A8, eFuse, non-volatile memory, Trusted Computing Base Jamboree, TCB Jamboree, Sandia National Laboratories, cryptographic key, side channel attack, firmware, exploit development, intelligence community, IC exploitation, mobile security, semiconductors
Identifier:
secure-key-extraction-by-physical-de-processing
PDF SHA-256:
335693a9a9462be8159d14541077d3edc433525904776771fb6ffcc591104bf2
My notes
[edit] (S//NF) Secure key extraction by physical de-processing of
Apple's A4 processor
(U) Presenters: [REDACTED] and [REDACTED] (U) The Apple A4 processor contains an on-board, AES cryptographic key called the Global ID (GID) that is believed to be shared across all current "iDevices". This GID key is used to un-wrap the keys that decrypt the corresponding boot firmware code stored in system non-volatile memory. Currently, the only way to examine unencrypted boot code is to gain execution through an exploitable software security flaw. However, Apple is quick to address these flaws with each new release of firmware and hardware.
(S//NF) The Intelligence Community is highly dependent on a very small number of security flaws, many of which are public, which Apple eventually patches. This presentation will discuss a method to physically extract the GID key. If successful, it would enable decryption and analysis of the boot firmware for vulnerabilities, and development of associated exploits across the entire A4-based product-line, which includes the iPhone® 4, the iPod touch® and the iPad®.
(S) Apple relies on commercial and proprietary relationships with major integrated circuit (IC) manufacturers to supply the internal hardware for their leading-edge consumer products. Therefore, design and manufacturing information about the A4 is closely held intellectual property (IP). Some reverse-engineering reports have concluded that the A4 is manufactured by Samsung Ltd. for exclusive use in Apple products. Their data is compelling. They have shown that the Samsung Cortex A8 µProcessor core layout is used in the A4. If that is true, then it is possible that other Samsung IP, such as its non-volatile memory technology, may be used in this chip. Programmable non-volatile memory (NVM) offers the most design flexibility, reliability and security to store proprietary critical product information, such as the GID key.
(S//NF) Although, Samsung is a major supplier of flash memory chips it also holds IP in the area of CMOS-compatible, eFuse technology. The eFuse memory is thought to offer more immunity to random data upset, and a higher level of anti-tamper resistance. Therefore, this type of memory would be ideal as a secure repository of critical product information on the A4. We will use comparative examples of known Samsung product, versus the A4, in order to determine the type and location of NVM. In addition, we will discuss the progress made to date to determine where the GID key is located on the A4 IC, and how it can be recovered by physical de-processing of the chip.
Published in the Same Report
(9 documents)
-
Leaky phone apps [pdf]
These GCHQ slides describe the "WARRIOR PRIDE" mobile intrusion capability being ported to iPhone and Android, with plugins for power management, remote microphone, high‑precision geolocation, kernel stealth, and self‑protection. It claims the ability to retrieve almost any content from infected phones (SMS/MMS, email, call records, photos, calendar, etc.). Part of GCHQ's project "Mobile Applications Project".
Programs: Mobile Applications Project · WARRIORPRIDE · DREAMYSMURF · NOSEYSMURF · TRACKERSMURF · PORUS · PARANOIDSMURF -
Apple A4/A5 Application Processors Analysis [pdf]
This document appears in a collection of presentations from a secret CIA-sponsored conference called the "Jamboree," where security researchers shared methods for exploiting vulnerabilities in consumer electronics. The presentation focused on analyzing Apple's A4 and A5 processors, which were used in iPhones and iPads, as part of broader intelligence agency efforts to extract encryption keys and find security weaknesses in Apple devices.
-
Black Budget: Cryptanalysis & Exploitation Services – Analysis of Target Systems [pdf]
This document is a budget justification for the NSA's Cryptanalysis & Exploitation Services project, which develops capabilities to defeat commercial encryption systems, exploit emerging communications technologies, and conduct vulnerability analysis against both foreign and domestic security products.
-
Differential Power Analysis on the Apple A4 Processor [pdf]
1 p.This presentation abstract details a non-invasive method to extract the global AES cryptographic key (GID) from Apple's A4 processor using Differential Power Analysis (DPA). Success would enable the Intelligence Community to decrypt the boot firmware on devices like the iPhone 4 and iPad, providing a persistent means to find vulnerabilities and develop exploits independent of patchable software flaws.
-
Rocoto: Implanting the iPhone [pdf]
A top secret abstract from the CIA's 2010 Trusted Computing Base Jamboree conference, describing a Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory presentation on efforts to create intelligence community exploitation tools for the iPhone 3G, including analysis of its firmware security architecture and leveraging community jailbreak methods for signals intelligence purposes.
-
Strawhorse: Attacking the MacOS and iOS Software Development Kit [pdf]
Abstract from the 2012 CIA Trusted Computing Base Jamboree, presented by Sandia National Laboratories, describing successful modification of Apple's Xcode 4.1 SDK to create a covert injection vector capable of embedding backdoors, exfiltrating developer private keys, forcing data transmission to intelligence listening posts, disabling ASLR in kernel extensions, and installing a keylogger via a modified OS X updater.
People: Thompson, Ken -
TCB Jamboree 2012 [pdf]
1 p.A TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN entry from NSA's internal WikiInfo-NF wiki describing the CIA Trusted Computing Base Jamboree — an annual conference hosted by CIA's Emerging Technologies Branch within the Information Operations Center, bringing together CIA analysts and contractors conducting research for the TCB programme, with NSA invited to participate through its own counterpart TCB programme.
-
TCB Jamboree 2012 Invitation [pdf]
The invitation to the CIA Information Operations Center's seventh annual Trusted Computing Base Jamboree, held at the Lockheed Martin Dulles Executive Plaza in Herndon, Virginia, February 7-9 2012 — an informal conference organised by the Engineering Development Group's Emerging Technologies Branch for developers working to circumvent or exploit new security capabilities, with a focus on applying Security Portfolio research results to Trusted Platform Module threats and opportunities and exploiting new attack vectors.
-
TPM Vulnerabilities to Power Analysis and An Exposed Exploit to Bitlocker [pdf]
A secret abstract from the Trusted Computing Base Jamboree describing research by Sandia National Laboratories into power analysis attacks against Trusted Platform Modules from five manufacturers — extracting RSA private keys non-invasively via wired power analysis and electromagnetic emissions, including a novel unpublished single-trace attack against a Chinese Remainder Theorem RSA implementation — and a case study demonstrating how the extracted TPM key enables circumvention of Microsoft BitLocker's root-of-trust system by modifying BIOS digest values without software-level detection.
Related Documents
-
Differential Power Analysis on the Apple A4 Processor [pdf]
1 p.This presentation abstract details a non-invasive method to extract the global AES cryptographic key (GID) from Apple's A4 processor using Differential Power Analysis (DPA). Success would enable the Intelligence Community to decrypt the boot firmware on devices like the iPhone 4 and iPad, providing a persistent means to find vulnerabilities and develop exploits independent of patchable software flaws.
-
Apple A4/A5 Application Processors Analysis [pdf]
This document appears in a collection of presentations from a secret CIA-sponsored conference called the "Jamboree," where security researchers shared methods for exploiting vulnerabilities in consumer electronics. The presentation focused on analyzing Apple's A4 and A5 processors, which were used in iPhones and iPads, as part of broader intelligence agency efforts to extract encryption keys and find security weaknesses in Apple devices.
-
Rocoto: Implanting the iPhone [pdf]
A top secret abstract from the CIA's 2010 Trusted Computing Base Jamboree conference, describing a Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory presentation on efforts to create intelligence community exploitation tools for the iPhone 3G, including analysis of its firmware security architecture and leveraging community jailbreak methods for signals intelligence purposes.
-
Strawhorse: Attacking the MacOS and iOS Software Development Kit [pdf]
Abstract from the 2012 CIA Trusted Computing Base Jamboree, presented by Sandia National Laboratories, describing successful modification of Apple's Xcode 4.1 SDK to create a covert injection vector capable of embedding backdoors, exfiltrating developer private keys, forcing data transmission to intelligence listening posts, disabling ASLR in kernel extensions, and installing a keylogger via a modified OS X updater.
People: Thompson, Ken -
TPM Vulnerabilities to Power Analysis and An Exposed Exploit to Bitlocker [pdf]
A secret abstract from the Trusted Computing Base Jamboree describing research by Sandia National Laboratories into power analysis attacks against Trusted Platform Modules from five manufacturers — extracting RSA private keys non-invasively via wired power analysis and electromagnetic emissions, including a novel unpublished single-trace attack against a Chinese Remainder Theorem RSA implementation — and a case study demonstrating how the extracted TPM key enables circumvention of Microsoft BitLocker's root-of-trust system by modifying BIOS digest values without software-level detection.