August 2009 NSA Cryptological School Course
Open PDFDocument date: 2009-08-01
Type: FOIA
Pages: 132
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: -
2009 NSA course materials for NSA personnel with access to bulk telephony and electronic communication metadata acquired pursuant to Sections 501 and 402 of FISA. ACLU/EFF FOIA Litigation.
My notes
The Office of General Counsel
OFFICE OF GENERAL COUNSEL
NSA
THIS PRESENTATION
IS CLASSIFIED
TOP SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
General Principles of Law
- Principle #1: Authority
(What is the authority to do my job?) - Principle #2 Restrictions
(Is the authority restricted in any way?)
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Constitution
Fourth Amendment
- Protects the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures.
- Requires probable cause for a search warrant.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Supreme Court Cases
- Olmstead v. U.S.
(1928) - Katz v. U.S.
(1967)
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Operation Shamrock: 1945-1975
- NSA received copies of international telegrams to, from, and transiting the U.S.
- Included virtually all international telegrams carried by major telecom carriers.
- In later years, 150,000 telegrams per month reviewed by NSA analysts
- Probably the largest governmental interception program affecting Americans ever undertaken
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Project Minaret: 1967-1973
(The Watch List)
- Names of U.S. persons used systematically as basis for selecting messages
- Foreign influence on Domestic Antiwar and Civil Rights Activists
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
E# Narcotics Collection: 1970-1973
- Telephone Links between the U.S. and South America collected
- Used Names of U.S. persons
- Obtained Communications that Law Enforcement could not acquire under Title III
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
The Problem...
- Congressional Inquiries
Church/Pike Committees - Information TO, FROM, and ABOUT U.S. Citizens was:
- Improperly Collected
- Improperly Retained
- Improperly Disseminated
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Results of Church Committee and Other Investigations
- Termination of illegal collection activities
- Executive Order requiring the establishment of procedures relating to U.S. person information
- Greater Executive and Legislative Oversight
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Congressional/Executive Response to IC Abuses
- Federal Law
- Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (as amended)
- Executive Order
- E.O. 12333
- Intelligence Activities
- Regulations and Procedures
- DoD 5240.1-R and
Classified Annex - USSID SPOO18 (USSID 18)
- Minimization Procedures
- DoD 5240.1-R and
End of Module One
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA)
- The FISA, was originally passed in 1978.
- Most recently amended in the FISA Amendments Act (FAA) of 2008.
- Defines “electronic surveillance” and requires an order from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC) to conduct such surveillance.
- As amended, by the FAA, requires that the USG obtain a court order to conduct electronic surveillance against US persons either in the US or abroad.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Definitions
- Electronic Surveillance
- U.S. Person
- Foreign Power
- Agent of a Foreign Power
- Contents
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FISA
“Electronic Surveillance”
- f(1): acquisition of communications of particular known USP inside the US by targeting that person
- f(2): acquisition of wire communication to or from a person in the US if acquisition occurs inside the US
- f(3): acquisition of radio communications if all parties to the communication are located inside the US
- f(4): monitoring in the US to acquire information other than from a radio or wire communication
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Definitions -- U.S. Persons
- U.S. Citizen
- Permanent Resident Alien
(Green Card Holder) - Corporations (incorporated in the U.S.)
- Associations (primary membership
composed of U.S. persons) - U.S. flagged ships/aircraft
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Definitions -- Foreign Power
- A foreign government or any component thereof
- A faction of a foreign nation
- An entity openly acknowledged to be directed or controlled by a foreign government(s)
- A group engaged in international terrorism
- A foreign based political organization
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Definitions -- Agent of a foreign power
- An officer or employee of a foreign power
- A spy, terrorist, saboteur, aider/abettor, or conspirator
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Definitions -- Contents
- Communications
- Any information concerning the identity of the parties to such communications
- OR
- “Substance”
- “Purport”
- “Meaning”
- “Existence”
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FISA Amendments Act of 2008
- Became law in July 2008
- Applies to targets overseas
- Sections 702/703/704/705
FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 702
- Authorizes the USG to gather foreign intelligence by targeting foreign persons reasonably believed to be outside the US with authorization jointly executed by the AG and DNI.
- The government must employ targeting procedures and minimization procedures which comply with the statute and which are reviewed by the FISC.
- Prohibits “reverse targeting”.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 703
- Authorizes “electronic surveillance” against a USP reasonably believed to be outside of the US, but --
- An order from the FISC is required.
- Target must be a “foreign power”, “agent of a foreign power”, or officer or employee of a foreign government.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 704
- Authorizes “other acquisitions” targeting US persons overseas – but
- An order from the FISC is required.
- The FISC does not review surveillance techniques.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 705
- (U) Section 705 has two parts, 705(a) and 705(b).
- (U) 705(a) – a judge may simultaneously authorize acquisitions conducted both inside and outside of the US against a USP overseas (703 and 704).
- (U) 705(b) – if there is an existing FISA order authorizing surveillance of target inside of the US, the AG can authorize targeting while the USP is reasonably believed to be outside of the US.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FISA Procedures
- Establishes the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court
- Provides criteria/requirements for applications
- Establishes Congressional Oversight
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
E.O. 12333
United States Intelligence Activities
- Provides goals, directions, and responsibilities for the Intelligence Community
- Defines NSA's responsibilities (Part 1.7(c))
- Requires each agency to have AG-approved procedures, for collection, processing and dissemination of U.S. person information
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
E.O. 12333
United States Intelligence Activities
- Collection, Processing, and Dissemination of Signals Intelligence for National Foreign Intelligence Purposes.
- Collection, Processing, and Dissemination for Signals Intelligence for Counterintelligence Purposes.
- SIGINT Support for Military Operations.
- Information Assurance.
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
REGULATIONS
DoD 5240.1-R (1982)
- Procedures Governing the Activities of DoD Intelligence Components that Affect U.S. Persons
- NSA/CSS Policy 1-23
- Procedures Governing the Activities of NSA/CSS that Affect U.S. Persons
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
End of Module Two
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
(U//FOUO) FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705 Minimization Procedures
(U//FOUO) Anyone targeting US persons located outside of the US under FAA is required to read and be familiar with the minimization procedures
(U) The Overall Classification of this presentation is TOP SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
SECRET//COMINT// [REDACTED]
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Requirements
FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
(U) The FAA may authorize collection against:
- ✓ A US person
- ✓ Reasonably believed to be outside of the US
- ✓ To acquire foreign intelligence information
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
2
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Limitations
NSA Surveillance Under Sections 703, 704, and 705
- (U) NSA CANNOT use FAA authorities to target:
- Anything/Anyone in the US
- (U//FOUO) NSA FAA data CANNOT be:
- ~ Accessed without being properly trained on NSA’s FAA minimization procedures
- ~ Processed at locations other than those approved by SID
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
3
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 703
- • (U) An order from the FISC to target a US person reasonably believed to be outside the US
- • (U) Authorizes “electronic surveillance” or the acquisition of stored electronic communications or stored electronic data
- • (U) Authorization for up to 90 days
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
4
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 704
- (U) An order from the FISC to target a US person reasonably believed to be outside the US
- (U) Authorizes “other acquisitions” targeting US persons overseas (techniques are not described to the court)
- (U) Authorization for up to 90 days
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
5
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED
(U) FISA Amendments Act of 2008
Section 705
- (U) Section 705 has two parts, 705(a) and 705(b).
- (U) 705(a) authorizes the Government to request, and a judge to issue a single order authorizing 703 and 704 surveillance
- (U) 705(b) authorizes the AG to approve surveillance of a US person overseas if the FISC has already issued an order authorizing electronic surveillance or physical search against that US person in the US
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
6
UNCLASSIFIED
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
NSA Minimization Procedures Under FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
Minimization Procedures need to be Followed Unless...
- (U//FOUO) To protect US National Security, life or property, or for Law enforcement purposes – NSA may deviate from Standard Minimization Procedures with AG approval (coordinate in advance with NSA OGC)
- (U//FOUO) If advance coordination is not feasible and NSA needs to act in order to protect against immediate threat to human life – consult with NSA OGC who must report any such action within 7 days to DOJ.
- (U) If you believe you must deviate from the procedures, YOU MUST GO TO NSA/OGC FIRST!!!
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
7
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
NSA Minimization Procedures Under FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
(U) Collection
(S//SI//[REDACTED])
- NSA must terminate collection promptly if NSA learns that a targeted US person is located in the US
- Collection against a US person in the US may only be reinstated in accordance with the FISA
- NSA may resume collection if the target departs the US during the life of the order
- Selectors for 704 and 705 surveillances may be tasked
[REDACTED]
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
8
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
NSA Minimization Procedures Under FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
(U) Processing
- (U//FOUO) Searches or reviews of collected materials must be designed, to the extent operationally possible, to minimize the risk of returning data concerning unconsenting US person’s who are not the target of authorized surveillance
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
9
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
NSA Minimization Procedures Under FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
(U) Retention
- (S//SI//[REDACTED]) The following communications shall be destroyed upon recognition unless the AG authorizes retention:
- Inadvertent collection of communications while the target enters the US
- Inadvertent collection of communications in which all the communicants are in the US
- Inadvertent collection of communications in which all the communicants are US persons who are not authorized targets
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
10
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
(U) AG Destruction Waiver
Inadvertent Collection:
- All communicants inside the US
- All communicants are US person’s who are not authorized targets
- The authorized target is in the US
Data shall be destroyed unless the AG determines that the communication contains:
- Significant foreign intelligence
- Evidence of a serious crime
- Information related to a threat of serious harm to life or property
- Technical information about a communications vulnerability
(S/SI//[REDACTED])
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
11
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
(U) Without AG Destruction Waiver
Inadvertent Collection:
- • Of US domestic communications
- • Against an unauthorized target
Even without a Destruction Waiver, technical data concerning such communications may be retained for collection avoidance purposes
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
SECRET//COMINT//[REDACTED]
12
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Retention
- (U//FOUO) NSA may retain FAA data in databases for up to 5 years without additional authorization
- (U//FOUO) NSA’s SIGINT Director may authorize retention for a longer period in response to an authorized foreign intelligence or counterintelligence requirement
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
13
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Incident Reporting
- (U//FOUO) All incidents should be reported at the time of recognition AND again in the IG Quarterly report
- (U//FOUO) Incidents include:
- Inadvertent and incidental collection
- Unauthorized targets
- Collection continued on targets inside the U S
- Unauthorized access to data:
- By unauthorized personnel
- By untrained personnel
- At non-SID-approved locations
- Inappropriate storage, labeling, or handling
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
14
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U) Requirements for Data Access
- (U//FOUO) To gain access to data both the individual user and the location must be certified
- The user must:
- Complete this training (renewing it every two years)
- Maintain current Annual Intelligence Oversight readings
- Work under DIRNSA’s full operational & technical control
- Have a mission need
- • The location must:
- Operate under DIRNSA’s full operational & technical control
- Possess a delegated mission
- Have SID approval for access to FAA data
- Have an established oversight infrastructure
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
15
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
FAA Sections 703, 704, & 705
(U) Where to go for Help
- OGC: DL GC_FISA
(after hours contact NSOC SOO to get in touch with OGC) - Oversight and Compliance: DL FISATEAM
- Targeting Mission Management (TMM): DL OPSDICTS
- Documents Available at SV1 Homepage: (‘go SV’)
- For the Minimization Procedures document
- Comparison charts of 703/704/705 orders
- Specific targets authorized under these sections
Targeting US persons located outside of the US
16
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
USSID SPOO18
Legal Compliance and Minimization Procedures
- Main body of SPO018 Compilation of responsibilities from the FISA, E.O. 12333, and DoD Regulation 5240.1-R as they apply to the U.S. SIGINT system
- covers collection, processing, retention, and dissemination
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
What is “Collection”?
- Targeting a SPECIFIC COMMUNICANT (e.g. a terrorist, a foreign minister, a computer hacker)
- Collecting based upon SUBJECT MATTER (e.g. nuclear proliferation, oil sales, economics)
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Targeting Specific Communicants SPO018 Section 4
The Four Rules
- No [REDACTED] without Attorney general approval
- No U.S. Persons in the U.S. without a Court Order
- No U.S. persons outside the U.S. without a Court Order
- Foreign persons outside the U.S. --- fair game
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Targeting by Subject Matter
USSID SPO018 Section 5
- Selection terms that:
- have intercepted or
- are likely to intercept
- U.S. Person communications
- MUST BE DESIGNED
- (to the greatest extent practicable under the circumstances)
- to DEFEAT communications that
- do not contain foreign intelligence
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Targeting Issues
Presumptions
(If no other information is available)
- In the U.S., then U.S. person
- Outside the U.S., then foreigner
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Targeting Definitions
Targeting U.S. Persons
- INADVERTENT (Did not know is a U.S. Person)
- INCIDENTAL (Legitimate foreign target; as a by product NSA acquires U.S. Person information/communications)
- REVERSE (Target foreign entity to intentionally acquire U.S. Person information/communications)
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
USSID SPOO18
Dissemination
- Allow access to non-minimized raw traffic voice/data database
- Provide copy of a non-minimized piece of raw traffic
- Disclose (orally or in writing) the contents of non-minimized raw traffic
- Disclose (orally or in writing) the identity of a U.S. person contained in an NSA product
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
USSID SPOO18
Dissemination
- Authorized Recipients of Raw Traffic
- THE SIGINT PRODUCTION CHAIN
- People who Collect Raw Traffic
- People who Process Raw Traffic
- People who Retain Raw Traffic
- People who Manage the SIGINT Process
- People who do Oversight of the SIGINT Process
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
USSID SPOO18
Dissemination
Examples of Non-SIGINT Production Personnel
- A Customer in Another Agency (e.g. CIA, FBI)
- Another Agency’s Liaison Representative to NSA
- Non-SIGINT producing NSA Organizations or Personnel (e.g Security (Q), Personnel (MD))
- NSA Employees Detailed/Assigned to Another Agency (e.g. CIA/TMO, IOTC)
- Any person not necessary to Produce the SIGINT Product
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
End of Module Three
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Questions?
- Who is the target?
- – U.S. Person or Non-U.S. Person
- Where is the target?
- – In the U.S. or Outside the U.S.
- What kind of communications will be collected?
- – Private (e-mail, wire, cell, encrypted) or Non-Private
- How will the communications be collected?
- – Passively or Actively
- Where will the communications be collected?
- – In the U.S. or Outside the U.S., or in International Waters, or from Outer Space
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Questions?
Office of General Counsel
(Operations/Intel Law)
NSOC has an attorney on call 24/7!
Database Access Briefing
USSID SP0018 and Raw Traffic Databases
(U//FOUO) Contact O&C or the OGC if you have questions about this material
NSA SID Oversight and Compliance (Database Team): [REDACTED] (nsts)
dl u18dbtarget
NSA SID Oversight and Compliance (Reporting Team): [REDACTED] (nsts)
[REDACTED]
dl ussid18
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U//FOUO) Contact O&C or the OGC if you have questions about this material
NSA Office of the General Counsel (Ops): (nsts)
dl gcoops (for NT users)
(for UNIX systems)
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U//FOUO) Module 5
Administration and Background
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U//FOUO) Briefing Lifespan
- 2 Years – With use of USSID SP0018 sensitive databases
- 6 Months – Without use of USSID SP0018 sensitive databases
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Why is this training required?
This training covers access to and use of “Raw SIGINT” data and databases.
Raw SIGINT is: Results of collection BEFORE the information has been evaluated for foreign intelligence AND minimization purposes, per USSID CR1610.
“Analysts are not permitted … to roam freely in the universe of collected communications, examining messages which are not directly related to their assigned tasks.”
-Office of Intelligence Policy and Review
Raw SIGINT access is restricted to those within a SIGINT Production Chain as defined by USSID CR1610.
There is no single “SPC”.
There are SPCs at various levels from organic SIGINT assets in the field through the NSA Product Line level.
Raw SIGINT databases contain completely innocent U.S. person communications and non-foreign intelligence information as well as FI.
Confidential//XX1
Database Queries = collection/targeting
Dictionary Tasking = collection/targeting
Protecting U.S. Persons’ rights is only half the story. USSID SP0018, section 5.1 states that analysts must also ensure, to the greatest extent possible, that queries only target Foreign Intelligence.
Sharing of SIGINT
In this age of data and information sharing, we must remain mindful of the current regulations that prohibit the casual sharing of SIGINT.
E.O.12333, section 2.3 specifically addresses this.
Targeting for Personal Purposes
If you know someone is using the SIGINT system for personal purposes, YOU have the responsibility to report the activity.
SECRET//COMINT//20291123
Auditing Requirements
USSID CR1610 Annex A details auditing requirements for certain raw SIGINT systems. This auditing meets Department of Justice mandates for NSA’s operations.
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20291123
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Derivative Databases
If data is saved into another file or database, that derivative database must have the same access, auditing and retention issues that the originating database held
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Access and Retention
USSID SP0018, Section 6
- 5 Years on-line
- Up to 10 years off-line – request for historical searches made to OIPR
- Some retention exceptions
- Recognizes intrusiveness of SIGINT
- FISA Data: Depends upon nature of data –check USSID SP0018, Annex A, and/or call SV
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
Accountability of Access
NSA must account for:
- 1. Who uses SIGINT databases
- 2. What purpose
- 3. From what location
- 4. Under what controls
Therefore, accesses must be re-justified if:
- You Change Offices or Mission
- You Change Locations
- You Change Auditors
- Your Account Lapses Due to Inactivity for 90 days
End of Module 5
(U//FOUO) Module 6
Protections and Restrictions
(U//FOUO) How do we protect ourselves?
The best way to protect ourselves and our SIGINT is to play by the rules.
No matter how inconvenient the rules may seem, if we fail to adhere to them, the next set of rules will be far stricter.
(U//FOUO) There are very few things we cannot accomplish within the existing rules, using the authorities we have and those authorities we can receive.
Confidential//XX1
(U//FOUO) Each phase of Production (collection, processing, retention, and dissemination) must be:
Accountable Defensible
Repeatable Retrievable
(C/[REDACTED]) Violations of authorities must be reported:
- at the time of recognition to SID O&C
- as part of the E.O. 12333 quarterly report to the IG
(U//FOUO) If you determine that you have made a targeting mistake:
- Stop the query as soon as possible
- Notify your auditor
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Anyone using NSA SIGINT databases must abide by the same rules and authorities as NSA.
Access to these databases is restricted to persons operating under DIRNSA authority.
(C//[REDACTED]) In addition to having a National Foreign Intelligence purpose (which includes FI, Counter-intelligence and Support to Military Operations), the following general rules apply:
(C//[REDACTED]) Additional authority is required to target:
- U.S. persons (anywhere) or people within U.S. territory
[REDACTED]
(C//[REDACTED]) What is a Second Party Person?
In general terms, we apply the same basic definitions of a Second Party person as we apply for U.S. people.
U.S. Identities in SIGINT, Section 9 contains full definitions of each Second Party person.
(U//FOUO) End of Module 6
(U//FOUO) Module 7
Production Guidance
(U//FOUO) Targeting Clarifications
Each query is an act of targeting.
Start queries narrow; widen as necessary. Look out for queries that are too broad.
Reasonableness, Not Perfection!
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(U//FOUO) Targeting takes place at front end via dictionaries AND at the keyboard with follow-on queries
Choose qualifiers carefully
- “AND” and “BUT NOT” will reduce your results
- “OR” will expand your returns exponentially
UNCLASSIFIED//FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) E-Mail Address Targeting
Specific e-mail addresses of valid foreign intelligence targets outside countries may be targeted regardless of email domain without additional authority.
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) E-Mail Address Targeting
Do Not:
- Wildcard domains
- Wildcard user names
- Wildcard across domains
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Dissemination Clarifications
E-mail addresses with U.S. domains may be included in dissemination if:
a. the user is a foreign national (excluding AUS/CAN/NZL/GBR)
b. Information is disseminated only to recipients who have a specific need for full addresses for a lawful government purpose.
(S//SI// ) Targeting Clarifications
Targeting:
- Permanently assigned?
- - Check Lookup tools BEFORE the first query
- - Defeat domains using the same but not a part of your target
- - Do not wildcard
(S//SI//[REDACTED] Targeting Clarifications
Avoid general search terms without valid FI selectors
visa password narcotics
Bank
(Based on USSID SP0018, Sect. 5.1.c)
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Sole Selectors
Targeting all communications on a given will flood you with information that has no FI value or is to/from/about USPs
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Avoid Site SIGADS as Sole Selectors
Do you need to see all information from a given site, or just select topics?
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Avoid Names as Sole Selectors
Use locations, associates, or activities to focus searches on your target and not just anyone with that same name
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20201123
(C//SI// ) Targeting foreign flagged ships or aircraft located in US territorial waters or airspace:
- -COMINT stops at 12nm without additional authority
- - ELINT to coastline and beyond pursuant to USSID AP2231
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20291123
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20320108
[REDACTED] allowed if specific FI selectors are used as well.
(ex: [REDACTED]
AND [REDACTED])
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20320108
(C//[REDACTED]) Dissemination Clarifications
Equipment and product designators, such as [REDACTED], and brand names may be included in SIGINT reports, if the focus is on the product, not the manufacturer of the product.
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20201123
(C//SI//[REDACTED]) Targeting Deceased U.S. People or communications devices registered to them requires:
a. a VERY strong foreign intelligence purpose
b. mission driver
c. approval of the NSA OGC
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20201123
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20320108
(C//SI//[REDACTED]) Targeting Deceased People or communications devices registered to them requires:
a. a VERY strong foreign intelligence purpose
b. mission driver
c. approval of the appropriate
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20320108
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20320108
(C//SI//[REDACTED]) Dissemination Clarification
Can deceased protected persons be named in dissemination?
- U.S. : YES
- : NO
CONFIDENTIAL//COMINT//20320108
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) DO NOT USE Raw Traffic repositories to verify the protected status of an entity.
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Protected entities listed by name or context in dissemination do not imply collection is authorized.
(C//[REDACTED]) Imminent Threat to Safety
COLLECTION: USSID SP0018, 4.1.d.(1)
DIRNSA may authorize the collection to, from, or about a USP outside the U.S. when life or physical safety is reasonably believed to be in immediate danger.
Contact NSOC
(C//[REDACTED]) Dissemination Clarification
DISSEMINATION: USSID SP0018, 7.2.c.(6)
Information indicates that the identity of the USP is pertinent to a possible threat to the safety of any person or organization, including those who are targets, victims or hostages of international terrorist organizations.
(C//[REDACTED]) Dissemination Clarification
If a person is in imminent danger and you have relevant information, you may disseminate that information unmasked in product and follow-up with SV afterwards.
(C//[REDACTED]) Why do we still need this level of oversight?
Past Abuses
targeting of international telegrams
Present Examples
targeting of
(C//[REDACTED]) Why do we still need this level of oversight?
Past Abuses
Phone lines into the U.S. for identities of U.S. based narcotics smugglers
Present Examples
Restaurant in Texas to identify narcotics smuggler
(C// ) Why do we still need this level of oversight?
Past Abuses
Watch-listing U.S. people for evidence of foreign influence
Present Examples
Unauthorized targeting of suspected terrorists in U.S.
(U//FOUO) End of Module 7
(U//FOUO) Module 8
Dissemination Guidance
(U//FOUO) U.S. location identifiers in reports
Some US identifiers may be included when used in a LOCATIONAL SENSE (i.e. They identify a place).
- RESTAURANTS
- AIRLINE FLIGHT NUMBERS
- HOTELS
- AIRPORTS
(U//FOUO) Avoid Contextual Identification
Don’t provide so much detail about a masked protected identity that the reader could determine who is being referenced due to context.
(C//[REDACTED]) Dissemination Authority
Generally, to include the identity of a U.S. person or entity in SIGINT product (by name, title, or context):
1) it must be necessary to understand or assess the foreign intelligence, and
2) the recipient must need that information to perform his/her official duties.
3) You will need the approval of Chief Information Sharing Services.
4) Keep your focus on the foreign intelligence.
(U//FOUO) End of Module 8
(C//[REDACTED])
No chaining from or through U.S. contacts (email, phone, etc.)
Contacts Masked
(U//FOUO)
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
(S//SI//[REDACTED]) Why do U.S. SIGINT analysts care?
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
SECRET//COMINT//20320108
(S//SI// ) Tasking must comply with USSID SP0018 and [REDACTED].
SECRET//COMINT//20320108