BLARNEY report April 2013

Open PDF
Creating agency: NSA National Security Agency (US)
Document date: 2013-04-23
Pages: 7
Genre: report
Banner:
Classification: TOP SECRET COMINT
Dissemination: REL TO USA, FVEY

This NSA document describes the deployment of surveillance systems (RINGBILL, TURTLEPOWER, SKIDROWE) at "TITAN POINTE" to process bulk communications data including VoIP and video teleconferencing traffic. The systems are designed to intercept, filter, and analyze high-volume network traffic using legacy architecture initially, with plans to transfer to newer processing solutions for long-term mass surveillance capabilities.

Long Description:
This NSA document from April 2013 details the technical implementation of mass surveillance infrastructure under codename "RINGBILL" at a facility called "TITAN POINTE." The project involves deploying multiple interconnected surveillance systems—including VISIONQUEST, SKIDROWE, XKeyscore (XKS), and TURTLEPOWER—to process what the document refers to as "DNI" (Digital Network Intelligence) at unusually high data rates. The NSA engineers describe using legacy WC2/XKS systems initially because newer solutions won't be ready until mid-2013, requiring special network configurations "to be capable of higher than normal throughput." The document reveals concerns about overwhelming their PINWALE storage partitions (NSA's metadata repository) with the sheer volume of intercepted data, necessitating filtering mechanisms. Significantly, the engineers note they need to develop capabilities to "associate signaling with media cuts" for VoIP processing and implement "filtering based on dialing patterns"—indicating bulk collection of phone conversations that are then selectively stored based on call patterns. The document also describes deploying TURTLEPOWER, a specialized VoIP processing system, specifically because it can handle "desk phone conversations" from the RINGBILL data stream faster than their existing Trireme solution. The justification emphasizes speed: delivering intercepted voice communications to analysts sooner by using "potentially unique data found in the BLARNEY environments." The technical work tasks reveal the infrastructure's scale—ordering specialized equipment, installing 10-gigabit network cards, duplicating fiber optic signals with splitters, and conducting system design reviews.

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on: 4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Blarney-40-12
Work in Progress
ECP Lead: [REDACTED]

Title of Change: DNI Processing of RINGBILL Access
Site(s): TITAN POINTE :
Project(s): No Project(s) Entered
System(s): VISIONQUEST :
SubSystem(s): No Subsystem(s) Entered

Description of Change: This is a partially historical ECP to track efforts performed for processing the DNI portion of RINGBILL. The initial processing of RINGBILL will be performed on our legacy WC2/XKS systems (using Trireme for VoIP & VTC traffic). Once we stand up SKIDROWE, the processing will transfer to that solution so we will need to be cognizant of any and all requirements that should be defined for the SKIDROWE team to enable our solution.

Because we are initially using our legacy systems there will be extra work required to configure them and the network to be capable of higher than normal throughput. There will also be work to determine what kind of filtering is required so that we don't overwhelm our PINWALE partitions. Finally, it is already apparent that further work will be required on the VoIP processing to associate signaling with media cuts. Once that is complete we will be able to look into filtering based on dialing patterns.

Reason for Change: We now have access to the RINGBILL DNI and rather than waiting until the June/July timeframe to use the new solution for processing, we have developed an interim solution for processing the high data rates on existing architecture.

Mission Impact: These efforts are an interim solution to process the RINGBILL signal months earlier than we orginally planned. Resources will have to be prioritized against other efforts.

Additional Info:

Last CCB Entry: 04/10/13 15:44:43 [REDACTED]
09 Apr CCB - ECP status reviewed

Work Task ID: WT00010435
Status: Reassigned
Life Cycle Phase:
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:31:14 --- 4/11/13 - NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Update Baseline - DNI Processing of RINGBILL Access
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010584
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:31:49 --- 4/11/13 - NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Enable DNI Processing of RINGBILL through [REDACTED] WC2 architecture
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 23 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on: 4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Work Task ID: WT00010585
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:32:25 --- 4/11/13 - NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Enable VoIP processing of RINGBILL desk [REDACTED]
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586
Status: Being Worked
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/03/13 15:51:25 --- XKS has been loaded on the two SR systems at TP. The TW release is expected by the end of April, though this may push out again. There are some planned RPM updates for XKS that will be installed next week.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Deploy SKIDROWE solution for RINGBILL DNI Processing
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-1
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:33:02 --- 4/11/13 - NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Define RINGBILL Hardware Requirements
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-2
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 08/22/12 13:56:48 --- Order equipment for the RINGBILL SKIDROWE system
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Order Skidrow Equipment
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-3
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 01/16/13 09:33:07 --- All equipment associated with the RINGBILL SKIDROWE has been ordered and received. Closing worktask.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Order Additional Parts
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-4
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 08/22/12 14:03:13 --- Receive equipment that was ordered.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Recieve Ordered Equipment
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 24 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on: 4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Work Task ID: WT00010586-5
Status: Being Worked
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/03/13 15:52:20 --- XKS has been upgraded to 1.5.11 and we have begun to test, though we need to install some patches before we can continue. We are still waiting for TW software.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Stand up Test System
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-6
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 12/05/12 15:57:17 --- Servers have been installed at site and powered on. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Test the RINGBILL SKIDROWE Servers.
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-7
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 12/05/12 16:00:07 --- Completed.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Install 10G NICs in each RINGBILL SKIDROWE [REDACTED]
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-8
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 01/16/13 09:39:48 --- Rack elevations and network plan has been developed an has been incorporated into site documentation. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Design Site Plan
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-9
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 02/21/13 14:50:16 --- Equipment has been shipped to site and installed. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Transport Equipment to Site
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-10
Status: Assigned
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:34:12 --- 4/11/2013 - NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Load System and Test Functionality
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 25 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on: 4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Work Task ID: WT00010586-11
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 02/21/13 14:00:40 --- Signal has been duplicated with a 30/70 splitter. When [REDACTED] we're ready to start processing we'll have to see if the light levels are good enough. [REDACTED] also has a 50/50 splitter at site that we can try if need be. Marking as complete and will reopen if further work needs to be performed.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Duplicate RINGBILL Signal to the SKIDROWE [REDACTED]
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-12
Status: Assigned
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:35:55 --- NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Declare System IOC
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-13
Status: Assigned
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/11/13 08:36:10 --- NTR
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Decommission WCT05
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-14
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 08/22/12 14:24:44 --- Completed 6/26/12
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Perform Site Survey
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-15
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 01/16/13 09:35:03 --- This was completed as part of the ERB. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Conduct System Design Review
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-16
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 01/16/13 09:35:34 --- Completed during the ERB for SKIDROWE. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Obtain ETS TD Approval of System Design
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 26 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on: 4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Work Task ID: WT00010586-17
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 01/16/13 09:36:08 --- ERB presentation was completed and approved. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: ERB Processing Recommendation Matrix
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010586-18
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 01/16/13 09:36:39 --- This was completed as part of the ERB. Closing ticket.
ECP Number: Blarney-40-12
Description: Schedule/Conduct Depolyment Readiness [REDACTED] (DRR)
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 27 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on: 4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Blarney-55-12
Work in Progress
ECP Lead: [REDACTED]

Title of Change: Deployment of TURTLEPOWER system in VQ environment
Site(s): No Site(s) Entered
Project(s): No Project(s) Entered
System(s): VISIONQUEST:
SubSystem(s): No Subsystem(s) Entered

Description of Change: This ECP will encompass working with CES [REDACTED] to stand up and forward deploy a TURTLEPOWER system for the purpose of processing VoIP. Installation will occur [REDACTED] followed by deployment to TP and testing against the RINGBILL data. If successful we could turn this into an operational system and work through the details for tasking and number normalization.

Reason for Change: The primary purpose of this system will be to determine its VoIP processing capabilities, though other capabilities will likely be examined as well. Trireme requires some development to support desk phone conversations of the RINGBILL data and it has been conveyed that TURTLEPOWER has the capability already. We are proposing deploying a TURTLEPOWER system to test this capability and potentially provide a solution for forwarding SIGINT to the to TOPIs in a compressed timeframe (comparitvely to the Trireme solution.

This also provides BLARNEY an opportunity to help TURTLEPOWER develop their capabilities by using potentially unique data found in the BLARNEY environments. Any derived enhancements to TURTLEPOWER will help the agency as a whole.

Mission Impact: This effort will potentially allow us to deliver RINGBILL voice cuts to the TOPI sooner than waiting for the Trireme solution. It also allows us to make sure we're using the best processing solution for the job.

This will be worked in accordance to priorites as set by the BAT branch so other mission will not be negatively impacted.

Additional Info:

Last CCB Entry: 04/10/13 15:47:00 [REDACTED]
09 Apr CCB - ECP status reviewed.

Work Task ID: WT00010899
Status: New
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: None ATT
ECP Number: Blarney-55-12
Description: Update Baseline - Deployment of TURTLEPOWER system in VQ environment
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Work Task ID: WT00010944
Status: Completed
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 12/05/12 15:50:37 --- System has been deployed, configured, and is processing operational data. A DMR was submitted and approved prior to going live with operational processing on November 16th.
Marking ticket completed as this system is now in an operational capacity.
ECP Number: Blarney-55-12
Description: Installation and configuration of initial TP server
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 29 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY

TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY
(Report generated on:4/23/2013 7:00:17AM)

Work Task ID: WT00010945
Status: Being Worked
Life Cycle Phase: [REDACTED]
Last Log Entry: --- 04/03/13 15:49:37 -- Test data has been provided to PE to further develop against non SKINNY protocols in an effort to perform processing against a broader scope of data. We are currently waiting for their feedback on progress and what it would take to improve the system performance.
ECP Number: Blarney-55-12
Description: Analysis of Turtlepower Proceessing in BLARNEY
Assigned To: [REDACTED]

Page 30 of 51
TOP SECRET//COMINT//REL TO USA, FVEY