NSA El Paso Intelligence Center Trip Report 2008

Open PDF
Creating agency: NSA National Security Agency (US)
Document date: 2008-02-20
Pages: 3
Genre: report
Banner:
Classification: CONFIDENTIAL
Dissemination: REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL

This internal NSA memo summarizes a meeting held on February 20, 2008, regarding the deployment of the Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) system at the El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC), a DEA-led facility. It details challenges in funding, staffing, legal policies, and coordination between DEA, DHS, and NSA, with the goal of enhancing intelligence sharing and operational capabilities for law enforcement, and using RT-RG on the U.S.-Mexico border.

Long Description:
This NSA memorandum outlines a meeting held on February 20, 2008, to discuss the potential deployment of the Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) system at the El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC), a DEA-led facility that coordinates intelligence across various law enforcement agencies. The memo highlights key logistical and legal challenges that emerged during the discussions, particularly in relation to securing funding, determining appropriate staffing, and addressing the complex legal frameworks surrounding intelligence sharing between federal agencies. At the heart of the discussions was the DEA's eagerness to move forward with the RT-RG deployment, despite the absence of a clear funding source, with DEA officials requesting up to $10 million from the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI). Staffing concerns were raised due to the uncertainty around the legal authorities under which the RT-RG system would operate, as well as the differing legal frameworks governing intelligence collection. The memo further reveals tensions within the agencies involved, particularly regarding the technical challenges of integrating RT-RG with EPIC’s existing infrastructure, including issues related to connectivity and bandwidth. Despite these hurdles, there was significant enthusiasm from the DEA, who were particularly keen on the operational benefits that RT-RG could offer in terms of real-time intelligence for combating drug trafficking, human smuggling, and other cross-border criminal activities. Additionally, the document touches on the need to address the role of the DEA’s Special Operations Division (SOD) in coordinating and deconflicting law enforcement operations based on intelligence from RT-RG. There was also concern about the potential complications arising from the sharing of sensitive intelligence across different agencies. The memo suggests that while RT-RG’s deployment at EPIC was not yet a top priority for NSA, if funding were secured, it could eventually serve as a model for further deployment across other regions.

CONFIDENTIAL//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL//20391123

SUBJECT: NSAT Trip Report
WHERE: El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC)
WHEN: 20 Feb 2008
WHO:
NSAW: COL Barbara Trent – RT-RG Program Office; Mr. Larry Foster – S33; [REDACTED] – S2F
NSAT: [REDACTED] – FTS3; [REDACTED] – FTS2; [REDACTED] – NSAT liaison at EPIC.
DEA HQ: Mr. Douglas Poole, DEA, Office of National Intell; Mr. [REDACTED], DEA, Liaison to NSAW/S2F; Mr. [REDACTED], DEA/SOD; Ms. [REDACTED], DEA OGC.
JIATF-S: Ms. Sandy Brooks – JIOC; Ms. Ila Sutton-DeAbreu – DEA Liaison to JIATF-S; Mr. Harry Petrey – JIATF-S
EPIC: Mr. Arty Doty, EPIC Chief (DEA); Mr. [REDACTED] EPIC D/Ch (CBP); various EPIC technicians and briefers;

PURPOSE: (U//FOUO) Discussion of deployment of RT-RG capabilities to EPIC. Senior officials from agencies with personnel at EPIC – DEA, DHS, CBP – have recently engaged with senior NSA officials regarding the possibility of deploying RT-RG capabilities to these agencies. Most of these discussions have focused on EPIC as the most logical place for the system given its real time tactical mission. While NSA SID has not included this deployment in its list of priorities for 2008, if these agencies provide funding, NSA will support the deployment of RT-RG capabilities to them. Discussions centered on issues regarding the deployment, various aspects of EPIC mission and the infrastructure and data flows at EPIC.

DISCUSSION/KEY POINTS:

  1. (U//FOUO) DEA is very enthusiastic about and anxious to move ahead smartly on the acquisition of an RT-RG capability located at EPIC. DEA identified four areas needing resolution in order to move forward. These areas were: Funding; Staffing; Polices and Authorities and a Timeline.
    a. (U//FOUO) Funding – DEA has requested ODNI to provide up to $10 Million for RT-RG and is very optimistic that the request will be approved. If not, however, the project will end unless other funding sources can be identified. As of the 20th, the request was still pending. DEA did express concern that other agencies possibly were seeking funding for this same project. DEA felt having “multiple threads” requesting funding for the same project possibly could be a showstopper for all. Sandy Brooks was of the opinion that the “funding will shake loose,” because the DNI, DIRNSA and Charlie Allen were all in accord in about the “value of sharing interagency data.” Ms. Brooks also indicated that funding was included in FY-09 and future POM cycle planning.
    b. (U//FOUO) Staffing - DEA has not as yet identified any resources to staff an RT-RG capability. Without clarification of policy and authorities questions, it is difficult for DEA to know what staffing will be required. Ms. Brooks made some recommendations

Derived From: NSA/CSSM 1-52
Dated: 20070108
Declassify On: 20391123

CONFIDENTIAL//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL//20391123

CONFIDENTIAL//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL//20391123

regarding the formation of an RT-RG team at EPIC and the kind of personnel who should
be part of this initiative.

c. (S) Policies and Authorities – DEA and EPIC agreed that there is great uncertainty as
to not only whether, but how the differing legal authorities can and will be addressed, and
a lack of understanding or clarity about if/how RT-RG can or will be able to bridge, or if
policies will allow such a bridge, between the different authorities, Title 21 vs. Title 50.
There were lots of questions and uncertainties, but no clarity about or answers to the
various questions that arose. There was general agreement that policies would need to be
put in place to allow the intelligence to be released at usable levels for the various
customers. EPIC's Art Doty commented that “real-time distribution and dissemination
authority was absolutely essential” and that anything classified above Law Enforcement
Sensitive would be unusable for the law enforcement customer set. COL Trent
commented that these same issues were being worked in the RT-RG deployments in Iraq
and Afghanistan and part of the solution is the representation of data at the level the
operator needs vice providing access to actual data streams.

d. (S) Timeline - DEA favored a timeline following funding approval of 90 days to have
RT-RG underway. However, RT-RG installation, practically speaking, will require
several levels of effort beginning with the basic challenges of assessing the
communications infrastructure and resolving or improving connectivity and bandwidth
requirements. Additionally, all acknowledged that current priorities for the RT-RG
program office are for the Afghanistan deployment and timeline for other deployments
would be based on progress made with that effort. The timeline was not delineated
further except to agree it would be a crawl-walk-run process at best.

  1. (U//FOUO) DEA indicated that the RT-RG capability in whatever form it exists at EPIC
    would have to respect and incorporate Special Operations Division's (SOD's) role as the
    coordination and deconfliction center for DEA law enforcement operations, meaning that
    SOD would have to be included in any new information flows that might result from the RT-
    RG deployment. DEA will take on the task of defining the operational concept for RTRG to
    ensure this is addressed. This does not apply to the DHS components at EPIC that would
    also be supported by RTRG.
  1. (C//REL) Linkage between the law enforcement and SIGINT worlds is the ultimate goal, but
    there are multiple policy issues to be addressed before that can be realized. According to Art
    Doty, analysts assigned to EPIC, from whatever Agency they originate, have access to
    myriad EPIC databases. Whether that same access can be granted to NSA integrees is one of
    these issues. As part of the crawl-walk-run strategy, all agreed that the initial RT-RG
    deployment would focus on EPIC data only and increasing their analytic capabilities with
    more efficient and effective use of current datasets. Concurrently, NSA will continue to
    develop and implement the Southern Defense Strategy that includes deployment of NSA
    civilians and contractors to EPIC to achieve increased intelligence sharing. NSA OGC has
    approved the initial phase of this effort in which NSAʼers will provide technical assistance to
    EPIC. While not tied exclusively to RT-RG, the intent is to use these personnel to support
    deployment of RTRG to EPIC.

CONFIDENTIAL//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL//20391123
2

CONFIDENTIAL//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL//20391123

  1. (U//FOUO) DEA asked exactly what the RT-RG funding was going to "buy them." The
    answer was that they would be getting "an appliance and comms upgrades between EPIC and
    NSAT. There was uncertainty about whether EPIC would need/get a full RT-RG capability
    resident on site or connectivity to a more robust capability at NSAT.
  1. (U//FOUO) The name for this project will be RT-RG EPIC. POCs for this project at the
    various agencies are as follows:

EPIC: Art Doty to identify as an ACTION item
DEA: Doug Poole and [REDACTED] for IT issues
NSAT/S2: [REDACTED]
NSAW/S2: [REDACTED]
NSAW/RTRG: COL Barb Trent, USA

CONCLUSION/RECOMMENDATIONS:

(U//FOUO) NSA will continue to work with DEA to resolve several of the issues raised. The
following actions were agreed on:

  • Coordinate an RT-RG demo at NSAW for various DEA HQ, DEA SOD, EPIC and
    NSAT analysts; NSAW/DEA – [REDACTED], NSAT – [REDACTED]
  • Investigate the status of NSA-net connectivity at EPIC; NSAT – [REDACTED],
    NSAW – [REDACTED]
    • UPDATE: Per [REDACTED] there have been at least two requests via REMEDY
      tickets to IT to activate connectivity, but no funding sponsor was identified
      therefore no action has been taken. There have been discussions with the NCR
      DHS and S2F on sponsoring this connectivity requirement. [REDACTED] has
      contacted NSAW and made the determination that any infrastructure that might
      have been in place is no longer active and therefore the process will need to begin
      with submission of the requirement via a REMEDY ticket from the NSA sponsor
      to NSA IT. NSAT personnel involved will discuss soonest and identify next steps
      for action, the primary being getting resolution on funding the connectivity.
  • Provide DEA & EPIC details of what needs to be purchased and how much funding
    required; NSAW RTRG – COL Trent;
  • Continue development of Southern Defense Strategy working with NSA OGC and
    Oversight & Compliance to address policy and legal issues regarding this initiative;
    NSAT – [REDACTED], NSAW – [REDACTED]

CONFIDENTIAL//REL TO USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL//20391123
3