Supporting HMG’s Climate Change Ambitions (… or, “A GCO’s tales from Cancun”)

Open PDF
Creating agency: GCHQ, SIS Government Communications Headquarters (UK), Secret Intelligence Service (UK)
Document date: 2011-02
Pages: 23
Genre: slides
Classification: -
Dissemination: -

This joint GCHQ/MI6 presentation from February 2011 documents the process of international climate change negotiations becoming a “serious intelligence priority” for the UK.

Long Description:
No extended description available.

GCHQ

SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE

COP16 méxico 2010

Supporting HMG's Climate Change Ambitions

(...or, "A GCO's tales from Cancun")

27 November – 10 December 2010

[REDACTED]


GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Background

  • International Treaty opened for signature in 1992 as the UNFCCC
  • Kyoto Protocol agreed in 1997
  • Defined first commitment period for certain 'developed' countries (2008-12)
    • It agreed GHG emissions reductions by % of 1990 levels
  • Second commitment period needed to include commitments for 'developing' countries (a 'KP2')
  • 192 countries now party to UNFCCC

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Why include Developing Countries?

In 2010......

Top 10 economies (by GDP):

  1. USA
  2. China
  3. Japan
  4. India
  5. Germany
  6. UK
  7. Russia
  8. France
  9. Brazil
  10. Italy

Top 10 CO2 emitters
(one unit = 1,000 tonnes)

USA
CHINA
RUSSIA
JAPAN
INDIA
GERMANY
UK
CANADA
ITALY
MEXICO

6,000,000
5,000,000
4,000,000
3,000,000
2,000,000
1,000,000
0


GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

The Players

  • UK – negotiates as part of EU and plays a leading role
  • Major developed countries e.g. USA and Canada
  • Major developing countries – BASIC (Brazil, South Africa, India, China)
  • COP hosts (Mexico)
  • Vulnerable countries – AOSIS, G77
  • Other influencers e.g. OPEC

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Opposing views and Sticking Points

  • Historic responsibility of developed countries
  • Emissions reductions seen as a way of slowing growth of emerging powers
  • Money and technology for developing nations for clean energy, adaptation and mitigation (the Green Fund or „Fast-Start“)
  • Monitoring, Reporting and Verification (MRV)
  • An agreement binding developed and developing countries

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

The road to Cancun

  • 2007 COP13, Bali: the first time that climate change became a serious intelligence priority – COP13 has to work!
  • Spring MEF meeting in Paris: our first GCO climate change deployment

Some lessons learned!

  • 2008 COP14, Poznan: not expected to be a significant gathering
  • 2009 COP15, Copenhagen or bust (it bust!)

"The Copenhagen Accord"

Our first COP climate change GCO deployment

...a success

  • 2010 COP16, low ambition, low expectation, but hugely important

The talks must get back on track


GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

What's the role for intelligence?

Political decisions often made in advance

  • What do governments want?
  • What will they sign up to?
  • What are the negotiating positions on broad or specific issues?
  • What are their red lines?
  • Views about other countries
  • Who is aligning with who?
  • Who is lobbying who?
  • Who are the spoilers?
  • Are delegates reporting back and getting fresh instructions?
  • What are they?

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Customers

  • No.10 and Cabinet Office
  • Department for Energy and Climate Change
  • FCO
    • Diplomats
    • SOSFCA's Special Representative
  • Department for International Development
  • Treasury
  • G20 representatives

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Now...where did I put my sombrero?

  • Why did we decide to send someone to Cancun?
    • Customers wanted us to be there
    • High likelihood of relevant, time-sensitive intelligence
    • First opportunity to show a new ministerial team what we can do
  • Preparations
    • Suitable cover within UK delegation
    • Logistics (kit, rooms, passes, delegate lists, etc)
    • Introductions with customers
    • Intelligence requirements
    • Coordination in HQ
      • With other teams and SIS
      • Methodology for delivery
      • Working patterns
      • Policy clearance

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Behind the scenes at COP16

cop16 méxico 2010



Oficinas de Delegaciones
Delegations Offices

Oficinas de Delegaciones
Delegations Offices

Sombrero

1244 - 1255 | 1243 - 1200
1144 - 1155 | 1143 - 1100
1044 - 1055 | 1043 - 1000

China

UNITED KINGDOM






GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Why was Cancun a success?

  • The talks didn't fail and...
  • Agreed that emissions should peak at 2°C
  • Anchored emissions reduction pledges from the Copenhagen Accord
  • Agreed a system of MRV
  • Green Fund established
  • Agreed to reduce emissions from deforestation
  • Set up mechanisms for developed countries to access low carbon technology

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

The future

  • Continue to support negotiations, but...
    • How are South Africa approaching COP17?
    • Who is backing Qatar and South Korea in their bids for COP18?
    • A KP2 is looking unlikely, but...
    • ...some kind of multi-stage, bolt on agreement is probably achievable
    • A low carbon economy through efficiency and new technology could help achieve climate change goals...good for the economy and probably trade

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

UK Customers

  • Department for Energy and Climate Change
    • International negotiations
    • Domestic and European policies (energy efficiency, achieving a low-carbon economy; meeting 2020 obligations)
  • Foreign and Commonwealth Office
    • International diplomacy
    • Secretary of State's Special Envoy
  • Ministry of Defence
    • Regional instability
    • Resource security (water, food, land)
  • Department for International Development
    • Overseas aid
    • Emergency relief
  • Her Majesty's Treasury
    • The Green Fund
  • Department for Business Innovation & Skills
    • Supporting UK inward/outward investment and international trade
    • Developing low carbon technologies
    • Protecting intellectual property

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

New challenges for intelligence

  • Policy questions

Fewer disputing science – climate change happening and almost certainly man-made, so...

  • Is low carbon ambition driving government and investor decisions in economies?
  • Is UNFCCC still important or is private capital shifting to low carbon because costs and scarcity of resource make sense?
  • Are governments making the link between extreme weather and high commodity prices?
  • Are governments planning for instability or mass migrations caused by water/food scarcity, lack of natural resources and land-use change?
  • Competing intelligence priorities

GCHQ
SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE
COP16 méxico 2010

Questions?

Sombrero Tequila