SIGINT Then and Now: Vietnam vs Iraq
Open PDFDocument date: 2009-03-02
Type: SIDtoday
Pages: 3
Genre: newsletter
Banner: DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
Classification: SECRET SI
Dissemination: REL
A former Army analysts compared the role of signals intelligence now versus during the Vietnam war.
-
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
Vietnam, Iraq
Tags:
vietnam war, direction finding, morse, metadata, mobile phones, find fix finish, Cryptologic Support Team, OPSEC, COMSEC, insurgents, counterterrorism, targeting
Identifier:
2009-03-02_SIDToday_-_SIGINT_Then_and_Now_Vietnam_vs_Iraq
PDF SHA-256:
ce6b8cd49c36c05568237fcd480dc6a047bad501e15171b22f2ee6fe41a7cf47
My notes
DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
SIDtoday
(U//FOUO) SIGINT Then and Now: Vietnam vs Iraq
FROM: [REDACTED]
Recent deployer to Iraq (who just retired from NSA)
Run Dates: 03/02/2009 , 03/03/2009
(U//FOUO) A former Army signals analyst compares his recent deployment in Iraq to his
experiences in the Vietnam War.
(S//SI//REL) As I sit here waiting for my screen to fill with metadata and wondering why it's
taking so long, I just laugh to myself at how things are so different now than when I participated
in another war (Vietnam, 1970). Back then I was an enlisted soldier serving with the Army
Security Agency under the Military Assistance Command Vietnam, assigned to the 8th Radio
Research Field Station located at Phu Bai, just outside the city of Hue. The mission is basically
the same -- ferret out the bad guys and target them -- but times have changed with respect to
the manner in which it is done.
The author in Vietnam
The author in Iraq
(U//FOUO) The author in Vietnam (left) and Iraq
(S//SI//REL) In those days the enemy mainly used high frequency manual Morse
communications, in which the radio frequency transmitter was easily (for the most part) located
using direction finding (DF) techniques. Of course, during this era the derived lines of bearing
were manually plotted and processed to determine the possible location of the transmitting
signal.
(S//SI//REL) As a DF Operator/Analyst and Morse qualified, I copied many a target and directed
DF assets from within country and around the Pacific Theater to determine their approximate
locations. Once the location was refined and the communications analyzed, strikes were usually
carried out against the targets by either land, air, or sea forces, or any combination thereof.
Afterwards, more often than not, the analyst would find that a sizeable enemy force had been
decimated to ineffectiveness. However, most units were replenished with reinforcements from
the north along the infamous Ho Chi Minh Trail.
(S//SI//REL) One of the methods adopted by the enemy was to place the radio operator away
from the main force while transmitting, lest the whole unit be targeted in one fell swoop. Other
basic OPSEC/COMSEC* principles were also employed. As a result of effective targeting and the
passage of time, a program was instituted called " chieu
hoi ," which allowed the Viet Cong or North Vietnamese to
surrender and be provided preferential treatment.
However, some of those invoking the words "chieu hoi"
only did so when their backs were against a wall after the
ambush that they had set was turned against them.
(S//SI//REL) As a volunteer today, serving in a civilian
capacity as a member of a Cryptologic Support Team in
Iraq,** I find that the enemy is no different in its doggedness to disrupt a country's goal in
attaining basic freedoms. In today's environment, the enemy is mainly using the mobile phone
to communicate, and targets at this stage of involvement are acquired -- mostly -- one at a
time.
(S//SI//REL)The phrase "find-fix-finish" has been the path to ferreting out the insurgents and
terrorists in today's war. Our technology has allowed us to exploit a mobile communication for
its content ("find") through a multitude of available databases, and pinpoint its location ("fix")
within a very small radius using locational information inherent to the mobile network and/or air
assets. Of course, today the majority of information is processed using computer algorithms,
enabling the analysis to be done in a more efficient and timely manner. As a result, only a
platoon-sized force (if that) is needed to action ("finish") the target.
(S//SI//REL) Once again, the magnitude of our successes has led to changes or counteractions
by those we desire to remove from the field. Periodically, communications collected from various
factions have been noted stressing basic OPSEC/COMSEC procedures to minimize the chance of
being targeted and captured. Nevertheless, there are still basic tendencies that may be
exploited, given enough time and diligence by the analyst, which will eventually lead to the
enemy's demise. Once again, success and time have evolved into reconciliation and amnesty
programs which may be effective against the Iraqi insurgents, but not likely against the al-
Qaeda elements.
(U//FOUO) As my thoughts are now being drawn back to the metadata streaming across the
computer monitor, it's time once again to focus on the present while remembering the past with
equal satisfaction.
(U) Notes:
* (U) OPSEC = operations security; COMSEC = communications security
** (S//REL) The CST is assigned to the [REDACTED]
Combat Team and working alongside the [REDACTED] Regiment Delta Troop
SIGINT Platoon.
(U//FOUO) Do you have any wartime SIGINT recollections of your own you'd like to share? Post
them on the SIDtoday Blog .
"(U//FOUO) SIDtoday articles may not be republished or reposted outside NSANet
without the consent of S0121 (DL sid_comms)."
DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
DERIVED FROM: NSA/CSSM 1-52, DATED 08 JAN 2007 DECLASSIFY ON: 20320108
Published in the Same Report
(10 of 24 documents)
-
Summary of GCHQ Info Wrt OC TSS1 Excerpt [pdf]
GCHQ Summary of RTRG (or RT-TG). The RTRG program provides real-time intelligence support for global operations, particularly in the context of the Global War on Terrorism, using tailored systems that integrate multiple data sources to enhance target identification and analysis. The success of RT-RG in support of Operation Iraqi Freedom led to an expansion of the programme to support operations in Korea and Afghanistan, with new applications for keyword-based selection and alerting on voice intercept being trialled.
“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
SSO News on MYSTIC SHELLTRUMPET for June 20, 2012 [pdf]
Internal NSA memo describing how SHELLTRUMPET, part of the MYSTIC program, works in conjunction with Real Time-Regional Gateway (RT-RG) and various Special Source Operations (SSO) programs to provide metadata access for RT-RG Texas. The system obfuscates source information and filters irrelevant metadata, enabling RT-RG Texas to efficiently process metadata from DANCINGOASIS and SPINNERET.
“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Excerpt of May 2008 NSA Afghanistan Dataflow Analysis [pdf]
The document outlines how the NSA’s Real Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) in Afghanistan progressively expanded from late 2007 through 2008 to ingest massive amounts of GSM, VHF, HF, and telephony metadata from dozens of locations across Afghanistan, supplemented by third-party “dirtbox” collection from allied nations such as the Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Germany, and Spain. It details the specific collection sites, data types, and timelines (SPIN 9, 10, 11, etc.), illustrating how partner contributions and multiple signals sources fed into the RT-RG system to enable real-time intelligence.
Programs: FOURCORNERS · FORTRESS · WARRIOR · ECHIDNA · CASSIEOPIA · KARUS · SOUNDER · SNICK · TEMPOWOLFE · CALYPSO · TATTERAN · AIRBORNE · LEAVEBEHIND · UDEAUS · NELEUS · CROSSHAIR · SSO · DRT · RIVET JOINT · VOICESAIL“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Afghanistan Coalition Dissemination Brief to Senior Leadership Forum [pdf]
This document ooutlines the structure, goals, and challenges of multinational signals intelligence (SIGINT) collaboration in Afghanistan as of 2009. It reveals how the U.S. and its intelligence-sharing allies (notably the 5 Eyes, 9 Eyes, and 14 Eyes) coordinated SIGINT collection, decryption, analysis, and dissemination across NATO and coalition forces.
“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Bagram – Area 82 [pdf]
This document is a classified June 2010 progress report on the construction of the NSA’s Real Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) data center at Area 82, Bagram Airfield, coordination with multiple U.S. and allied agencies, and the eventual deployment of the system after extensive infrastructure work. It emphasizes the transition from temporary container setups to a permanent facility enabling real-time signals intelligence in Afghanistan.
Marking: SECRET“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
NSA Area 82 Update April 2009 [pdf]
Programs: RT-RG“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
NSA BOUNDLESSINFORMANT Chart on Denmark [pdf]
The Denmark BOUNDLESSINFORMANT chart covering Dec 10, 2012 to Jan 8, 2013 shows that Danish intelligence collected and shared about 22.9 million cellphone metadata records with the NSA through DRTBOX systems. These records were gathered in Afghanistan as part of the Afghanistan SIGINT Coalition, not mass surveillance inside Denmark.
“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
NSA El Paso Intelligence Center Trip Report 2008 [pdf]
This internal NSA memo summarizes a meeting held on February 20, 2008, regarding the deployment of the Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) system at the El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC), a DEA-led facility. It details challenges in funding, staffing, legal policies, and coordination between DEA, DHS, and NSA, with the goal of enhancing intelligence sharing and operational capabilities for law enforcement, and using RT-RG on the U.S.-Mexico border.
People: Trent, Barbara · Trent, Barb · Foster, Larry · Poole, Douglas · Brooks, Sandy · Sutton-DeAbreu, Ila · Petrey, Harry · Allen, Charlie · Doty, Art“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Real-Time Regional Gateway Cloud Analytics for Forward Users [pdf]
This document outlines the NSA’s Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) program, a global cloud-based signals intelligence system designed to provide near real-time data analysis and targeting support for military and intelligence operations. It details the transition to scalable cloud architectures such as GHOSTMACHINE and Cloudbase, enabling massive data retention, exploitation, advanced geolocation, and automated analytics for tracking high-value targets across multiple theaters, including Afghanistan, Iraq, and the Horn of Africa.
Programs: RT-RG · GOLDMINER · GEOT · AGENTLOGIC · SHARKFINN · SKS · PANOPTICON · DRT · CIDNE · JUGGERNAUT · LOPERS · TALIS · MATTERHORN · AIRHANDLER · LYCANTHROPE · VOICESAIL · RETURNSPRING · SORTINGLEAD · GHOSTMACHINE · GMROYALE · GMREGAL · GMGEIST · GMIDEA · GMTOTE · GMPEN · GMPAC · GMCALM · GMMATE · GMAPPLE · GMCAVE · GMPEACH · GMDEN · GMMOUNT · GMALAMO · GMLIGHT · GMBALTIC · GMPLACE · GMPARK · GMHALO · GMCARBON · DRAGONFIRE · DOMEEXPOSE · GIANTSQUID · MAINWAY · FURIOUSCHAINSAW · SHARKFURY · NIAGARAFILES · SHARKQUERY · SHARKDOCS · OCTAVE · UTT · BEDDOWN · CHEEKYMONKEY · LAYERCAKE · CYBERTRANS · GMSEMINOLE · GMGULF · GMZILLA · HLT · JEMA · NEVIS · SEDB · CLOUDBASE · MAPREDUCE · CASPORT · WAVELEGAL“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) [pdf]
This document from GCHQ details the NSA's Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG), a system designed to provide tactical military users with near-instantaneous SIGINT (signals intelligence) support by integrating and analyzing data from multiple sources. It outlines the system’s applications, benefits, and challenges, particularly in enhancing the speed and efficiency of intelligence delivery to military operations in regions like Afghanistan, and highlights its impact on collaboration with GCHQ.
Programs: RT-RG · RT-10 · GOLDMINER · VOICESAIL · GEOT · SHARKFINN · CELLEX · SORTINGLEAD · GREMIO · IMMERGO · HERRICK · AIRHANDLER · TIPPERS · PASHTOVOICE · VIPERFOCUS · SKS · GEOFUSION · EVENTS“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin
See all 25 documents published with “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” →
Related Documents
-
Follow the 'Honey' SIDtoday [pdf]
An Iraqi target ”known to take his cell phone completely apart when he went home to prevent our tracking” is located and caught by tracking his wife's cell phone.
“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
RT10: Getting Information to the Front Lines in Time to Make a Difference SIDtoday [pdf]
RT10, a new and "very high-priority" processing system in Baghdad brings "real-time [signals intelligence] collection feeds and advanced analytical tools to front-line war-fighters." Because intercepted data is stored locally, as opposed to being sent back to the U.S., RT10 can store and process more data and provide targeting information more quickly.
Programs: RT10People: Heath, James E.“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Real-Time Regional Gateway Cloud Analytics for Forward Users [pdf]
This document outlines the NSA’s Real-Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) program, a global cloud-based signals intelligence system designed to provide near real-time data analysis and targeting support for military and intelligence operations. It details the transition to scalable cloud architectures such as GHOSTMACHINE and Cloudbase, enabling massive data retention, exploitation, advanced geolocation, and automated analytics for tracking high-value targets across multiple theaters, including Afghanistan, Iraq, and the Horn of Africa.
Programs: RT-RG · GOLDMINER · GEOT · AGENTLOGIC · SHARKFINN · SKS · PANOPTICON · DRT · CIDNE · JUGGERNAUT · LOPERS · TALIS · MATTERHORN · AIRHANDLER · LYCANTHROPE · VOICESAIL · RETURNSPRING · SORTINGLEAD · GHOSTMACHINE · GMROYALE · GMREGAL · GMGEIST · GMIDEA · GMTOTE · GMPEN · GMPAC · GMCALM · GMMATE · GMAPPLE · GMCAVE · GMPEACH · GMDEN · GMMOUNT · GMALAMO · GMLIGHT · GMBALTIC · GMPLACE · GMPARK · GMHALO · GMCARBON · DRAGONFIRE · DOMEEXPOSE · GIANTSQUID · MAINWAY · FURIOUSCHAINSAW · SHARKFURY · NIAGARAFILES · SHARKQUERY · SHARKDOCS · OCTAVE · UTT · BEDDOWN · CHEEKYMONKEY · LAYERCAKE · CYBERTRANS · GMSEMINOLE · GMGULF · GMZILLA · HLT · JEMA · NEVIS · SEDB · CLOUDBASE · MAPREDUCE · CASPORT · WAVELEGAL“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Excerpt of May 2008 NSA Afghanistan Dataflow Analysis [pdf]
The document outlines how the NSA’s Real Time Regional Gateway (RT-RG) in Afghanistan progressively expanded from late 2007 through 2008 to ingest massive amounts of GSM, VHF, HF, and telephony metadata from dozens of locations across Afghanistan, supplemented by third-party “dirtbox” collection from allied nations such as the Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Germany, and Spain. It details the specific collection sites, data types, and timelines (SPIN 9, 10, 11, etc.), illustrating how partner contributions and multiple signals sources fed into the RT-RG system to enable real-time intelligence.
Programs: FOURCORNERS · FORTRESS · WARRIOR · ECHIDNA · CASSIEOPIA · KARUS · SOUNDER · SNICK · TEMPOWOLFE · CALYPSO · TATTERAN · AIRBORNE · LEAVEBEHIND · UDEAUS · NELEUS · CROSSHAIR · SSO · DRT · RIVET JOINT · VOICESAIL“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin -
Hollywood Special Effects? No, It's Modern-Day SIGINT SIDtoday [pdf]
An NSA staffer flies to Baghdad to demonstrate the Real Time Regional Gateway system to awestruck representatives from FBI and other government agencies.
“Mission Creep: How the NSA’s Game-Changing Targeting System Built for Iraq and Afghanistan Ended Up on the Mexico Border” - The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · “Norges hemmelige krig i Afghanistan” - NRK ↗ (2019-05-29) · The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) · Moltke, Henrik · Skille, Øyvind Bye · Døvik, Olav · Hansen, Ståle Ellingsgard · Fjørtoft, Martin