German, NSA SIGINTers Share DNI Processing Knowledge
Open PDF +1 other copyDocument date: 2006-05-22
Type: SIDtoday
Pages: 1
Genre: newsletter
Banner: DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
Classification: SECRET SI
Dissemination: -
A delegation from Germany’s Federal Intelligence Service visits Fort Meade, Maryland, to learn about the NSA’s “packet level” selection and filtering of internet-based traffic, which is opposite to the approach used by the Germans.
GRANDMASTER, WEALTHYCLUSTER, TURMOIL, BLACKNIGHT
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
Germany
Tags:
DNI, Digital Network Intelligence, emails, packet filtering, privacy, liaison
Identifier:
2006-05-22_SIDToday_-_German_NSA_SIGINTers_Share_DNI_Processing_Knowledge
PDF SHA-256:
eb2a7f7a0a74ba2cb6f8d0b0b74315e225095910041b8965fdac5ff46358457b
My notes
DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
SIDtoday
(S//SI) German, NSA SIGINTers Share DNI Processing Knowledge
FROM: [REDACTED] and [REDACTED]
SUSLAG (Special US Liaison Activity Germany)
Run Date: 05/22/2006
(S//SI) A BND* delegation responsible for building BND's next generation DNI (Digital Network Intelligence)- processing architecture visited the Joint SIGINT Activity (JSA) in late February for two days of discussions to learn more about NSA's DNI architecture. The JSA, an operational element of the Special US Liaison Activity Germany (SUSLAG), is a joint SIGINT development, collection, and exploitation site manned by German and US personnel.
(S//SI) BND analysts discussed their processing architecture, which is largely based on NSA's old P25 and P26 GRANDMASTER prototypes. Their focus is primarily e-mail processing, specifically SMTP e-mail. Spam filters are used to manage large data volumes. Selected traffic is passed through an automated privacy protection system, ensuring that analysts cannot view German-protected traffic. On-site BND analysts then manually assess all selected traffic to determine potential intelligence value.
(S//SI) In conducting this evaluation, they do not prioritize the selected traffic by target or keyword. Instead they focus on e-mails carrying attachments with the goal to scan e-mails as quickly as possible to increase their throughput. E-mails that are determined to be of potential intelligence value are then forwarded to BND HQS for follow-on evaluation and reporting.
(S//SI) NSA intelligence analysts discussed NSA's SIGINT Development model, NSA's "Hunt versus Gather" philosophy, our multi-stage selection and filtering process, and the evolution of DNI processing systems from GRANDMASTER to WEALTHYCLUSTER and, in the future, TURMOIL. The BND appeared especially interested in the TURMOIL approach of scanning and making judgments at the packet level prior to any sessionizing.
(S//SI) In summary, NSA and BND use opposite selection and filtering approaches. Where NSA primarily relies on equipment for selection (e.g. BLACKNIGHT) and analyst minimization for privacy protection, the BND relies on analysts to manually scan traffic for selection, and then equipment to filter data for privacy protection. Full use of current NSA DNI processing systems and analysis methodologies at JSA will be key to influencing the BND to alter their strategic DNI processing approach.
*(U) Note: BND = Germany's Bundesnachrichtendienst (the Federal Intelligence Service)
(U) This article is reprinted from the Foreign Affairs Digest, April edition.
"(U//FOUO) SIDtoday articles may not be republished or reposted outside NSANet without the consent of S0121 (DL sid_comms)."
DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
DERIVED FROM: NSA/CSSM 1-52, DATED 08 JAN 2007 DECLASSIFY ON: 20320108
Published in the Same Report
(10 of 27 documents)
-
SID Around the World: The Rheinland SIDtoday [pdf]
An NSA couple worked at locations in Germany’s Rheinland and enjoyed local cuisine and European travel.
“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2016-05-16) -
European Security Center to Begin Operations SIDtoday [pdf]
SIGINT operations in support of U.S. Army Europe and European Command will start at a facility in Darmstadt, Germany, in April 2004.
Marking: SECRET“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2016-12-07) -
A Little Bad Aibling Nostalgia SIDtoday [pdf]
With the closing of Bad Aibling Station in Germany, some BA veterans post a list of nostalgic recollections from working there.
“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2016-12-07) -
Forward Production at NCEUR — Inside the Customers' Decision Space SIDtoday [pdf]
Beginning in 2003, a team of NSA counterterrorism analysts based at NSA/CSS Europe began a dedicated project to support counterterrorism efforts in North Africa. The team collected signals intelligence, which they distributed to U.S. European Command and U.S. ambassadors, who then transmitted this information to governments in Mali, Algeria, and Mauritania. They believe this effort was "responsible for the capture or kill of over 40 terrorists."
“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2017-09-13) -
On the Road Again: SID Team Visits Germany SIDtoday [pdf]
A Signals Intelligence Directorate team visits NSA sites in Germany.
Marking: CONFIDENTIAL“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2018-08-15) -
European Technical Center Area Checked for Unexploded WWII Ordnance SIDtoday [pdf]
The European Technical Center area in Mainz, Germany, was closed for a day while investigators checked what seemed to be — but wasn’t — unexploded Word War II ordnance.
“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2018-08-15) -
The European Security Center to Become the 'ESOC' SIDtoday [pdf]
The European Security Center in Darmstadt, Germany will expand to become the European Security Operations Center; additional civilian NSA staff will join existing Army staff. The ESOC's primary responsibilities will be targets in Africa.
“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) -
NSAers Make First-Ever Visit to FORNSAT Collection Site in Schöningen, Germany SIDtoday [pdf]
The BND (German Federal Intelligence Service) has a base at Schoningen, where they collect different types of mobile communications (satellite, fax, and GSM), many of which they share with their NSA counterparts. NSA visited to compare notes, and requested copies of some of the Germans' software tools--which had "features that surpass US SIGINT capabilities--for call chaining and metadata analysis.
“The NSA in Germany: Snowden's Documents Available for Download” - Der Spiegel ↗ (2014-06-18) · The Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) -
BOUNDLESSINFORMANT Overview [pdf]
World map view from the Boundless Informant program, with "CNE" (Computer Network Exploitation) selected from the dropdown.
Programs: BOUNDLESSINFORMANT -
Internal NSA presentation on the BND's organization [pdf]
These six organizational charts and briefing slides detail the structure of Germany's BND foreign intelligence service, specifically its SIGINT Directorate (Abteilung Technische Aufklärung) and new Cyber Intelligence division (T4), along with a cooperation model showing intelligence sharing between BND, domestic intelligence service BfV, and the Federal Office for Information Security (BSI).
Related Documents
-
SSO dictionary relevant entries [pdf]
This document provides a detailed list of relevant entries related to NSA's Special Source Operations (SSO), highlighting various NSA surveillance and data collection systems used to monitor global communications. It includes descriptions of programs such as BIGBIRD and DISHFIRE, which focus on cable and SMS interception, as well as tools like LOPERS and COURIERSKILL for processing telephony metadata and refining target selection. The entries emphasize the extensive and automated nature of the NSA's intelligence-gathering operations, particularly in relation to undersea cables and telecommunication networks, and underscore the secretive and expansive scope of SSO's global surveillance activities.
Programs: ARTIFICE · BIGBIRD · FAIRVIEW · SSO · POORWILL · PINECONE · BLACKBELT · CADENCE · BLACKNIGHT · SHIPMASTER · COURIERSKILL · THEORYMASTER · WEALTHYCLUSTER · CLIFFSIDE · DISHFIRE · MARINA · MAINWAY · NUCLEON · PINWALE · FASCIA · BANYAN · LAMPSHADE · ASSOCIATION · HOMEBASE · SEDB · FRIAR · KEYCARD · TURMOIL · TURBULENCE · UTT · IRISHBEAUTY · OCTAVE · KOZYKOVE · LITHIUM · BLARNEY · LOPERS · MAILORDER · LUMBERYARD · MERLIN · NODDY · SAGUARO · NUTHATCH · CONTRAOCTAVE · XKEYSCORE · PLANK · RODEOSTAR · SAGURA · SERENADE · STARGATE · SILVERCOLLAM · SEALION · SEAGULL · SLIVER · SORA-2 · TITANPOINTE · TUBE · VPCS · STONEGATE“NSA Spying Relies on AT&T’s ‘Extreme Willingness to Help’” - ProPublica ↗ (2015-08-15) · “AT&T Helped U.S. Spy on Internet on a Vast Scale” - The New York Times ↗ (2015-08-15) · “The Wiretap Rooms: The NSA’s Hidden Spy Hubs in Eight U.S. Cities” - The Intercept ↗ (2018-06-25) · Angwin, Julia · Larson, Jeff · Savage, Charlie · Moltke, Henrik · Poitras, Laura · Risen, James · Gallagher, Ryan -
SKIDROWE [pdf]
This document reveals the extensive surveillance capabilities of the NSA's SKIDROWE program at TITANPOINTE, specifically designed to intercept and analyze satellite communications and internet data. It highlights how intercepted data is processed and filtered through advanced systems like XKEYSCORE, which enables real-time intelligence gathering by sifting through massive amounts of digital content, including emails, calls, and internet activity.
Programs: SKIDROWE · WEALTHYCLUSTER2 · WEALTHYCLUSTER · TURNWEALTHY · VPCS · XKEYSCORE · GENESIS · CONTROLAND · ATM · FITBOY · DARKTHUNDER · FIP · METTLESOME · SKYFRAME · PVOICE · XXPY0012 · AGITATOR · STARPROC · SPELLBINDER · BLACKPEARL · BLACKALCHEMY · BLACKGOLD · BLACKFIRE · MONKEYMIND · BCD · EVVIPER · QUANTUM · MISTYPEAK · VALIANTSURF · GALLANTWAVE · SWINE · BLUESNORT · TOSSSWUNG · GNOMEVISION · GNOMEGOGGLES · HIDDENSALAMANDER · TURMOIL · PSC -
WINDSTOP - Last 30 Days [pdf]
The WINDSTOP report shows massive NSA collection activity over a 30-day period, with daily DNI (Digital Network Intelligence) and DNR (Dialed Number Recognition) records reaching up to 600 million per day. Most data volume came from DS-300 and DS-200B collection points, processed primarily through XKEYSCORE and TURMOIL, and included a mix of signal types such as PCS, INMAR, MCIP, VSAT, and PSTN. The chart follows the same structure as BOUNDLESSINFORMANT, the NSA’s global SIGINT visualization tool, using bar and pie charts to track and categorize collection volume by signal type, SIGAD, and processing system.
-
XKEYSCORE intro [pdf]
A TOP SECRET NSA presentation from 2008 introducing XKeyscore — one of the earliest overview documents in the archive — describing the system as a globally distributed Linux cluster across approximately 150 sites and 700+ servers that stores a ~3-day rolling buffer of all unfiltered internet traffic, and demonstrating its core capabilities for finding previously unknown targets by mining metadata, tracking documents by embedded image hashes, detecting encryption and VPN use, and language tracking.
Programs: XKEYSCORE · TURMOIL · TURBULENCE · TRAFFICTHIEF · WEALTHYCLUSTER · MOONSHINE · SEARCHLIGHT · MARINA · PSC · SSO · TIMBERLINEPeople: bin Laden, Osama“'Brasil é um grande alvo', diz jornalista sobre vigilância dos EUA” - O Globo ↗ (2013-07-07) · “XKeyscore: NSA tool collects 'nearly everything a user does on the internet'” - The Guardian ↗ (2013-07-31) · “No Place to Hide” - Metropolitan Books ↗ (2014-05-13) · “XKEYSCORE: NSA’s Google for the World’s Private Communications” - The Intercept ↗ (2015-07-01) · Greenwald, Glenn · Bridi, Sônia · Marquis-Boire, Morgan · Lee, Micah -
FAIRVIEW dataflow charts April 2012 [pdf]
This document outlines data flow diagrams that show how various types of sensitive communication, including voice, fax, and modem traffic, are handled through systems operated by the NSA and its partners. These partners include corporations, telecommunications companies, ISPs, and other entities involved in processing and managing the data through secure and classified channels. The document covers processing flows for various data types, metadata, and communications systems under NSA's control, detailing how data is routed, stored, and analyzed across different platforms and sites.
Programs: FAIRVIEW · SAGUARO · TURNSTILE · MESA · TITANPOINT · RIMROCK · MAILORDER · PINECONE · BLARNEY · STONEGATE · TINSEL · CONVEYANCE · FISHWAY · NUCLEON · PINWALE · SCISSORS · COURIERSKILL · DRIFTWOOD · ASDF · FALLOUT · MARINA · LOPERS · WEALTHYCLUSTER · PUPR · CLEARSIGHT · MIDFIELD · CADENCE · BUGCATCHER · WAYLAND · DESOTO · GATEKEEP · HIGHDECIBEL · XKEYSCORE · YANKEE · TOPROCK · FASCIA · DISHFIRE · SEAGULL · BIGDIPPER · CORPORATE · LILDIPPER · HAVASU · WEALTHYCLUSTER2 · RAGTIME · TUMULT · TATTOO · DARKTHUNDER · ICYTWINS · TML-STATUS · WATERFRONT · VULCANDEATHGRIP · STEELFLAUTA · UNITY · KEYCARD · UTT · BTUBE · ISLANDTRANSPORT · SSO · MAINWAY · SSDM · TUBE · TITANPOINTE · TURMOIL · VPCS“NSA Spying Relies on AT&T’s ‘Extreme Willingness to Help’” - ProPublica ↗ (2015-08-15) · “AT&T Helped U.S. Spy on Internet on a Vast Scale” - The New York Times ↗ (2015-08-15) · “Titanpointe: The NSA’s Spy Hub in New York, Hidden in Plain Sight” - The Intercept ↗ (2016-11-16) · Angwin, Julia · Larson, Jeff · Savage, Charlie · Moltke, Henrik · Poitras, Laura · Risen, James · Gallagher, Ryan