Article
How London's 7/7 Bombings Led to "Unprecedented" Surveillance Tactics
Documents published with this article 5
-
The Alice Springs Resolution [pdf]
In June 2004, the intelligence chiefs of the Five Eyes nations signed the Alice Springs Resolution, establishing plans for a unified system that allowed single-query access to all member states’ metadata repositories.
-
Contact chaining [pdf]
A secret GCHQ Applied Research presentation describing how the agency's analysts use automated tools to map out a surveillance target's social network — starting with a known email address or phone number, then scoring and ranking every person that target communicates with to identify the most "suspicious" or strongly connected contacts, using twelve different relationship types including direct calls, shared locations, timing patterns, equipment sharing and calling profile similarity.
Programs: CARPAT · PRIME TIME · SNAPDRAGON · MoaG · SORTING FRIENDS · CHART BREAKER · MAMBA · CONTACTLENS · FLEXIMART · PSOUP · IMMINGLE -
Graph theory in the operational environment – GCHQ [pdf]
This document details GCHQ’s research on identifying “closed loops” of communication, where targets use a small set of phones to communicate exclusively among themselves, often with cheap, disposable handsets like the Nokia 1100. It explains the methodology for analyzing anonymized metadata, constructing contact graphs, and extracting non-giant, non-tree components to discover operationally relevant closed loops for intelligence and counterterrorism purposes.
Programs: VOICESAILPeople: Rumsfeld, Donald -
Sensitive Metadata Analytic Collaboration (SMAC) - Concept of Operations, October 2006 [pdf]
This document outlines the Sensitive Metadata Analytic Collaboration (SMAC) initiative, a system developed by the Five Eyes intelligence agencies to facilitate the sharing and analysis of sensitive metadata to support SIGINT (signals intelligence) missions. While the concept aims to improve collaboration and data sharing, its success is hindered by ongoing policy, legal, and technical barriers, as well as concerns about trust and participation among the agencies involved. The document suggests a complex, somewhat opaque process of metadata sharing that risks undermining privacy protections.
Programs: SMAC -
Transnational DNI training [pdf]
This document outlines a transnational training session on sensitive information sharing and collaboration among the "Five Eyes" intelligence partners (USA, AUS, CAN, GBR, NZL), focusing on key concepts such as "Need to Know" vs. "Need to Share" and operational frameworks for sharing SIGINT data, including the establishment of initiatives like SMAC, TICKETWINDOW, and the Alice Springs Resolution. It emphasizes the challenges of balancing security with collaboration, highlighting sensitivities related to partner identities, agreements, and interception points. Also see: PINWALE-Slides