Article
Western Spy Agencies Secretly Rely on Hackers for Intel and Expertise
Documents published with this article 4
-
NATO Civilian Intelligence Council – Cyber Panel – US Talking Points [pdf]
This 2011 US intelligence assessment for NATO identifies cyber espionage as the principal threat to Alliance networks, ranking Russia and China as the most significant nation-state actors and advocating for a shift to a consequence-based defense model that prioritizes the protection of NATO's most critical data.
-
LOVELY HORSE – GCHQ Wiki Overview [pdf]
This February 2012 GCWiki page describes LOVELY HORSE, a GCHQ initiative to collect, index, and distribute open-source intelligence from cybersecurity blogs and Twitter accounts to analysts on classified networks, utilizing JTRIG's BIRDSTRIKE architecture to scrape content from approximately 60 sources including security researchers, hacktivist groups like Anonymous and LulzSec, and cybersecurity companies, with legal approval from MP-LEG (Mission Policy-Legal).
Programs: LOVELYHORSE · HAPPYTRIGGER · BIRDSEED · JTRIG · BIRDSTRIKE · MERAPEAK · LEXHOUND · JEDI · DISCOVER -
HAPPY TRIGGER/LOVELY HORSE/Zool/TWO FACE – Open Source for Cyber Defence/Progress [pdf]
A TOP SECRET STRAP1 COMINT GCWiki page cataloguing GCHQ's open source intelligence gathering for cyber defence, listing approved and pending data sources fed into internal databases HAPPY TRIGGER, LOVELY HORSE, ZooL and TWO FACE, covering malware tracking, vulnerability intelligence, infrastructure mapping and domain monitoring.
Programs: HAPPYTRIGGER · LOVELYHORSE · TWOFACE · ZOOL · XKEYSCORE · POSITIVEPONY · NETPLATE · HIDDENSPOTLIGHT · SNORT · FOXTRAIL · REFRIEDCHICKEN · GEOFUSION · GLOBALSURGE · SHORTFALL · JTRIG · BIRDSEED · BIRDSTRIKE · MARBLEPOLLSPeople: Stewart, Joe -
INTOLERANT – Who Else Is Targeting Your Target? Collecting Data Stolen by Hackers – SIDtoday SIDtoday [pdf]
A TOP SECRET SIDToday article from Menwith Hill Station describing how NSA and CSEC discovered and began exploiting INTOLERANT — a sophisticated email-stealing hacking operation targeting Indian diplomats, Central Asian diplomats, Chinese human rights defenders, Tibetan pro-democracy activists, Uighur activists and European officials — by intercepting the stolen emails as they transited satellite links, a technique internally called "fourth party collection" or "outsourcing SIGINT."
Programs: INTOLERANT