Center for National Security Studies Letter, September 25, 2013
Open PDFDocument date: 2013-09-26
Type: FOIA
Pages: 2
Classification: -
Dissemination: -
FISC/FISCR Court Filings
My notes
Center for National Security Studies
U.S. FOREIGN
protecting civil liberties and human rights INTELLIGENCE
SURVEILLANCE COURT
2013 SEP 26 PM 4:56
LEEANN FLYNN HALL
CLERK OF COURT
September 25, 2013
The Honorable Reggie B. Walton
Presiding Judge
United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court
Washington, D.C. 20001
Dear Judge Walton,
Owing to the considerable importance of legal issues concerning bulk telephone metadata
collection under section 501 of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance, we are writing concerning
the procedures the Court may use to ensure plenary consideration on a public record of these
issues in the event that the Government seeks reauthorization of that collection.
First, we request that the Court direct the Government, if it seeks reauthorization, to file
on the public record an application and supporting brief that sets forth its argument on the
legality of bulk telephony metadata collection. While the Government may have supplemental
classified information that is submitted to the Court under seal, it is important that there be a
public record that describes the full legal basis for the Government's application.
We note that the Court has now published an opinion on telephony metadata collection
under section 501 (per Judge Eagan). That decision, like earlier decisions of the Court, was
reached after ex parte proceedings. Moreover, the Court notes (opinion fn. 4) that it explicitly
did not consider the Administration White Paper on Bulk Collection of Telephony Metadata
Under Section 215 of the USA PATRIOT Act (August 9, 2013) which was released after the
Court's ex parte hearing with the Government. It is therefore important that in the briefing now
being proposed the Government go first so that it is clear what legal analysis it is now relying
on.
Second, we request that the Court establish a briefing schedule that enables interested
persons or organizations to submit briefs amicus curiae responding to the Government's
submission. This would be in accord with procedures utilized by the Court of Review in In re
Sealed Case, 310 F.3d 717 (Foreign Intel. Surv. Ct. Rev. 2002) and in In re: Directives Pursuant
to Section 105B of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act, 551 F.3d 1004 (Foreign Intel. Surv.
Ct. Rev. 2008). My organization, the Center for National Security Studies, participated as
amicus curiae in the 2002 In re Sealed Case, and filed a Legal Memorandum In re Warrantless
Electronic Surveillance before the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court in 2006.
1730 Pennsylvania Ave NW, 7th Floor, Washington, D.C. 2006
tel: (202) 721-5650 fax: (202) 530-0128 kmartin@cnss.org
Third, we believe that pursuant to section 103(a)(2), 50 USC 1803(a)(2) of the Foreign
Intelligence Surveillance Act and implementing rules of this Court, this is an appropriate matter
for the Court to consider en banc. Under the Act and the rules, a majority of the judges of the
Court may order en banc consideration when "the proceeding involves a question of exceptional
importance." Any request by the Government to reauthorize bulk collection of telephony
metadata would meet that standard.
We believe that the Court's favorable action in response to these requests will promote
the public interest in assuring that there is plenary consideration of the significant legal issues in
this matter and help fulfill the Government's commitment to greater transparency on these
issues.
We are sending copies of this letter to John P. Carlin, Acting Assistant Attorney General
for National Security, and Robert S. Litt, General Counsel, Office of Director of National
Intelligence. We hope that they will join in these requests.
We are submitting these requests by letter. If a formal motion is required, we ask you to
treat this letter as a motion or advise us that it should be refiled as such.
Thank you for your consideration of this matter.
Sincerely,
Kate Martin
cc:
John P. Carlin
Acting Assistant Attorney General for National Security
U.S. Department of Justice
950 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20530
Robert S. Litt
General Counsel
Office of the Director of National Intelligence
1500 Tysons McLean Dr.
McLean, Virginia 22102
2