DNI Clapper 2013 Jewel Shubert SSP Unclassified Signed Declaration
Open PDFDocument date: 2013-12-20
Type: FOIA
Pages: 22
Classification: -
Dissemination: -
Public declaration of James R. Clapper disclosing information regarding the government. ACLU/EFF FOIA Litigation.
My notes
STUART F. DELERY
Acting Assistant Attorney General
JOSEPH H. HUNT
Director, Federal Programs Branch
ANTHONY J. COPPOLINO
Deputy Branch Director
JAMES J. GILLIGAN
Special Litigation Counsel
MARCIA BERMAN
Senior Trial Counsel
BRYAN DEARINGER
RODNEY PATTON
Trial Attorneys
U.S. Department of Justice
Civil Division, Federal Programs Branch
20 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20001
Phone: (202) 514-4782
Fax: (202) 616-8460
Attorneys for the Government Defendants
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
SAN FRANCISCO DIVISION
CAROLYN JEWEL, et al.,
)
) No. 08-cv-4373-JSW
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
NATIONAL SECURITY AGENCY, et al.,
)
)
Defendants.
)
)
VIRGINIA SHUBERT, et al.,
) No. 07-cv-693-JSW
)
Plaintiffs,
) PUBLIC DECLARATION OF
) JAMES R. CLAPPER, DIRECTOR
v.
) OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE
)
BARACK OBAMA, et al.,
) No Hearing Scheduled
) Courtroom 11, 19th Floor
Defendants.
) Judge Jeffrey S. White
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
1
I, James R. Clapper, do hereby state and declare as follows:
INTRODUCTION
- I am the Director of National Intelligence (DNI) of the United States. I have held
this position since August 9, 2010. In my capacity as the DNI, I oversee the U.S. Intelligence
Community (IC) and serve as the principal intelligence adviser to the President. Prior to serving
as the DNI, I served as the Director of the Defense Intelligence Agency from 1992 to 1995, the
Director of the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency from 2001 to 2006, and the Under
Secretary of Defense for Intelligence from 2007 to 2010, where I served as the principal staff
assistant and advisor to the Secretary and Deputy Secretary of Defense on intelligence,
counterintelligence, and security matters for the Department of Defense. In my capacity as the
Under Secretary of Defense for Intelligence, I simultaneously served as the Director of Defense
Intelligence for the Office of the Director of National Intelligence (ODNI).
- The purpose of this declaration is to formally assert, in my capacity as the DNI
and head of the IC, the state secrets privilege and a statutory privilege under the National
Security Act of 1947, as amended, see 50 U.S.C. § 3024(i)(1), in order to protect intelligence
sources and methods that are at risk of disclosure in the above-captioned cases. This assertion of
privilege updates and modifies my prior assertions of privilege in this litigation. As discussed
below, I am no longer asserting privilege over the existence of various presidentially authorized
National Security Agency (NSA) intelligence activities, later transitioned to authority under the
Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA). I continue to assert privilege over still-classified
information concerning the scope and operational details of these intelligence activities,
including but not limited to information that would tend to confirm or deny that particular
persons were targets of or subject to NSA intelligence activities or that particular
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
2
telecommunications service providers assisted NSA in conducting intelligence activities.
Disclosure of this still-classified information regarding the scope and operational details of NSA
intelligence activities implicated by plaintiffs' allegations could be expected to cause extremely
grave damage to the national security of the United States.
- The statements made herein are based on my personal knowledge as well as on
information provided to me in my official capacity as the DNI. I am also submitting a classified
declaration, solely for the Court's in camera, ex parte review, which further sets forth the basis
for my privilege assertion. See Classified In Camera, Ex Parte Declaration of James R. Clapper,
Director of National Intelligence (Dec. 20, 2013).
SUMMARY
- In the course of my official duties, I have been advised of this lawsuit and the
allegations at issue in the plaintiffs' complaints in the Jewel and Shubert actions. In personally
considering this matter, I have executed a separate classified declaration dated December 19, - Moreover, I have read and personally considered the information contained in the Public
and the In Camera, Ex Parte Declaration of Frances J. Fleisch, National Security Agency (NSA),
executed on December 20, 2013 (hereafter "Classified NSA Declaration"). Disclosure of the
information covered by my and NSA's privilege assertions reasonably could be expected to
cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security of the United States and, therefore, the
information should be excluded from any use in this case.
- I reach this conclusion, and make these assertions of privilege, mindful of the
public disclosures of information about classified NSA intelligence programs, both authorized
and unauthorized, that have taken place since June 2013. The wave of unauthorized public
disclosures of classified information regarding NSA intelligence activities that began in June
2013 has been extremely damaging to the national security of the United States, threatening the
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
3
ability of the IC to conduct operations effectively and keep our country safe. At the same time,
these disclosures have generated great public interest in how the NSA uses its special tools and
authorities to gather intelligence, and whether they have been used appropriately. At the
President's direction, I have therefore declassified and publicly released numerous documents
disclosing the existence of, and a number of details about, the NSA's collection of bulk
telephony and Internet metadata under sections 402 and 501 of FISA, and the content of
communications of non-U.S. persons located abroad under FISA section 702. I did this to
facilitate informed public debate about the value and appropriateness of these programs with full
understanding of what they allow, the oversight mechanisms in place, and the contribution these
programs have made to the Nation's security and safety. These documents were properly
classified and the decision to declassify and release them was not taken lightly. But I concluded,
in consultation with elements of the IC, that in light of the unauthorized disclosures, the public
interest in the documents outweighed the potential for additional damage to national security.
- On December 20, 2013, under authority of the President, the existence of
collection activities authorized by President George W. Bush in October 2001 was also
declassified. Specifically, starting on October 4, 2001, President Bush authorized the Secretary
of Defense to employ the capabilities of the Department of Defense, including the NSA, to
collect foreign intelligence by electronic surveillance in order to detect and prevent acts of
terrorism within the United States. President Bush authorized the NSA to collect (1) the contents
of certain international communications, a program that was later referred to and publicly
acknowledged by President Bush as the Terrorist Surveillance Program (TSP), and (2) telephony
and Internet non-content information (referred to as "metadata") in bulk, subject to various
conditions.
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
4
- President Bush issued authorizations approximately every 30-60 days. Although
the precise terms changed over time, each presidential authorization required the minimization of
information collected concerning American citizens to the extent consistent with the effective
accomplishment of the mission of detection and prevention of acts of terrorism within the United
States. The NSA also applied additional internal constraints on the presidentially authorized
activities.
- Over time, the presidentially authorized activities transitioned to the authority of
the FISA. The collection of communications content pursuant to presidential authorization
ended in January 2007 when the U.S. Government transitioned TSP to the authority of FISA
under orders of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC). In August 2007, Congress
enacted the Protect America Act (PAA) as a temporary measure. The PAA expired in February
2008 and was replaced by the FISA Amendments Act of 2008, which was enacted in 2008 and
remains in effect today. Today, content collection is conducted pursuant to section 702 of FISA.
The metadata activities also were transitioned to orders of the FISC. The bulk collection of
telephony metadata transitioned to the authority of FISA in May 2006 and is collected pursuant
to section 501 of FISA. The bulk collection of Internet metadata was transitioned to the
authority of FISA in July 2004 and was collected pursuant to section 402 of FISA. In December
2011, the U.S. Government decided not to seek re-authorization of the bulk collection of Internet
metadata under section 402.
- As a result of the declassification of the information described above, the U.S.
Government is no longer asserting privilege over the existence of these programs, whether
conducted under presidential authority or FISC authorization. It has remained necessary,
however, to withhold certain information about these programs, even from the publicly released
documents, to protect sensitive sources and methods, such as particular targets and subjects of
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
5
surveillance, and methods of collecting and analyzing intelligence information, because public
disclosure of this information would likely cause even graver damage to national security than
has already been done by the unauthorized disclosures that have occurred since June 2013. As
explained in great detail in my classified, in camera, ex parte declaration, and in the Classified
NSA Declaration, the same is true with respect to the highly sensitive and still-classified
information that is implicated by the plaintiffs' allegations in this litigation. For example,
litigating plaintiffs' claims would likely risk or require the disclosure of information that would
tend to confirm or deny whether particular telecommunications carriers have assisted with the
NSA activities at issue. Therefore, notwithstanding the unauthorized disclosures and the official
declassification and release of information about NSA intelligence programs that have taken
place since June of this year, it is my judgment that disclosure of the classified, privileged
national security information described herein, and in greater detail in my classified in camera,
ex parte declaration, and the Classified NSA Declaration, will risk further and exceptionally
grave damage to the national security of the United States.
- Accordingly, as set forth further below, I am asserting the state secrets privilege
and the DNI's authority to protect intelligence sources and methods pursuant to 50 U.S.C. §
3024(i)(1) to protect against the disclosure of highly classified and important intelligence
information, sources and methods put at issue in this case, many of which are vital to the national
security of the United States, including: (a) information concerning the specific nature of the
terrorist threat posed by al-Qa'ida and its affiliates and other foreign terrorist organizations to the
United States; (b) information that would tend to confirm or deny whether particular individuals,
including the named plaintiffs, have been subject to any NSA intelligence activities, (c)
information concerning the scope or operational details of NSA intelligence activities that may
relate to or be necessary to adjudicate plaintiffs' allegations, including plaintiffs' claims that the
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
6
NSA indiscriminately intercepts the content of communications, and their claims regarding the
NSA's bulk collection of telephony and Internet communications records ("metadata"); and
(d) information that may tend to confirm or deny whether AT&T or Verizon (and to the extent
relevant or necessary, any other telecommunications carrier) has provided assistance to the NSA
in connection with any intelligence activity.
- I specifically concur with the NSA that public speculation about alleged NSA
activities above and beyond what has been officially disclosed does not diminish the need to
protect intelligence sources and methods from further exposure, and that official confirmation
and disclosure of the classified, privileged national security information described herein, in my
classified in camera, ex parte declaration, and in the Classified NSA Declaration, can be
expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security. For these reasons, as set
forth further below, I request that the Court uphold the state secrets and statutory privilege
assertions that I make herein, as well as the statutory privilege assertion made by the NSA
pursuant to Section 6 of the National Security Agency Act, see 50 U.S.C. § 3605 (note), and
protect the information described in this declaration from disclosure.
BACKGROUND ON DIRECTOR OF NATIONAL INTELLIGENCE
- The position of DNI was created by Congress in the Intelligence Reform and
Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004, Pub. L. 108-458, §§ 1011(a) and 1097, 118 Stat. 3638, 3643-
63, 3698-99 (2004) (amending sections 102 through 104 of Title I of the National Security Act
of 1947). Subject to the authority, direction, and control of the President, the DNI serves as the
head of the IC and as the principal adviser to the President, the National Security Council, and
the Homeland Security Council for intelligence matters related to the national security. See 50
U.S.C. § 3023(b)(1), (2).
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
7
- The IC includes the ODNI; the Central Intelligence Agency; the NSA; the
Defense Intelligence Agency; the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency; the National
Reconnaissance Office; other offices within the Department of Defense for the collection of
specialized national intelligence through reconnaissance programs; the intelligence elements of
the military services, the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the Department of the Treasury, the
Department of Energy, the Drug Enforcement Administration, and the Coast Guard; the Bureau
of Intelligence and Research of the Department of State; the elements of the Department of
Homeland Security concerned with the analysis of intelligence information; and such other
elements of any other department or agency as may be designated by the President, or jointly
designated by the DNI and heads of the department or agency concerned, as an element of the
IC. See 50 U.S.C. § 3003(4).
- The responsibilities and authorities of the DNI are set forth in the National
Security Act of 1947, as amended. See 50 U.S.C. § 3024. These responsibilities include
ensuring that national intelligence is provided to the President, the heads of the departments and
agencies of the Executive Branch, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and senior military
commanders, and the Senate and House of Representatives and committees thereof. See 50
U.S.C. § 3024(a)(1). The DNI is also charged with establishing the objectives of, determining
the requirements and priorities for, and managing and directing the tasking, collection, analysis,
production, and dissemination of national intelligence by elements of the IC. Id. §
3024(f)(1)(A)(i) and (ii).
- In addition, the National Security Act of 1947, as amended, provides that "[t]he
Director of National Intelligence shall protect intelligence sources and methods from
unauthorized disclosure." 50 U.S.C. § 3024(i)(1). Consistent with this responsibility, the DNI
establishes and implements guidelines for the IC for the classification of information under
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
8
applicable law, Executive orders, or other Presidential directives, and access to and
dissemination of intelligence. Id. § 3024(i)(2)(A), (B). In particular, the DNI is responsible for
the establishment of uniform standards and procedures for the grant of access to Sensitive
Compartmented Information (SCI) to any officer or employee of any agency or department of
the United States, and for ensuring the consistent implementation of those standards throughout
such departments and agencies. Id. § 3024(j)(1), (2).
- By virtue of my position as the DNI, and unless otherwise directed by the
President, I have access to all intelligence related to the national security that is collected by any
department, agency, or other entity of the United States. See 50 U.S.C. § 3024(b); section 1.3(a)
of E.O. 12333, as amended. Pursuant to E.O. 13526, the President has authorized me to exercise
original TOP SECRET classification authority.
ASSERTION OF STATE SECRETS PRIVILEGE
- After careful and actual personal consideration of the matter, based upon my own
knowledge and information obtained in the course of my official duties, including the
information contained in the public and classified In Camera, Ex Parte Declarations of Frances
J. Fleisch, NSA, I have determined that sensitive state secrets concerning NSA sources, methods,
and activities are implicated by allegations that lie at the core of plaintiffs' claims, and that the
disclosure of this information—as set forth herein and described in more detail in the Classified
NSA Declaration—can be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security
of the United States, and therefore that information must be protected from disclosure and
excluded from this case. Thus, as to this information, I formally assert the state secrets privilege.
ASSERTION OF STATUTORY PRIVILEGE UNDER NATIONAL SECURITY ACT
- Through this declaration, I also hereby invoke and assert a statutory privilege held
by the DNI under the National Security Act of 1947, as amended, to protect the information
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
9
described herein, in my classified in camera, ex parte declaration, and in the Classified NSA
Declaration, see 50 U.S.C. § 3024(i)(1). My assertion of this statutory privilege for intelligence
sources and methods is coextensive with my state secrets privilege assertion.
INFORMATION SUBJECT TO ASSERTIONS OF PRIVILEGE
- In general and unclassified terms, the following categories of still-classified
information are subject to my state secrets and statutory privilege assertions:
A. Threat Information: information concerning the specific nature of
the terrorist threat posed by al-Qa'ida and its affiliates and other
foreign terrorist organizations to the United States, including actual
intelligence information collected from intelligence collection
activities;
B. Persons Subject to Intelligence Activities: information that would
tend to confirm or deny whether particular individuals, including
the named plaintiffs, have been subject to any NSA intelligence
activities;
C. Operational Information Concerning NSA Intelligence Activities:
information concerning the scope and operational details of NSA
intelligence activities that may relate to or be necessary to
adjudicate plaintiffs' allegations, including:
(1) Communications Content Collection: information concerning
the scope or operational details of NSA intelligence activities
that may relate to or be necessary to adjudicate plaintiffs'
claims that the NSA indiscriminately intercepts the content of
communications, see, e.g., Jewel Complaint ¶¶ 9, 10, 73-77;
Shubert SAC ¶¶ 1, 2, 7, 64, 70, including:
a) TSP information: information concerning the scope and
operation of the now inoperative TSP regarding the
interception of the content of certain one-end-international
communications reasonably believed to involve a member or
agent of al-Qa'ida or an affiliated terrorist organization;
b) FISA section 702: information concerning operational
details related to the collection of communications under
FISA section 702; and
c) any other information related to demonstrating that the NSA
has not otherwise engaged in the content-surveillance
dragnet that the plaintiffs allege, and
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
10
(2) Communications Records Collection: information concerning
the scope or operational details of NSA intelligence activities
that may relate to or be necessary to adjudicate plaintiffs'
claims regarding the NSA's bulk collection of telephony and
Internet communication records (or "metadata"), see, e.g.,
Jewel Complaint ¶¶ 10-11, 13, 73-77, 82-97; Shubert SAC
¶ 102;
and
D. Telecommunications Provider Identities: information that may
tend to confirm or deny whether AT&T or Verizon (and to the
extent relevant or necessary, any other telecommunications
carrier), has provided assistance to the NSA in connection with any
intelligence activity, including the collection of communications
content or non-content transactional records alleged to be at issue
in this litigation.
DESCRIPTION OF INFORMATION SUBJECT TO PRIVILEGE
AND HARM OF DISCLOSURE
A. Information Concerning the Threat Posed by al-Qa'ida, Its
Affiliates, and Other Foreign Terrorist Organizations
- The intelligence activities, sources, and methods that are implicated by this
lawsuit, and put at risk of disclosure in further proceedings, must be viewed and understood in
the context of the threat faced by the United States. In unclassified terms, more than a decade
after the September 11, 2001 attacks, we remain in a global conflict with al-Qa'ida and we face
an evolving threat from its affiliates and adherents. America's campaign against terrorism did
not end with the mission at Bin Ladin's compound in May 2011. Indeed, the threats we face
have become more diverse.
- In addition, to the extent classified information about the al-Qa'ida threat, from
September 11, 2001 to the present, or the many other threats facing the United States, would be
at issue in attempting to litigate this case (for example, to demonstrate the reasonableness of the
intelligence-gathering activities initiated in the wake of the September 11, 2001, attacks, and
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
11
those that remain in place today), such information could not be disclosed without revealing
intelligence sources, methods, and information of the United States and thereby causing
exceptionally grave damage to the national security. Therefore, I assert the state secrets and DNI
statutory privilege to protect such information from disclosure. By way of illustration, set forth
below is an unclassified discussion of al-Qa'ida and several of its principal affiliates. My ex
parte, in camera declaration discusses some of the classified threat information pertaining to
these terrorist organizations that is subject to this assertion of privilege.
- Al-Qa'ida in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) remains of particular concern to the
United States. The National Counterterrorism Center (NCTC) assesses that this is the most
likely entity to attempt attacks in the West. Even in the wake of Anwar al-Aulaqi's death in
September 2011, this group maintains the intent and capability to conduct anti-United States
attacks with little to no warning. In its three attempted attacks against the U.S. Homeland – the
airliner plot of December 2009, an attempted attack against U.S.-bound cargo planes in October
2010, and an airliner plot in May 2012 similar to the 2009 attempt – AQAP has shown an
awareness of the capabilities of Western security procedures and demonstrated its efforts to
adapt. AQAP continues to exploit Yemen's inability to disrupt its operations on a consistent
basis to secure safe havens in the country and mount attacks against the U.S. Embassy in Sanaa.
- AQAP has also continued to publish the English-language Inspire magazine—
previously spearheaded by now-deceased al-Aulaqi and Samir Khan—in order to mobilize
Western-based individuals for violent action, and the publication continues to reach a wide
global audience of extremists.
- Al-Qa'ida's affiliate in Iraq has demonstrated its capacity to mount coordinated,
country-wide terrorist attacks is growing, as it continues at an increasing pace to kill Iraqi
civilians by the scores, even hundreds, with near-daily car and suicide bombs over the past year,
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
12
while also publicly acknowledging the group had established an affiliate in Syria, the al-Nusrah
Front, with resources diverted from its operations in Iraq. In April, AQI declared its merger with
al-Nusrah Front to form the "Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant." However, al-Nusrah Front's
leader rejected the merger and pledged allegiance directly to al-Qa'ida leader Ayman al-
Zawahiri. Zawahiri in June 2013 recognized al-Nusrah Front as an al-Qa'ida affiliate,
independent of AQI/ISIL and primarily responsible for operations in Syria. Despite his
differences with al-Qa'ida leadership over roles insides Syria, AQI/ISIL's leader last year
espoused support for violence against the United States, and continues to support al-Qa'ida's
global ideology.
- While al-Nusrah Front and AQI/ISIL at times openly have fought, both groups
share the near-term goals of removing the Syrian regime from power, and creating a government,
favorable to them, based on a strict interpretation of Sharia law. Al-Nusrah Front and AQI/ISIL
subscribe to a global jihadist ideology, and each group probably has ambitions beyond the
conflict in Syria. The groups potentially have access to thousands of foreign fighters, including
some Americans, who since 2012 have traveled to Syria to participate in the conflict for a variety
of reasons. Additionally, the groups probably have established training camps, familiarizing
recruits with combat tactics, as well as the handling of firearms and explosives. Al-Nusrah Front
and AQI/ISIL's access to foreign fighters, and the permissive operating environment in Syria,
raise the IC's concerns that such individuals, Americans among them, could be leveraged and
trained to conduct terrorist attacks in their home countries.
- AQI/ISIL leadership also continues to make public statements inciting violence
against governments outside of Iraq and Syria. In an August 2013 statement, the group's
spokesman called on Egyptians to attack the Egyptian military and follow the example of
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
13
extremists in Iraq and Syria. Both the group's spokesman and its overall leader last year
threatened future efforts to target Americans.
- For the first time, AQI/ISIL in 2013 began releasing propaganda openly recruiting
Westerners, including Belgian and French speakers, highlighting its intent to build a capability to
mount attacks against the West. AQI/ISIL's spokesman in mid-2013 publicly stated the group
plans to conduct attacks from eastern Iraq to western Lebanon, and the group's vitriolic rhetoric
and hard-line agenda suggest the group poses a broader threat outside the region than at any time
since it was pushed into decline by U.S. coalition forces during the Iraq conflict.
- During the past two-to-four years, American and Canadian authorities have
arrested several North America-based AQI/ISIL associates, highlighting the potential threat
posed to the United States. In May 2011, the FBI arrested Kentucky-based Iraqi nationals Waad
Alwan and Shareef Hamadi for attempting to send weapons and explosives from Kentucky to
Iraq and conspiring to commit terrorism while in Iraq. Alwan pled guilty to supporting terrorism
in December 2011. In January 2010, Canadian authorities arrested dual Iraqi-Canadian citizen
Faruq 'Isa who is accused of vetting individuals on the Internet for suicide operations in Iraq.
- The IC continues to monitor al-Shabaab and its foreign fighter cadre as a potential
threat to the U.S. Homeland, although the group is mainly focused on combating African Union
Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) forces battling the group in Somalia. The group, which formally
merged with al-Qa'ida in February 2012, also remains intent on conducting attacks against
regional and Western targets in East Africa, especially in countries contributing to the AMISOM
mission. Al-Shabaab associated militants in September 2013 conducted an attack on a shopping
mall in Nairobi, Kenya. Al-Shabaab leaders in the past have publicly called for transnational
attacks, including threatening to avenge the January 2012 death of British national and al-
Shabaab senior foreign fighter Bilal Berjawi.
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
14
- Al-Qa'ida in the Lands of the Islamic Maghreb (AQIM) and Boko Haram have
shown minimal interest in targeting the U.S. Homeland, but remain focused on local and regional
attack plotting, including targeting Western interests through kidnap-for-ransom operations and
other means. AQIM is actively working with local extremists in northern Mali to establish a safe
haven from which to advance future operational activities. Al-Murabitun, the extremist group
formed in August 2013 through the merger of two AQIM offshoots – Mohtar Belmokhtar's al-
Mulathamun Battalion and Tawhid wal Jihad in West Africa (TWJWA) – likewise appears
focused on plotting against Western interests in North and West Africa. Boko Haram probably
has an emerging awareness of U.S. persons or entities in the United States with connections to
Nigeria. The group's spokesman publicly threatened to find a way to attack a U.S.-based news
organization if its coverage of Islam did not change.
- In addition, while most Pakistani and Afghan militant groups pose a more direct
threat to U.S. interests and our allies in that region, the IC continues to watch for indicators that
any of these groups, networks, or individuals are actively pursuing or have decided to
incorporate operations outside of South Asia as a strategy to achieve their objectives. Tehrik-e
Taliban Pakistan (TTP) leaders have repeatedly threatened attacks against the United States,
including after the death of Bin Ladin. NCTC assesses that TTP's claim of responsibility for the
failed New York Times Square bombing in May 2010 demonstrates its willingness to act on this
intent.
- In sum, a variety of entities continue to pose a significant threat to the nation's
security. The U.S. Government is utilizing all lawful intelligence gathering capabilities,
including those set forth in the Classified NSA Declaration, to meet these threats and to protect
the American people. I set forth this information not only to provide the Court with background
information necessary to understand why the intelligence activities implicated by or directly at
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
15
issue in this case are being undertaken, but also to assert a claim of privilege over classified
threat information. The U.S. Government cannot disclose classified threat information in
addressing plaintiffs' allegations or other issues in this case, or even in publicly supporting its
assertion of privilege, because to do so would disclose to our adversaries what we know of their
plans and how we may be obtaining information about them. Such disclosures would lead our
adversaries not only to alter their plans, but also to implement greater security for their
communications, thereby increasing the risk of non-detection. In addition, disclosure of threat
information might reveal human sources for the United States, compromise those sources, and
put their or their families' lives in danger. Accordingly, because I believe that classified threat
information is crucial to understanding the importance to our national security of the NSA
intelligence activities, sources, and methods implicated by the plaintiffs' allegations, I must
assert the state secrets privilege and the DNI's statutory privilege over this classified threat
information because of the exceptionally grave danger to national security that could reasonably
be expected to result from its disclosure.
B. Information That May Tend To Confirm or Deny Whether Particular
Individuals, Including the Named Plaintiffs, Have Been Subject to NSA
Intelligence Activities.
- Next, I am also asserting privilege over information that would tend to reveal
whether particular individuals, including the named plaintiffs in this lawsuit, have been subject
to NSA intelligence activities implicated by plaintiffs' allegations. Disclosure of such
information can be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security,
because actually demonstrating whether particular individuals have or have not been targeted by
or subject to intelligence activities would require the disclosure of sensitive and classified details
about NSA intelligence-gathering methods. Accordingly, I assert the state secrets and DNI
statutory privilege as to this information.
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
16
- The NSA cannot publicly confirm or deny whether any particular individual is
subject to intelligence-gathering activities, no matter how likely or unlikely it might appear that
the individual would be subject to surveillance. If the NSA were to reveal that an individual is
the target or a subject of intelligence-gathering, the collection capability relating to that
individual would certainly be compromised. On the other hand, if the NSA were to reveal that
an individual is not the target or subject of intelligence-gathering, adversaries would know that a
particular individual has avoided scrutiny and is a secure source for communicating. Moreover,
providing assurances to those individuals who are not targets or subjects quickly becomes
unworkable when faced with a situation in which an individual has in fact been a target or
subject. If the NSA were to confirm that any specific individual is not a target or subject of
intelligence-gathering, but later refuse to confirm or deny that fact in a situation involving an
actual target or subject, it would be apparent that intelligence-gathering was occurring in the
latter case. The only recourse for the NSA is to neither confirm nor deny whether someone has
been targeted by or subject to NSA intelligence-gathering activities, regardless of whether the
individual has been a target or subject or not. To say otherwise when challenged in litigation
would result in the frequent, routine exposure of NSA information, sources, and methods, and
would severely undermine surveillance activities in general.
C. Information Concerning the Scope or Operational Details of NSA
Intelligence Activities, Including NSA Sources or Methods.
- Furthermore, I am asserting privilege over any other still-classified facts
concerning the scope or operational details of any NSA intelligence activities that may relate to
or be necessary to adjudicate plaintiffs' allegations. As noted above, my privilege assertion
encompasses (1) facts concerning the operation of the now-defunct TSP, including any facts
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
17
needed to demonstrate that the TSP was limited to the interception of the content¹ of one-end
foreign communications reasonably believed to involve a member or agent of al-Qa'ida or an
affiliated terrorist organization, (2) facts concerning the operation of the collection of
communications under FISA Section 702; (3) any other information related to demonstrating that
the NSA has not otherwise engaged in the content-surveillance dragnet that the plaintiffs allege,
and (4) still classified information concerning the scope or operational details of NSA
intelligence activities involving the collection of bulk communications metadata, as discussed in
greater detail in the Classified NSA Declaration.
- As the NSA indicates, see Public NSA Declaration, the NSA's collection of the
content of communications under the TSP was directed at international communications in which
a participant was reasonably believed to be associated with al-Qa'ida or an affiliated
organization. Thus, as the U.S. Government has previously stated, plaintiffs' allegation that the
NSA has indiscriminately collected the content of millions of communications sent or received
by people inside the United States after September 11, 2001, under the TSP is false. I concur
with the NSA that to the extent it must demonstrate in this case that the TSP was not the content
dragnet plaintiffs allege, or demonstrate that the NSA has not otherwise engaged in the alleged
content dragnet, highly classified details about the scope and operation of the TSP and other
NSA intelligence activities would be disclosed, including NSA intelligence sources and methods,
thus risking exceptional harm to national security.
- As explained in further detail in the Classified NSA Declaration, the United States
faced urgent and immediate intelligence challenges after the September 11, 2001, attacks, and
undertook signals intelligence activities pursuant to presidential authorization that were designed
to meet those challenges and to detect and prevent future terrorist attacks. In addition to the
1 The term "content" is used herein to refer to the substance, meaning, or purport of a
communication, as defined in 18 U.S.C.§ 2510(8).
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
18
TSP, those activities have included the bulk collection of telephony and Internet non-content
metadata that was also later transitioned to FISA authority.
- Based on my personal consideration and judgment as to the harm disclosure can
be expected to cause to national security, my privilege assertion includes, but is not limited to,
the following information, discussed in greater detail in the Classified NSA Declaration.
- I assert privilege over still-classified facts concerning: the scope and operation of
the TSP and any other NSA intelligence activities needed to demonstrate that the TSP was
limited to the interception of international communications reasonably believed to involve a
member or agent of al-Qa'ida or an affiliated terrorist organization; the collection of
communications content under FISA section 702; and the fact that the NSA does not otherwise
conduct a dragnet of content surveillance as the plaintiffs allege. Such facts include those
concerning (a) how targets were selected under the TSP; (b) the specific sources methods used
under the TSP to intercept telephone and Internet communications; (c) the nature and identity of
the targets under the TSP; (d) any additional classified details about the operation of the TSP that
would be necessary to litigate the plaintiffs' allegations; and (e) other NSA surveillance
activities, including collection of communications content under FISA section 702, that may be
needed to address and disprove the content dragnet allegation. See Classified NSA Declaration.
In my judgment, revealing or risking disclosure of the foregoing NSA intelligence activities,
sources, and methods in order to show that the NSA is not conducting the "dragnet" on the
content of communications that plaintiffs allege can reasonably be expected to cause
exceptionally grave harm to national security by disclosing to our adversaries the ability of the
United States to monitor and track their activities and communications.
- I also assert privilege over still-classified facts that would describe the scope or
operational details of other NSA intelligence activities, including but not necessarily limited to
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
19
metadata collection activities, that may relate to or be necessary to adjudicate plaintiffs' claims.
See Classified NSA Declaration. In my judgment, the NSA is unable to disclose information
about the scope or operation of the NSA's bulk collection or targeted analysis of Internet or
telephony metadata (whether conducted under presidential or FISC authority), beyond that which
has already been officially acknowledged by the U.S. Government, without risking exceptionally
grave harm to national security. Disclosing or confirming further details about these activities
could seriously undermine an important tool—metadata collection and analysis—for tracking
possible terrorist plots; and could reveal methods by which NSA has targeted and continues to
target its intelligence-gathering activities, thus helping foreign adversaries evade detection, and
otherwise undermining ongoing intelligence operations conducted under E.O. 12333 and FISC
authorization.
- In my judgment, disclosure of still-classified details regarding these intelligence-
gathering activities, either directly or indirectly, would seriously compromise, if not destroy,
important and vital ongoing intelligence operations. After personal consideration of the matter,
it is my judgment that disclosing the information described herein and by the NSA would
compromise important and critical activities, sources, and methods, thereby helping our
adversaries evade detection and causing exceptionally grave damage to the national security of
the United States.
D. Information That May Tend To Confirm or Deny Whether AT&T, Verizon,
or any Other Telecommunications Carrier Has Provided Assistance to the
NSA in Connection With any Intelligence Activity.
- In addition, I am asserting privilege over information that may tend to confirm or
deny whether or not AT&T, Verizon, or to the extent necessary, any other particular
telecommunications provider, has assisted any NSA intelligence activity, including but not
necessarily limited to the alleged intelligence activities. The disclosure of any information that
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
20
would tend to confirm or deny allegations of such assistance can be expected to cause
exceptionally grave harm to the national security, for a variety of reasons.
- Confirming or denying such allegations would reveal to foreign adversaries
whether or not the NSA utilizes particular intelligence sources and methods and, thus, either
compromise actual sources and methods or disclose that the NSA does not utilize a particular
source or method. For example, revealing that a particular company assists the NSA would
compromise a range of intelligence activities by providing confirmation that certain channels of
communications are vulnerable to NSA interception. Confirmation or denial of a carrier's
assistance would replace speculation with certainty for hostile foreign adversaries who are
balancing the risk that a particular channel of communication may not be secure against the need
to communicate efficiently.
- This remains so, in my judgment, notwithstanding the U.S. Government's
declassification of a now-expired April 25, 2013, FISC order directing Verizon Business
Network Services (VBNS) to produce bulk telephony metadata to the NSA. Although the U.S.
Government, in acknowledging the existence of the telephony metadata program carried out
under FISC authorization, also confirmed the participation of VBNS in that program for the time
period covered by that order (April 25 through July 19, 2013), it has never confirmed or denied
the identities of any other carriers that previously participated in that program, or the identities of
any carriers that continue to participate in the program today.
CONCLUSION
- In sum, I am asserting the state secrets privilege and the DNI's statutory privilege
set forth in 50 U.S.C. § 3024(i)(1) to protect the classified national security information
described herein and in the Classified NSA Declaration. I respectfully request that the Court not
only protect that information from disclosure, but take all steps necessary to protect the
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
21
intelligence information, sources, and methods described herein in order to prevent exceptionally
grave damage to the national security of the United States.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed on: December 20, 2013
JAMES R. CLAPPER
Director of National Intelligence
Public Declaration of James R. Clapper, Director of National Intelligence
Jewel et al. v. National Security Agency et al. (08-cv-4873-JSW); Shubert, et al. v. Obama, et al., No. 07-cv-693-JSW
22