The SIGINT Philosopher: Unlike All My Terrible Teammates, I Am a

Open PDF
Creating agency: NSA National Security Agency (US)
Document date: 2012-09-17
Type: SIDtoday
Pages: 4
Genre: newsletter
Banner:
Classification: UNCLASSIFIED
Dissemination: FOUO

A 2012 SIDtoday SIGINT Philosopher column using the annual ACE performance review process as a springboard to examine the structural tension between individual competition and collaborative teamwork at NSA, arguing that the agency's promotion and awards system inadvertently incentivizes analysts to hoard work rather than mentor colleagues or enable others.

Long Description:
This unclassified SIDtoday column, published September 17, 2012 as the fifth installment of the SIGINT Philosopher series, opens with a self-aware account of the author completing their annual ACE performance review bullets — and noticing the inherent contradiction between bullets that claim individual superiority and bullets that simultaneously claim to have elevated everyone else's performance. The author identifies this as symptomatic of a structural flaw in most promotion systems, including NSA's: the colleagues an analyst is supposed to cooperate with to accomplish the mission are simultaneously their competitors for a fixed pool of promotion and awards resources, creating rational incentives to prioritize personal credit over collective output. The column develops this tension through practical workplace scenarios — most notably the dilemma facing a subject-matter expert when interesting work arrives: handle it personally for a clean, creditable output, or invest extra time mentoring a junior colleague at the cost of personal productivity metrics. The author argues that informal day-to-day mentoring and ad hoc assistance — what they call "office assists" in a deliberate basketball analogy contrasting LeBron James's facilitative style with Michael Jordan's individual dominance — are systematically undercounted in formal performance documentation because they resist easy quantification. Formal mentoring roles are documentable; quietly helping a colleague work through a difficult problem is not. The piece surveys potential remedies including peer performance review systems and points-based peer recognition programs the author encountered in private sector employment, while acknowledging the risks of junk feedback and gaming. It closes with a pointed observation that collaboration has been described as essential to the post-9/11 intelligence mission every day of the author's career — making the absence of meaningful metrics for collaborative behavior a notable institutional inconsistency.
Programs:
SCQAWK

People mentioned:
James, LeBron, Jordan, Michael

Countries:
-

Tags:
performance review, promotions, analyst culture, workforce, organizational culture, SIGINT Philosopher, humor

Identifier:
sigint-philosopher-unlike-all-my-terrible

PDF SHA-256:
02e0e4a9e0dcad32974b8d474141b98be9239a45c4fe66b4e1b5a80b7ffab5fc

DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST
POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA
AUS CAN GBR NZL

Welcome! Saturday, 10 Nov 2012

  • Web search
  • Agency-all Emails
  • SID-all Emails
  • NSA Rolodex
  • SCQAWK: The SID Mailbag
  • SIDtoday Blog
  • SIDtoday Series
  • SIGINT Worldwide VTC
  • SIDtoday Article
  • Letter to the Editor
  • SIGINT-y Social Media Page

(U) The SIGINT Philosopher: Unlike All My Terrible Teammates, I Am a Wonderful Teammate

FROM: (U//FOUO) [REDACTED]

Run Date: 09/17/2012
(U//FOUO) Like many of you, I recently finished providing my supervisor with written bullets summarizing my achievements to help her with the task of completing my yearly ACE assessment. As I sought for just the right phraseology that would demonstrate how irreplaceable I am, I found myself using phrases like "produced 50% of all reporting on a team of seven people," or "was the only team member who did such-and-such." They were all some version of indirectly saying "I am more productive than other people."

(U) Then, I had to complete bullets for the collaboration section, in which I tried desperately to show that while outperforming everyone else, I also somehow managed to help them out in such a way that they were more productive because of me. Which means I then had to talk about the great work done by those same people I supposedly outperformed blindfolded with my hands tied behind my

SERIES:
The SIGINT Philosopher

  1. The SIGINT Philosopher Is Back -- with a New Face!
  2. The SIGINT Philosopher: Descartes Would Have Been a Lousy SIGINT Reporter
  3. The SIGINT Philosopher: When Brevity Is Just the Soul of "Huh?"
  4. The SIGINT Philosopher: In Praise of Not Knowing
  5. The SIGINT Philosopher: Unlike All My Terrible Teammates, I Am a Wonderful Teammate
  6. The SIGINT Philosopher: Lessons for Civil Servants from the American Civil War (That Don't Concern Killing
    Vampires)

outperformed blindfolded with my hands tied behind my back. This highlights what I think is an inherent weakness in our promotion system (and most promotion systems): the people we're supposed to be cooperating with to get the job done are the same ones we're competing with for limited promotion and awards dollars.

(U) My guess is that if you are thinking about getting promoted, it probably complicates your calculus somewhat
when you are making decisions about how to spend your time in a day. If you are a subject-matter expert, and something really juicy and interesting but also difficult comes in, do you knock it out yourself, or do you spend extra time to have someone newer handle the work with guidance from you?

(U) Judging from many offices I've been in, I would say that at least sometimes, the prevailing prejudice is that it's better to be able to take credit for doing something important without help than it is to claim you enabled others to do the same work. If you think about it, it's also a much easier bullet to write. "Wrote 40% of reports on a team of eleven people" is easier to understand and sounds more impressive than "helped give a lot of people who were feeling underutilized a purpose in life by giving them stuff to do that mattered," or
"helped someone to do a good job on it even though it took more time to do that than it would have taken to do it myself."

(U//FOUO) I work on a very small team, and so for most work, I don't have much choice but to do it myself. But I have felt this same tug in my own work, and confess I sometimes feel impatient while explaining things to others, because deep down, I sense it is hurting my ability to afford to send my son to MIT one day.*

(U) Almost everyone has mentoring as part of their objectives, but it is much easier to document "formal" mentoring, such as a role in a professional organization, than it is to document informal day-to-day helping out of the people around you. Lebron James (the basketball player) will never get the respect Michael Jordan did, because nobody cares that you found the open guy for the winning shot with five seconds left instead of taking the shot yourself. In fact, your office "Lebron" has it even worse than the real one does: there are no statistics to record ad hoc office assists.

(U) But assists should matter. When I worked at a large corporation once, they had a system to try to rewa d

corporation once, they had a system to try to reward employees for helping each other. Essentially, everyone got a certain number of points they earned each month that could be applied to purchases from a rewards program. It was a really good rewards program, and people really used those reward points. In addition to the ones you got for yourself, you got some points you could give to someone for helping you out at work. It was a major incentive to help other people. Some employees who were especially helpful covered their entire Christmas shopping using those reward points.

(U) The notion of "peer performance review" has apparently taken off in some circles. According to a 31 July
2012 article in the Wall Street Journal (see it here), some firms are using peer performance reviews as a way to flatten management and encourage teamwork. Bloggers commenting on this article pronounced that "The manager-driven, once-a-year performance review may soon become a thing of the past. Good riddance."

(U) Admittedly, there are some problems with peer performance review. One big issue is the same one that plagues internet news sites that allow comments: junk feedback. While it is probably dangerous to completely base rewards on employee feedback, I have to believe that what peers think about an employee has to mean something. If a branch manager thinks that an employee deserves 10% of his branch's available rewards, but the branch rank and file feel this person deserves none, that shows at the very least that there is a problem somewhere.

(U) I don't think I've spent a day in my career as a post-9/11 hire where I haven't heard about the importance of collaboration. If it really is that important, it seems like it ought to be have some metrics other than those dreamt up in my own self-conflicting -- and self-conflicted -- bullets.

(U) Notes:

  • (U) My son will never go to MIT. In order to multiply by sevens, he has to physically walk across the room to imagine himself scoring a touchdown for each factor of seven.

(U//FOUO) Have thoughts on this topic? Post them on the related Tapioca Pebble.

(U) Standard disclaimer: The opinions expressed by the SIGINT Philosopher are his own and do not necessarily

Comments/Suggestions about this article?

"(U//FOUO) SIDtoday articles may not be republished or
reposted outside NSANet without the consent of S0121
(DL sid_comms)."
Information Owner: [REDACTED]
Page Publisher: [REDACTED]
Last Modified: 11/10/2012 / Last Reviewed: 11/10/2012

DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE
CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR
NZL
DERIVED FROM: NSA/CSSM 1-52, DATED 08 JAN 2007
DECLASSIFY ON: 20320108