Yahoo! Inc's Unclassified Motion Under FISC Rule 62 to Allow Pre-Publication Review of Documents Produced in Response to this Court's July 15, 2013 Order, In re Directives Pursuant to Section 105B of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act

Open PDF
Creating agency: FISC Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (US)
Document date: 2013-09-30
Type: FOIA
Pages: 6
Classification: -
Dissemination: -
ACLU,EFF ↗2013-09-30

FISC/FISCR Court Filings

Long Description:
No extended description available.
Programs:
-

People mentioned:
-

Countries:
-

Tags:
-

Identifier:
FISC_-_105b-g-07-01-yahoo-motion-131001

PDF SHA-256:
efd3b77548db9a61005d0131296b1bcc7701476cb45147c18bbdf79166dbb7f6

FILED
LEEANN FLYNN HALL, CLERK
SEP 30 2013 5:05 PM.
U.S. Foreign Intelligence
Surveillance Court
IN THE FOREIGN INTELLIGENCE SURVEILLANCE COURT

In re: Directives Pursuant to Section
105B of the Foreign Intelligence
Surveillance Act

No. 105B(g) 07-01

YAHOO! INC.'S UNCLASSIFIED MOTION UNDER FISC RULE 62 TO
ALLOW PRE-PUBLICATION REVIEW OF DOCUMENTS PRODUCED
IN RESPONSE TO THIS COURT'S JULY 15, 2013 ORDER

Pursuant to this Court's order of July 15, 2013, the Government has begun
conducting a declassification review of the Court records associated with this case.
It provided the first portion of those records to the Court on September 12, 2013,
provided the second portion on September 27, 2013, and intends to make further
submissions on a rolling basis. Counsel for Yahoo has previously had access to
classified versions of these documents—many of which Yahoo itself filed. While
the Executive Branch retains some discretion over declassification decisions,
Yahoo respectfully requests permission to review the Government's submissions to
ensure that its redactions are well-founded and do not unintentionally create a risk
that the documents will be misunderstood. Likewise, because this Court ultimately
retains control over its own records, Yahoo seeks permission to review the
documents in order to state any objections to further redactions the Court may
make. Yahoo asks this Court to enter an order permitting Yahoo, through its
counsel holding an appropriate security clearance, to review all documents already

1

provided and to be provided by the Government in response to this Court's July 15,
2013 Order prior to ordering publication of such documents in redacted form.

Facts

In response to this Court's July 15, 2013 Order, the Government conducted a
declassification review of the Court's Memorandum Opinion of April 25, 2008 and
an accompanying order. Gov't's Second Response at 1-2. At the conclusion of
that review, it provided proposed redactions to the Court for the Court's own
review on September 12, 2013. The Government completed its declassification
review of briefs and materials cited in the Memorandum Opinion on September 27,
2013, and submitted those documents to the Court with proposed redactions. The
Government has stated that going forward it will complete its declassification
reviews on a rolling basis. Gov't's First Response at 1. Among the briefs and
materials the Government has submitted or will submit to the Court are eleven
briefs and one set of declarations filed by Yahoo. Id. app. at 1-3. Yet, the
government's proposed course of action—awaiting Court review on the
declassification by the DNI—avoids any review or input by Yahoo. Id. at 2.

Argument

Yahoo respectfully requests that the Court permit Yahoo, through its counsel
holding appropriate security clearance as required by FISC Rule 63, to review all
documents already provided and to be provided by the Government in response to

2

this Court's July 15, 2013 Order prior to the publication of such documents in
redacted form. Counsel for Yahoo in this case presently has access to "classified
information pertaining to this case in accordance with applicable security
requirements and regulations and applicable orders issued by [FISCR] or the
FISC." In re Directives Pursuant to Section 105B of Foreign Intelligence
Surveillance Act, 551 F.3d 1004, 1017 (Foreign Int. Surv. Ct. Rev. 2008). In
addition, twelve of the documents the Government has or expects to provide to the
Court will be Yahoo's own motions and declarations. As such, permitting counsel
for Yahoo to review the documents provided by the Government will not result in
any additional disclosure of classified information.¹

Furthermore, this Court retains control over its own records, and thus the
Government has argued that publication of court records requires additional action
by this Court after the Government has concluded its classification review. Rule
62(a); See Gov't Response to Provider's Motion at 1, 1 n. 1; In re Motion for
Release of Court Records, 526 F. Supp. 2d 484, 486 (Foreign Int. Surv. Ct. 2007)
(FISC "has supervisory power over its own records and files") (citations omitted).

Permitting Yahoo, by its counsel, to review the documents provided by the
Government in response to this Court's July 15, 2013 Order will assist the Court in
determining whether the documents are suitable for publication. In determining

¹ Through this motion, Yahoo does not request access to any documents or portions of documents that were
previously filed with this court ex parte.

3

whether an order is suitable for publication, the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance
Court of Review has considered whether redactions "distort[ ] the content of the
discussion of the statutory and constitutional issues." In re Directives, 551 F.3d at
1016. As a party to this litigation—and as the author of twelve of the documents
concerned—Yahoo has a unique understanding of "the content of the discussion of
the statutory and constitutional issues" involved in this case. In addition, as
discussed in Yahoo's Reply, Yahoo is currently facing litigation alleging statutory
and constitutional violations in connection with United States Government
demands for user data, which give Yahoo a unique interest in ensuring that the
orders, as redacted, are suitable for publication and accurately reflect the
discussion of statutory and constitutional issues. Yahoo Reply at 4-5. Therefore,
the Court should permit Yahoo to review the documents as redacted before the
Court orders publication.

Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, Yahoo asks this Court to enter an order permitting
Yahoo, by its counsel holding appropriate security clearance, to review all
documents already provided and to be provided by the Government in response to
this Court's July 15, 2013 Order prior to ordering publication of such documents in
redacted form.

4

Dated: September 30, 2013

Signature: /s/ Marc J. Zwillinger
Marc J. Zwillinger
Jacob A. Sommer
ZwillGen PLLC
1705 N St. NW
Washington, DC 20036
marc@zwillgen.com
jake@zwillgen.com
Attorneys for Yahoo! Inc.

5

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I hereby certify that on September 30, 2013, I served copies of the foregoing
motion on:

Christine E. Gunning
United States Department of Justice
Litigation Security Group
2 Constitution Square
145 N St NE
Suite 2W-115
Washington, D.C. 20530
(202) 514-9016
Christine.E.Gunning@usdoj.gov

pursuant to FISC Rule 8 and procedures established by the Security and
Emergency Planning Staff, United States Department of Justice.

/s/Jacob A. Sommer
Jacob A. Sommer

6