NSA Course Materials: Module 5
Open PDFDocument date: 2011-10-07
Type: FOIA
Pages: 10
Classification: TOP SECRET SI
Dissemination: NOFORN
Module 5 of 2011 NSA Course Materials regarding the agency’s metadata collection programs under Sections 501 and 402 of FISA. ACLU/EFF FOIA Litigation.
My notes
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Version 24 (Final)
Last Updated 10/6/11
Includes CAO Review feedback
COURSE: (TS//SI//NF) OVSC1205 Special Training on FISA (Analytical)
COURSE: (TS//SI//NF) OVSC1206 Special Training on FISA (Technical)
Module 5: (U) The Analytical and Technical Work Roles
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) Module Introduction | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 1 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5010
NEXT FRAME ID: 5020
BACK FRAME ID: n/a
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Insert image of HMC Character and
Technical Character sitting at a table
(U) Module 5
(U) The Analytical and Technical Work Roles
(U) This module will enable you to:
- (U) Compare and contrast the analytical and technical work roles
- (U) Identify analytical and technical personnel's authorization to touch the data
- (U) Identify how the authorities impact interactions with other roles and the data
(U) (Technical Character): During this part of our trip we will compare and contrast the analytical and technical work roles and provide you with a basic knowledge of the two distinct areas. This will serve as an introduction to the more role-specific module you will complete later.
(U) This module will enable you to:
- (U) Compare and contrast the analytical and technical work roles
- (U) Identify analytical and technical personnel's authorization to touch the data
- (U) Identify how the authorities impact interactions with other roles and the data
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 1 of 10
Derived From: NSA/CSSM 1-52
Dated: 20070108
Declassify On: 20350501
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) The Analytical Work Role | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 2 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5020
NEXT FRAME ID: 5030
BACK FRAME ID: 5010
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Begin with image of HMC Character
and Technical Character sitting at a table,
then provide a close up of the HMC
Character
(U) The Analytical Work Role
(TS//SI//NF) The Analytical Work Role includes these primary functions:
- HMC
- Those who conduct intelligence analysis queries
- Those who can view and disseminate the results of intelligence analysis queries
(TS//SI//NF) (HMC Character): The analytical work role includes three primary functions: Homeland Mission Coordinators (HMC), those who can conduct intelligence analysis queries, and those who can view and disseminate the results of intelligence analysis queries.
(TS//SI//NF) Homeland Mission Coordinators, or HMCs, review and approve the RAS nominations. The analysts and HMCs work through the RAS approval process together to get the identifiers RAS-approved.
(TS//SI//NF) Recall from the last module that not all analysts are permitted to conduct contact chaining queries. Those who are permitted to conduct queries of the bulk metadata have been granted [REDACTED] credentials. Those who are permitted to view and disseminate query results, but not conduct queries, have been granted [REDACTED] credentials.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 2 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) The Technical Work Role | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 3 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5030
NEXT FRAME ID: 5040
BACK FRAME ID: 5020
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Begin with image of HMC Character
and Technical Character sitting at a table,
then provide a close up of the Technical
Character
(U) The Technical Work Role
(TS//SI//NF) The Technical Work Role is made up of two main functions:
- Support to Collection and Metadata [REDACTED]
- Support to Storage, Presentation, and Maintenance
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): The work performed by technical personnel in support of the Bulk Metadata Programs assists everyone working in support of these programs to maintain compliance with applicable legal documents and relevant authorities. Within the technical roles, there are two main areas of responsibility: collection and metadata [REDACTED] and the storage, presentation, and maintenance of the metadata.
(TS//SI//NF) Some high-level examples of how key organizations support collection and metadata [REDACTED] include:
- [REDACTED] to gain access to BR and PR/TT metadata.
- [REDACTED] develops protocol processing software that supports the collection and metadata [REDACTED] and standardization.
- Mission Capabilities (TD) integrates the BR and PR/TT protocol processing software into the larger exploitation systems.
(TS//SI//NF) [REDACTED] and Mission Capabilities also support the storage, presentation, and maintenance aspects of the Bulk Metadata Programs, and some high-level examples include:
- Mission Capabilities manages the BR and PR/TT repositories, as well as prepares the metadata for the analysts to use.
- [REDACTED] provides reasonable assurance that the data is normalized and presented in a usable format and provides support to intelligence analysts.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 3 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) Authorization to Touch the Data | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 4 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5040
NEXT FRAME ID: 5050
BACK FRAME ID: 5030
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Insert image of HMC Character and
Technical Character sitting at a table
(U) Authorization to Touch the Data
(U) Analytical and technical personnel have different authorization to touch the metadata due to the nature of their work roles
(U) Authorization for Analytical Personnel
- (TS//SI/[REDACTED]) Perform intelligence analysis (querying the data)
(U) Authorizations for Technical Personnel
- [REDACTED] Create, test, and implement tools to make this data easier for analytic personnel to use (TS/[REDACTED])
- Validate that safeguards appropriately control analyst's access
- (TS//SI/[REDACTED]) Perform processes to make the data usable
- Validation
- Defeat of collection
- Processing
- Analysis of high-volume identifiers
- Maintenance of records to demonstrate compliance
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): As we have discussed throughout the course, the sensitivity of the data drives many of the policies and restrictions that control access to the BR and PR/TT bulk metadata. However, because of the different roles and responsibilities of analytical and technical personnel, both have different authorizations to touch the metadata. Recall from Module 1 we defined "touching the data" as any form of data handling that creates an opportunity for a violation of the FISC Orders to occur. These activities may include data acquisition, modifying/preparing the data, querying, viewing results of the queries, and even oversight and compliance functions.
Analytic Personnel Info (audio file name OVSC_1205_M5_5040_A):
(TS//SI//NF) (HMC Character): Analytic personnel have authorization to touch the metadata to perform intelligence analysis. Analyst actions, such as querying the metadata for intelligence analysis purposes, must be done in a controlled way via tools designed to limit intelligence analysis access to RAS-approved identifiers and to the appropriate number of hops. Using these tools also provides reasonable assurance that these queries are tracked and
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 4 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
audited.
Technical Personnel Info (audio file name OVSC_1205_M5_5040_T):
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): Technical personnel create, test, and implement tools to make this data easier for analytic personnel to use, while validating that safeguards appropriately control analysts' access to the bulk metadata. Additionally, technical personnel may access the metadata to perform those processes needed to make the metadata usable for intelligence analysis. These processes may include metadata validation; the defeat of the collection, processing, or analysis of metadata associated with [REDACTED] identifiers; and the maintenance of records to demonstrate compliance with the terms of the authority.
(TS//SI//NF) In order to do this work effectively, technical personnel are allowed to access the metadata using identifiers that are not RAS-approved. In the case of [REDACTED] identifiers, technical personnel may use non-RAS-approved identifiers to query the metadata to confirm if the identifier is a [REDACTED] identifier and thus should not be included for target analysis. They may then share the identifier and the fact that it is a [REDACTED] identifier with authorized personnel. However, no other information resulting from such queries can be used for intelligence analysis purposes.
(TS//SI//NF) Technical personnel must take great care with their responsibilities because they may be accessing the data through tools that do not have safeguards, such as [REDACTED] that impose restrictions and minimize the chances of a violation of the FISC Orders. As a result, we need to maintain boundaries between technical and analytical personnel, and be crystal clear as to the circumstances under which the two groups can interact.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 5 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) Interaction Between Analytical and Technical Personnel | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 5 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5050
NEXT FRAME ID: 5060
BACK FRAME ID: 5040
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Insert image of HMC Character and
Technical Character sitting at a table
(U) Interaction Between Analytical and Technical Personnel
(U) (Begin with image of analytical and Technical Character sitting at a table, then provide a close up of the Technical Character)
(TS//SI//NF) All interactions must be based on RAS-approved identifiers and those results found within the number of hops authorized for intelligence analysis purposes
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): As we just discussed, analytical and technical personnel have different authorizations to touch this metadata. Because of these different authorizations, we must be careful when the two types of personnel are interacting with regard to this metadata. Specifically, outside of the sharing of [REDACTED] identifiers for defeat purposes, technical personnel should only be providing analytical personnel information under certain conditions.
(TS//SI//NF) (HMC Character): Sometimes, when analyzing the results of intelligence analysis queries, one or more of the specific results may seem out of the ordinary. Is it a [REDACTED] identifier that was overlooked? Is the identifier misnormalized? Is there something that just seems out of place? Or perhaps there is a particular data field in your results that you don't understand. In such instances, intelligence analysts may require assistance from certain technical personnel responsible for data integrity functions.
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): In these instances, technical personnel may assist authorized intelligence analysts, but any and all assistance must be based on RAS-approved identifiers and those results found within the number of hops authorized for intelligence analysis purposes. Essentially, when providing information to analytical personnel in these circumstances, the technical personnel must abide by the rules for the analytical personnel.
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): In the end, all personnel have a vested interest and shared responsibility in ensuring that only the most accurate intelligence information is reported to customers, while abiding by the policies and requirements in place for this metadata.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 6 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) Knowledge Check | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 6 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5060
NEXT FRAME ID: 5070
BACK FRAME ID: 5050
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Knowledge Check
1. (TS//SI//NF) TRUE or FALSE: Technical personnel and analytic work roles have the same authorization to touch the bulk metadata.
a) TRUE
b) FALSE
2. (TS//SI//NF) The Analytic Work Role includes these functions: intelligence analysts who query the data, intelligence analysts who can view the results of intelligence analysis queries, and [REDACTED]
a) Mission Capabilities (TD)
b) [REDACTED]
c) Homeland Mission Coordinators (HMC)
d) [REDACTED]
3. (TS//SI//NF) The Technical Work Roles are comprised of two general areas of responsibility including 1) [REDACTED] and 2) [REDACTED]
a) 1) collection and metadata [REDACTED] 2) reviewing RAS nominations
b) 1) collection of content, 2) storage, presentation, and maintenance of the metadata
c) 1) reviewing RAS nominations, 2) working with the telecommunications partners
d) 1) collection and metadata [REDACTED] 2) storage, presentation, and maintenance of the metadata
(U) (Technical Character): Let's make a few notes in our travel journal and see what we remember from this topic.
ANSWERS:
Question 1. (TS//SI//NF) Correct! The answer is b) FALSE. Technical personnel have authority to make the metadata usable for intelligence analysis, while analytical personnel can only touch the bulk metadata for intelligence analysis purposes using RAS-approved identifiers within the authorized number of hops.
(TS//SI//NF) Incorrect. The correct answer is b) FALSE. Technical personnel have authority to make the metadata usable for intelligence analysis, while analytical personnel can only touch the bulk metadata for intelligence analysis purposes using RAS-approved identifiers within the authorized number of hops.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 7 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Question 2. (TS//SI//NF) Correct! The correct answer is c). The Analytical Work Role includes analysts and Homeland Mission Coordinators (HMC).
(TS//SI//NF) Incorrect. The correct answer is c). The Analytical Work Role includes analysts and Homeland Mission Coordinators (HMC).
Question 3. (TS//SI//NF) Right! The correct answer is d). The Technical Work Roles are comprised of two general areas of support including collection and metadata [REDACTED] as well as storage, presentation, and maintenance of the metadata.
(TS//SI//NF) Incorrect. The correct answer is d). The Technical Work Roles are comprised of two general areas of support including collection and metadata [REDACTED] as well as storage, presentation, and maintenance of the metadata.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 8 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) Knowledge Check | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 7 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5070
NEXT FRAME ID: 5080
BACK FRAME ID: 5060
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Knowledge Check
4. (TS//SI//NF) [REDACTED] staff have access to the bulk metadata in order to prepare the metadata for the analysts to use.
a) [REDACTED]
b) Mission Capabilities (TD)
c) Analytical
d) Office of General Counsel (OGC)
5. (TS//SI//NF) If an intelligence analyst seeks assistance from technical personnel, technical personnel [REDACTED]
a) can query the metadata to confirm the analyst's results and point out potentially noteworthy contacts at the third or fourth hop
b) should explain that they are unable to assist in any way, except to identify [REDACTED] identifiers
c) may offer assistance, but must be cautious that any results shared or discussed are based on a RAS-approved identifiers and those results that fall within the number of hops authorized for intelligence analysis purposes
d) should provide whatever assistance is needed, but make a note of it in case anyone in management has questions later
e) should decline to assist because technical personnel should not assist intelligence analysts
(No audio or transcript on this page)
Question 4. (TS//SI//NF) Correct! Mission Capabilities staff has access to the bulk metadata in order to prepare the metadata for the analysts to use.
(TS//SI//NF) Incorrect. The correct answer is b). Mission Capabilities staff has access to the bulk metadata in order to prepare the metadata for the analysts to use.
Question 5. (TS//SI//NF) Correct! If an intelligence analyst seeks assistance from technical personnel, technical personnel may offer assistance, but must be cautious that any results shared or discussed are based on RAS-approved identifiers and those results that fall within the number of hops authorized for intelligence analysis purposes.
(TS//SI//NF) Incorrect. The correct answer is c). If an intelligence analyst seeks assistance from technical personnel, technical personnel may offer assistance, but must be cautious that any results shared or discussed are based on RAS-approved identifiers and those results that fall within the number of hops authorized for intelligence analysis purposes.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 9 of 10
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
| Topic | Page Classification | Screen Number | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (U) Summary | TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN | 8 of 8 | ||
| Home | Exit | Glossary | Back | Next |
DATE/PREPARER: SLS
FRAME ID: 5080
NEXT FRAME ID: 5090
BACK FRAME ID: 5070
ALT TAG:
GRAPHIC/AV:
(U) Insert image of HMC Character and
Technical Character sitting at a table
(U) Summary
(U) Now that you have completed this module you should be able to:
- (U) Compare and contrast the analytical and technical work roles
- (U) Identify analytical and technical personnel's authorization to touch the data
- (U) Identify how the authorities impact interactions with other roles and the data
(U) (Technical Character): Now that we have completed this part of our road trip, you should be able to:
- (U) Compare and contrast the analytical and technical work roles
- (U) Identify analytical and technical personnel's authorization to touch the data
- (U) Identify how the authorities impact interactions with other roles and the data
(TS//SI//NF) (Technical Character): Now that you are aware of the various roles that support the BR and PR/TT Programs you will move on to your role-specific module that will go into additional detail on topics relevant to your responsibilities.
TOP SECRET//SI//NOFORN
Page 10 of 10