Too Much of a Good Thing?
Open PDFDocument date: 2006-08-10
Type: SIDtoday
Pages: 2
Genre: newsletter
Banner: DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
Classification: SECRET SI
Dissemination: -
NSA's UK Menwith Hill Station finds itself "bursting at the seams" with unencrypted internet data collected from commercial satellite networks. A new initiative aims to "thin out the data we store at site".
COUNTRYSTORE, SKYLAB
People mentioned:
-
Countries:
-
Tags:
data storage, satellite communications, Digital Network Intelligence, data reduction, Menwith Hill, SIGDEV
Identifier:
2006-08-10_SIDToday_-_Too_Much_of_a_Good_Thing
PDF SHA-256:
7563c84796d7055d3c84848dd8d6ae41a280540a2670123d87cd99d83b80910d
My notes
DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
SIDtoday
(U) Too Much of a Good Thing?
FROM: Customer Outreach and Advocacy, Menwith Hill Station (F77)
Unknown
Run Date: 08/10/2006
(S//SI) Menwith Hill's COUNTRYSTORE project looks for ways to make the sorting, storage and
retrieval of data more efficient and effective.
(S//SI) Just over a decade ago, most folks within the intelligence community believed we would
suffer from a dearth of signal data from which to extract SIGINT. They thought the use of fiber
optic cabling would fully replace satellite communications, thus making the intercept of our high-
threat targets more problematic. This, coupled with the increased use of sophisticated,
commercially available cryptography, was viewed as the "beginning of the end" of easily
exploited target communication paths.
(S//SI) Flash forward to where we find ourselves today. The commercial satellite communication
business is alive and well and bursting at the seams with increasingly sophisticated bulk DNI
(Digital Network Intelligence) traffic that is largely unencrypted. This data source alone provides
more data for Menwith Hill analysts to sift through than our entire enterprise had to deal with in
the not-so-distant past. To twist a phrase, it would appear that communication begets
communication.
(S//SI) What's the problem, you ask? More data is a good thing, right? Well, anyone who has
ever spent time on search engines like Google¿ might get a hint at the problem. Accessing too
much data does not necessarily lead to good information upon which to make good decisions (or
in our case, good SIGINT) unless you know what to keep and what to throw out.
(S//SI) How do you sort through the gigabytes of data that we collect on a daily basis and figure
out the best bits to keep that will lead you to better understand or learn about new targets of
interest? We've proven we can't keep it all, and even if we did, we don't have all the tools and
technology in place to help us intelligently sift through the data to support the various types of
development that we would like to accomplish. So what's a forward-looking SIGDEV site (like
Menwith Hill) to do? Using a few familiar colloquialisms, simply figure out a way to "separate the
wheat from the chaff," while making sure you "don't throw the baby out with the bathwater."
(S//SI) This is not a new problem for NSA. However, it is a problem that Menwith Hill has
recently begun committing resources to in the form of its latest SKYLAB initiative known as
COUNTRYSTORE. Although the problem is not new, the signals and data content within those
signals are continuously changing as commercial communication vendors come up with new and
innovative ways of pushing more data through satellites.
(S//SI) The objective of the COUNTRYSTORE initiative is to work with a broad range of SIGDEV
stakeholders and determine a set of "business rules" to thin out the data that we store at site.
By doing this, it will allow us to apply subsequent analytics to this reduced set of data in a more
efficient and effective manner. Once these business rules are discovered and quantified, the
second phase of this initiative will be to codify them in software that will allow this intelligent
data reduction to actually occur.
(S//SI) For more information on this project, or if you are interested in helping, please contact
either [REDACTED] [REDACTED]) or [REDACTED] [REDACTED] . A core team of skilled individuals is
being assembled to tackle this initiative. The team leads would like to hear any "great ideas"
you might have on how to make this project a success.
(U//FOUO) Menwith Hill Station
POC: [REDACTED] [REDACTED])
(U//FOUO) This article is reprinted from Menwith Hill Station's Horizon newsletter, August
edition.
"(U//FOUO) SIDtoday articles may not be republished or reposted outside NSANet
without the consent of S0121 (DL sid_comms)."
DYNAMIC PAGE -- HIGHEST POSSIBLE CLASSIFICATION IS
TOP SECRET // SI / TK // REL TO USA AUS CAN GBR NZL
DERIVED FROM: NSA/CSSM 1-52, DATED 08 JAN 2007 DECLASSIFY ON: 20320108
Published in the Same Report
(10 of 26 documents)
-
APPARITION Becomes a Reality: New Corporate VSAT-Geolocation Capability Sees Its First Deployment SIDtoday [pdf]
This document provides an update to the APPARITION system, which is designed to provide precision geolocation information for VSAT terminals. APPARITION, as contrasted with GHOSTHUNTER, is designed to proactively target and geolocate VSATs and for that information to be populated in MASTERSHAKE. The result is that any location will be able to combine VSAT information with FORNSAT information to geolocate targets.
-
Afghanistan 30 enemy killed (Jan-Feb 2012) [pdf]
Taliban high-value targets in Afghanistan shifted to VSAT-based communications, which NSA and GCHQ analysts in Menwith Hill linked to known phone numbers. This intelligence enabled military operations that killed about 30 enemy fighters.
Marking: TOP SECRET -
APPARITION/GHOSTHUNTER TASKING INFO [pdf]
The document details how the NSA’s and GCHQ’s GHOSTHUNTER and APPARITION systems, based primarily at Menwith Hill Station, are used to geolocate VSAT satellite modems for both real-time operational support and strategic intelligence. It explains tasking priorities, coordination processes, and how geolocation results are shared through systems like Mastershake to support surveillance and capture/kill missions.
Programs: APPARITION · GHOSTHUNTER · SOUNDER · CARD · LADYLOVE · JACKNIFE · MOONPENNY · CARBOY · MASTERSHAKE · TRYST -
Elegant Chaos: collect it all, exploit it all [pdf]
This document outlines a classified project, "Elegant CHAOS," focused on advanced signals intelligence (SIGINT) collection, processing, and analysis using cutting-edge technologies like automated surveys and modems. It highlights goals such as real-time data analysis, collaboration with international partners, and integration with cloud-based platforms to manage massive data. See also the document with notes (by GCHQ): "Elegant-Chaos-collect-it-all-exploit-it-all-plus"
Programs: ELEGANTCHAOS · ASPHALT · ASPHALT-A · ASPHALT-A-PLUS · STORMFORCE · DARKQUEST · TORUS · XKEYSCORE · MHS CLOUD · TURMOIL · TARMAC · ASDF · SLR · POPQUIZ · WEALTHYCLUSTER2 · TRAVELLINGWAVE · BILBOBADGER · DRINKYBIRD · GLOBETROTTER · MASTERSHAKE · REST · TRAFFICTHIEF · VENUSAFFECT · FOGHORN · MATCHMAKER · ROADBED · MOONPENNY · AMULETSTELLAR · CLOUD · WEALTHYCLUSTER · MVR · TINT · IPGEOTRAP · MARINA · PLUS -
Elegant Chaos: collect it all, exploit it all (plus notes) [pdf]
GCHQ/NSA presentation describing ELEGANT CHAOS — an automated system at the Menwith Hill Station satellite interception facility that scores and ranks thousands of intercepted satellite signals by intelligence value, automatically deciding which ones deserve collection resources based on criteria like geographic location, target network hits, technology type and Computer Network Operations interest — built to implement the station's directive to "Sniff it All, Know it All, Collect it All, Process it All, Exploit it All, Partner it All" as collection capacity scaled from 100 signals to a planned 3,000 simultaneous intercepts.
Programs: ELEGANTCHAOS · ASPHALT · ASPHALT-A · ASPHALT-A-PLUS · STORMFORCE · DARKQUEST · TORUS · XKEYSCORE · MHS CLOUD · TURMOIL · TARMAC · ASDF · SLR · POPQUIZ · WEALTHYCLUSTER2 · TRAVELLINGWAVE · BILBOBADGER · DRINKYBIRD · GLOBETROTTER · MASTERSHAKE · REST · TRAFFICTHIEF · VENUSAFFECT · FOGHORN · MATCHMAKER · ROADBED · MOONPENNY · WHIZBANG · CLOUDBASE · APLUS · MAILORDER · CROSSBONES · AMULET STELLAR · MVR · TINT · WEALTHYCLUSTER · IPGEOTRAP · MARINA · CLOUD · PLUS -
GSM tower geolocation [pdf]
This TOP SECRET STRAP 1 note describes DYMO, a prototype GSM-tower geolocation system that combines RUFIS-bis (which demodulates co-channel GSM ARFCN streams per cell-ID) with WHAMI Fast Image (WFI) to remodulate and correlate signals to produce high-quality tower geolocation and matching metadata. The remodulated “synthetic geolocation” improves accuracy and is under development in the NMDC/Midas studies.
-
GSM tower mapping made easier and more accurate with new tool SIDtoday [pdf]
This document details DYMO, a prototype developed at the NSA’s Menwith Hill Station—the agency’s large British base operated in close cooperation with GCHQ—for highly accurate GSM tower geolocation. It highlights DYMO’s superior performance in mapping accuracy and metadata integrity, its extensive operational use across regions such as Iraq, Iran, and Somalia, and its integration with tools like GOLDENEYE and the Integrated COMINT System (ICS) to streamline analysis and intelligence fusion.
-
Ghosthunter and the geolocating of internet cafes [pdf]
This document announces an NSA “R Spotlight” webcast introducing GHOSTHUNTER, a multi-agency geolocation program designed to locate Time Division Multiple Access (TDMA) VSAT Internet access points, particularly internet cafés across the Middle East and North Africa in support of U.S. military operations. By mid-2009, GHOSTHUNTER had successfully geolocated over 5,000 VSAT terminals across Middle East demonstrating its operational effectiveness and integration with broader intelligence efforts.
Programs: GHOSTHUNTER -
Ghosthunter future capabilities (2008) [pdf]
This document indicates that Menwith Hill Station (MHS) provides approximately 99% of the FORNSAT data used by GHOSTHUNTER for geolocating targets, while additional FORNSAT sites can be tapped as needed to cover other regions. Although GHOSTHUNTER offers near-global geolocation capabilities, certain areas remain blind spots where coverage is limited.
Programs: GHOSTHUNTER -
GHOSTHUNTER Goes Global [pdf]
This document announces that GHOSTHUNTER, operated from Menwith Hill Station (MHS), is being used to geolocate terminals associated with high-value targets in Iraq and surrounding Middle Eastern countries. It references a hyperlinked article in the station’s Horizon newsletter for further details, which requires a secure NTS-PKI certificate to access due to its classification. The title suggests that GHOSTHUNTER has achieved global reach.
Programs: GHOSTHUNTER
Related Documents
-
SKIDROWE [pdf]
This document reveals the extensive surveillance capabilities of the NSA's SKIDROWE program at TITANPOINTE, specifically designed to intercept and analyze satellite communications and internet data. It highlights how intercepted data is processed and filtered through advanced systems like XKEYSCORE, which enables real-time intelligence gathering by sifting through massive amounts of digital content, including emails, calls, and internet activity.
Programs: SKIDROWE · WEALTHYCLUSTER2 · WEALTHYCLUSTER · TURNWEALTHY · VPCS · XKEYSCORE · GENESIS · CONTROLAND · ATM · FITBOY · DARKTHUNDER · FIP · METTLESOME · SKYFRAME · PVOICE · XXPY0012 · AGITATOR · STARPROC · SPELLBINDER · BLACKPEARL · BLACKALCHEMY · BLACKGOLD · BLACKFIRE · MONKEYMIND · BCD · EVVIPER · QUANTUM · MISTYPEAK · VALIANTSURF · GALLANTWAVE · SWINE · BLUESNORT · TOSSSWUNG · GNOMEVISION · GNOMEGOGGLES · HIDDENSALAMANDER · TURMOIL · PSC -
2006 European SIGDEV Conference Takes Collaboration to the Next Level SIDtoday [pdf]
The 2006 European SIGINT Development conference at Menwith Hill, UK, showed how "through collaboration, anything is possible". A presentation and discussion on GHOSTHUNTER exemplified this. The joint NSA / Menwith Hill project combines two access programs in "an untraditional manner", yielding results independent accesses could not achieve.
People: Dowd, PatrickThe Intercept ↗ (2019-05-29) -
Write Right: Too Much Redundancy is Redundant (repost) SIDtoday [pdf]
Repost: In the introduction to the 2005 “Write Right” column, the author quotes comedian George Carlin to explain how redundancy in word use is redundant.
Marking: UNCLASSIFIEDPeople: Carlin, GeorgeThe Intercept ↗ (2018-03-01) -
Write Right: Too Much Redundancy is Redundant SIDtoday [pdf]
In the introduction to the 2005 "Write Right" column, the author quotes comedian George Carlin to explain how redundancy in word use is redundant.
Marking: UNCLASSIFIEDPeople: Carlin, GeorgeThe Intercept ↗ (2017-09-13) -
Menwith Hill Internet Challenge SIDtoday [pdf]
Menwith Hill Station now has eight workstations to access the "non-attribution" internet and will soon install 33 more. The first analyst or team to use the new internet capability with significant success will be rewarded with a party in their honor.
Marking: CONFIDENTIALThe Intercept ↗ (2016-12-07)